Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S3 E31: Kelp Restoration on the Great Southern Reef with Professor Prue Francis
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The kelp forests of Australia's southern waters are in serious decline, impacted by rising ocean temperatures, pollution, and overgrazing by sea urchins. Today's guest, Prue Francis, Associate Professor of Marine Science at Deakin University in Melbourne, is part of a team racing to give a kelping hand to these underwater forests before it's too late.
Thumbnail Image: Professor Prue Francis snorkelling. Photo by Stefan Andrews.
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
You're listening to Word on the Reef, diving into marine science on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond, with Tanya Murphy and Brett Woodband. Good morning, everyone, and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver and marine conservationist Tanya Murphy. And joining me as always is Ken's Aquarium's Marine Educator and Fish Whisperer, Brett Goodbairn.
SPEAKER_00Morning, Tanya. Morning, everyone. It's nice to be back.
SPEAKER_02Now, Brett, it's a very exciting time of year. It is. It's been four days since the October full moon. And you know what that means?
SPEAKER_00I do. Oh yes.
SPEAKER_02That's right, it's coral spawning time. We interviewed a scientist about it last season. But for any listeners who aren't familiar, Brett, do you want to tell us what coral spawning is all about?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm going to try and narrow it down to two hours. And it's probably the largest dating event on planet Earth. And it's a really special time for us because the reef talks to us. So basically the whole reef picks the perfect night, so it's more romantic. Full moon, nice temperature, light a few candles, not a lot of water movement, and then she goes off. All the little corals produce the eggs, and then the sperm comes up, they meet up on the surface, they go for dinner, yadda yadda yadda. One thing leads to another. We have those tiny, new little polyps that grow in coral, and it's like an underwater rainbow, isn't it? It's just like these little coloured eggs floating up to the surface. It's incredible.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. And I understand you swam with a bit of coral spider in the city.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I have been very privileged to have been on the bottom. I can always I can remember my first one. I just sat there and sat there and sat there and thought, mm-hmm. Uh maybe they die because I'm looking at them, I don't know what's going on, and then all of a sudden it just went bang. I looked across, and this beautiful staghorn coral started producing these bright pink eggs. And then the neighbors looked at her and went, Oh, it's time. And then all the little blue eggs came out, and then the sperm, and I just took there going, my god, this is incredible. It's really special. But as you know, as divers we don't take out the dive gear down that night.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because it gets on your own.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it gets like that.
SPEAKER_02But it's beautiful.
SPEAKER_00It's like a confetti going off. Yeah, it would have to be one of the biggest reproduction dating nights on planet Earth.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, millions. I don't know how many millions of an unprecedented amount of.
SPEAKER_00You couldn't count it. Well, it's it's so big you can see it from the International Space Station on that. You can see it on the surface. Yep. It's that big.
SPEAKER_02Amazing. But now, on to today's topic. We're heading far away from the Great Barrier Reef to Australia's other Great Reef. Most people don't even know it exists. But the Great Southern Reef stretches more than 8,000 kilometres across five Australian states, supporting thousands of marine species and providing critical habitat along Australia's southern coastline. But the kelp forests that define this ecosystem are in serious decline, impacted by rising ocean temperatures, marine heat waves, and local pressures such as overgrazing by sea urchins. While the Great Barrier Reef has become synonymous with ocean conservation, Australia's temperate kelp forests have received far less attention, despite being just as vital to the health of our oceans. Scientists are now racing to understand, protect and restore these underwater forests. But how do we protect and restore an ecosystem most Australians don't even know exists? Here to take us on a deep dive into Australia's kelp forests is Prue Francis, Associate Professor of Marine Science at Deakin University in Melbourne. Good morning, Professor Francis, and welcome to Word on the Reef. Morning, Tanya, morning Brett. Thanks for having me. Excited.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, oh, we're excited to chat to you. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02It's great to have you on the show. Before we dive into Kelp Forests, can you please tell us a bit about yourself and your background?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, sure. So probably the listeners up in Cannes are not going to know which town I grew up in, but it's a little country town in Victoria called Kayabrum and it's sort of northern up near the Murray River and roughly about four hours from the nearest coast. And so growing up in this area, my love of water started by spending all this time on the Murray River, and I always like to say that the only wave I was catching back then was in the drop bar of an irrigation channel. So I didn't have much experience of being in near the coast. So I would sort of say that I followed the love of water and travelled downstream to study marine and freshwater science. And it was during that time that I experienced my first surf wave and also got to snorkel in a temperate marine environment and just absolutely fell in love. And that really pivoted my freshwater love to seaweeds and to end up having a career with salty water, I guess. And from there I actually doubled in a bit of high school science as a teacher and then also used to live up in Council, so not far from Cannes. And like you, Brett, I was an educator at an aquarium. So that's a few aquariums.
SPEAKER_00Were you?
SPEAKER_03Yes, yep, yep. And then as life has it, came back to Victoria and came back working with my true love on Kelp and Ocean Literacy, which is really about helping people like the kid I was living far from the coast and helping them to feel connected to the ocean and understand that we all depend on the ocean no matter where we live.
SPEAKER_00Wow. That's a resume. So you're working at you used to work at Reef HQ.
SPEAKER_03I did.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Okay. That's awesome.
SPEAKER_02All right. Now, after all my years diving in the tropics, I know my way around a coral, but I am absolutely kelpless when it comes to the subject of kelp.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, me too. What she said. Oh, well, I hope you've got some more coming up. So Well, hopefully I'll be kelping you get through this.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. We can't kelp ourselves. We're just pun at it.
SPEAKER_00Sorry, Ken.
SPEAKER_02We do apologize. So what exactly is kelp and what's so special about it?
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so kelp, I think often we refer to it as underwater plants. So it does look like a plant and it certainly acts like a plant. So it needs the sun to photosynthesize, it creates oxygen, but in fact it's actually a large brown algae. So it has no roots like you would see in a terrestrial plant. And instead of that root system, it has what we call a hold fast, which does exactly what that name suggests. It holds fast onto the rock. And instead of roots being able to take up nutrients from the soil, it absorbs the nutrients straight from the water.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, wow. And so anyone out there who knows a tiny bit about taxonomy, we talk about the animal kingdom, the plant kingdom, there's the fungus kingdom. So those are the main three. But the kelp is actually outside of that. It's something even more it's algae, it's more primitive even, but also very advanced.
SPEAKER_00Ziz a bit like our Zizentalae, aren't they? They're neither algae or plant. They're a proteist. Somewhere in the other. Yeah, protists. Sorry, we just infiltrated your kelp with our coral again. Sorry, we'll stop it. It's all about the kelp today, all right?
SPEAKER_02I hope we got that right, because we're actually just musing about things that we're not experts on. So kelp. What types of kelp are found in Australia?
SPEAKER_03Well, we do have several species of kelp, but probably the most too common ones that people have either seen in media or heard about is the giant kelp, which is that real large towering forest that can grow up to 50 metres, and it has this floating canopy at the surface. So you can actually see it from space, you can be able to track it through easily using drones. But then we also have another one which is a lot shorter, it's called the Golden Kelp, and that grows roughly to our knee or waist high. And this particular one is the one that's most widespread along the Great Southern Reef and the species that I have an interest in and work with mostly.
SPEAKER_02How fast can it grow? Because I understand that kelp can grow really, really fast.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it certainly can. And I have seen some quite interesting stats out there over my space of my career. And it really depends on the conditions of the ocean, but also on the species. And so looking again at these two different types, the giant kelp, which can, as I said, can grow 30 to 50 metres tall. So that means it does grow quickly as well. So if it has the right conditions, it can grow as much as 50 centimetres per day.
SPEAKER_02Half a metre per day, folks. Stop it. I knew it was crazy. Something crazy like that.
SPEAKER_03You can almost watch it while it grows. Watching it right. Yeah, yeah, exactly. Except the golden kelp, since it's a lot smaller, there has been studies that have tracked it to, I guess, a few millimetres per day, which is still quite a lot, but certainly not as big as the giant kelp.
SPEAKER_02Can you imagine the scientist who had to calculate how fast the giant kelp grows? Their job was literally watching kelp grow, watching C.
SPEAKER_00If you went for a dive and you swam away from the kelp that was near the boat and you was you were diving for an hour and came back. Yeah, where the hell's the boat gone?
SPEAKER_03Because a different a different individual.
SPEAKER_00Wow, that's blown me away. Impressive.
SPEAKER_02Oh, they grow up so fast. So fast growing, which means they're really good at capturing carbon and carbon storage, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's correct. And they have lots of benefits to us. So the carbon has been one and certainly one that has gained interest across the science community, but also in the aquaculture community at looking at ways that we can farm more of these species to capture some of that carbon that we have in the atmosphere. And that science is still very early, so we still don't really understand the role that it plays, but in general speaking, kelp and seaweeds do have that ability to capture that carbon.
SPEAKER_02What commercial uses are there for kelp? I saw online that kelp-based ingredients can find their way into all kinds of things, even ice cream.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right. And I was actually going to start with by saying that I'm 100% confident that both of you probably used a kelp product today without even realizing it.
SPEAKER_01Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_03And it is linked to the ice cream. So kelp actually has a product that you can get from it called alginate, and that's the product that you would see in a lot of household products like your ice cream. But also, which I'm hoping is what you've used today is toothpaste. You would often find alginate in toothpaste.
SPEAKER_00So if you have cleaned your teeth, you've likely cleaned it with kelp. Kelp cleaned my teeth this morning.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, hopefully.
SPEAKER_00That's so cool.
SPEAKER_03Beyond alginate, we also would see kelp or other seaweeds being used as agricultural fertilizer. So it's really good to help grow our veggie garden if anyone's out there trying to spruce that along. But also we see it now in a lot of our foods, particularly we're seeing more of it in the Western cultures now. And then using it for health and medicines and also for beauty, I've got a moisturizer that has kelp in it. So I feel like I'm glowing with kelp every day now.
SPEAKER_02The best product for your mermaid skin.
SPEAKER_03Exactly.
SPEAKER_02Rub kelp on your face. And why else is kelp really important to protect?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I mean it's important for us because I guess we can extract these products from it, but also people that live along the Great Southern Reef, which is 8,000 kilometres in length, and there's about 70% of us that live along this coastline. And so it's really important for us from a fishing and tourism value, but also from an underwater perspective. We sort of say that the kelp is the foundation species of the Great Southern Reef. So it's providing habitat and it's providing shelter, foods, supports this amazing biodiversity that is similar, well on parallel to the Great Barrow Reef. And as we've mentioned before, it draws that carbon and can take up nutrients or excess nutrients from the water as well. So it actually can be a filter similar to what the mangrove systems and seagrasses do up on the Great Barrow Reef.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so the Great Southern Reef, we've talked about it on the show last year with a guest from the Great Southern Reef Foundation, Stefan Andrews, and learned about it then. But for any guests who aren't familiar, what is the extent of the Great Southern Reef? Which states does it start and finish in?
SPEAKER_03It's pretty big, so 8,000 kilometres stretch of coastline. So it starts from, I guess, the border of New South Wales and Queensland, extends down that coastline into Victoria, down into Tasmania, South Australia, and into Western Australia up to about Cal Barry, where it stops. And I think a lot of people, when you say it's this cult forest, it's not technically a continual cult forest along that stretch of coastline, but it's the kalt forest and the temperate rocky reefs that connect that system through those different states. And it's the biological, chemical, and physical processes that's driving those systems and different habitats that you find along there. And so we say that these kelp forests are the building blocks of that great southern reef system, similar to what corals are the building blocks of the Great Barry Reef.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and there's heaps of endemic and very rare marine life which live on the Great Southern Reef, right? Like Australian sea lions and leafy sea dragons and all kinds of things, which I haven't actually been lucky enough to dive with yet.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, we'll have to. So the weedy sea dragon is another one which is found here in Victoria. In fact, it's Victoria's marine emblem. It's a little bit of our claim to fame. And that is endemic to this area down here. And it's got a soft spot for seaweeds. So we've got a really high endemic rate of seaweeds, particularly for the red seaweeds, where there's upwards of 70% that are found here on the Great Southern Reef and nowhere else in the world, which I just find is phenomenal. That seventy percent is is specific to this region, and just because of that really cold nutrient water that we've got coming up from Antarctica, it has that huge rich biodiversity.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, which might be why slightly less famous for diving because of that cold water from the Southern Ocean. Yeah. When I first thought about getting into diving, I was thinking of tropical palm tree-lined beaches, and I guess that's why I'm on the Great Barry Reef.
SPEAKER_00But it's the same here.
SPEAKER_02I have done some temperate diving and now I understand why it's worth it. Just put the wetsuit on, you're gonna see amazing things in amongst all that kelp. Yeah, so I have actually not really been diving in a kelp forest. But Professor Francis, I guess you have. What's it like diving on these kelp forests? Have you had some interesting animal encounters with sea lions or any of these other interesting animals that live down there?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, I'm similar to you that I've done a few dives when I was up in Townsville and Brett when you were describing the coral spawning before, I've seen that once in my life. And whilst I remember all the gametes in the water, my biggest memory were the worms in my ears. Yeah, um, invertebrates running around trying to eat all the coral spawns.
SPEAKER_00You do end up with a few hitchhikers on you when you get out. Absolutely.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yeah. But for us, you know, typical dive for me in my local area, seeing the golden kelp would be imagine that winter sun coming through the ocean. You see these golden blades shimmering as they're swaying with the current and fish darting in and out of the foliage, and then these little snails are clinging onto deer life, onto the blades, and then down below you've got this mix of colours of greens and browns and reds of all those seaweeds that live in amongst that kelp forest. And then there's odd abalone, which we love to fish for, and lots of people like to eat down here that would be hiding in rock crevices. We've got urchins and lots of different other invertebrates and sponges that bring life and colour to this area. But my favourite, not the sea lion, is I always like to see a banjo ray. If you can imagine a banjo catar, it's kind of similar, sort of shape to that, and it cruises down the bottom and always comes up to say hello to you, or you just will snorkel over the top of it, and it just you know it gives you a bit of an eye stare and making sure you're not a threat. But it's a lovely charismatic creature that I always like to see when I'm snorkeling.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, wow.
SPEAKER_00It's like an underwater wonderland, isn't it? I always have this vision of diving through the kelt forest with the sun coming in from behind it, and the little seal come up and say g'day and swim off and hang out, mate. Yeah, good. Just magical. But I'd need a dry suit or a submarine.
SPEAKER_03But I have that's with a hood too as well. So but the more thickness you go, you've got to have more weight, and that can get a bit tricky. So there's trade-offs.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So you're based in Port Phillip Bay, which is on the coast of Melbourne. Have you dived with the little penguins, which Port Phillip Bay is famous for?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so we do have a little penguin colony at St. Kilda Breakwater, which is right in Melbourne. And when I've been snorkeling up that end of the bay, I've seen one penguin in my time, which was actually off Williamstown, which is quite a little bit away from the St Kilda Breakwater. And this particular penguin, it was mid-mulch, so it was sort of a grey looking. And it was so charismatic. It was doing zoomies around chasing all these bait fish. And it became quite the talk of the community there because this particular location, there's a lot of people that use this area for fishing, for swimming, for snorkeling, and it was kind of a famous penguin that it was getting captured on film, and you could even spot it from not even getting in the water. You could stand on the halfway there and we would be able to see it coming up to the surface. So that was a really special experience for me, being snorkeling in that water and having this penguin runner zoom in around you.
SPEAKER_02That's amazing.
SPEAKER_00So cool.
SPEAKER_02I'd love to I've never swum with a penguin. That would be awesome to see. Did everyone have a name for it?
SPEAKER_03I'm not sure if there was a particular name given to it. No.
SPEAKER_00I'd probably end up calling him Skipper from Madagascar or Rico. Yeah, it's pretty cool.
SPEAKER_02It's great when people come up with a name for the local pesky animal. Like, is it Neil the Seal?
SPEAKER_00Neil the Seal, the big elephant seal that's been crushing everything in its path.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, where's that based?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's South Australia, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02Maybe yeah.
SPEAKER_00Was it South Oz, that big guy that was all over Facebook and everything because he was squashing telephone boxes and anything in his way?
SPEAKER_03We had a similar elephant seal come up close to where I live and it came up to the local service station and it says it's so big, it actually crushed the glass panelling into the shop, and we all sort of joked that it was trying to grab an ice cream because it was a really hot day.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, plus ice cream has kelp in it.
SPEAKER_00Oh, there you go. Stop putting kelp in ice cream and the elephant seals won't come and knock the joint off.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, very true. Maybe something in that.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_03Not very subtle.
SPEAKER_02Sounds like an amazing place to jump in the water. Why is there a need for the kelp restoration project that you're working on?
SPEAKER_03So in parts of Port Phillip Bay, we've had some losses up to 90% of the golden kelp. And so the main culprit for us here in this local area is a native animal, the purple sea urchin. And we have rough estimates that we think there's 150 million adults in the bay, and double that if we're going to include the juvenile. So that's a lot of urchins taking over. And so in 2022, we partnered up with the University of Melbourne and Parks Victoria and the Nature Conservancy and did a 26 hectare restoration trial at two of the marine sanctuaries that we have in north of the Bay.
SPEAKER_02Wow. Okay, so the urchins are the main problem in Port Phillip Bay. What's the reason for this urchin outbreak? You've got 150 million urchins, and even though they're a native species, that's way more than what they should naturally be, and they're just eating all the kelp. What's causing the urchin outbreaks?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, they are native, but over time what we've seen in Port Phillip Bay specifically changes in water quality. We've gone through a big drought period as well, which changed the way that our land was operating, less rainfall, which changed the water quality that was coming into the bay there, coupled with the reduced in the natural predators in the bay that would eat these urchins. So put those two combined over a space of, let's say, 20 or 30 odd years, the urchin numbers just exploded. So they remained unchecked. The water quality was great conditions for them to reproduce, similar to what you'd see with coral splings and millions and millions of reproductive babies were taken over, and so they just were mowing the areas where there was kelp forests. And when you do see these urchins in these big numbers, we call them an urchin barren. And so some of the areas here have actually been persisting since the 1970s. And sometimes naturally we would see that urchin barren revert back to a macroalgal kelp forest state, and we don't have to intervene. And we see that commonly would happen off the coast of California, for example, but here specifically for our local area, we just haven't seen it revert back naturally, and so that's was the reason for us as a collective group to come in and do something about it and reduce those numbers.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's interesting. So the main problem in Portville Bay, you said it's a purple urchin, is that right?
SPEAKER_03That's right, yeah.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, because I think we heard about is it the long spine urchins that are yes, that's right.
SPEAKER_03Different species. We also have that one here in Victoria, but it's more on the east coast of Victoria and hasn't quite yet entered into the bay. That could be our future problem, but at the moment we've got this particular species that's just booming in numbers and overgrazing.
SPEAKER_02Wow, so global conditions are just affecting multiple species of urchins. It's a good time to be an urchin if you want to overpopulate the planet. They're taking over, you know. The zombie films almost had it right, but it's actually the urchins that are got. come. Yeah. Yeah. Oh goodness. So a big factor in that is climate change because the urchins are moving south of their former range and invading new areas. Yep, following temperature. Yeah, because the water's getting warmer. So they're kind of like you brett. They wouldn't normally go there because it would be too cold for them. And as the water got away.
SPEAKER_00If it starts snowing in cans tomorrow, I'm going Cape York. I'm just going north.
SPEAKER_02Well, it's getting warmer, so you'll be like the urchins. You could start being more comfortable further south.
SPEAKER_00There you go. I'll head south.
SPEAKER_02Small winds. So interesting that there's a there's this other type of urchin that's causing an issue. We've heard about how marine heat waves, which are increasing because of climate change. Can also zap kelp. Is that right? In other parts of Australia?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right. And certainly the same is the case here in Victoria. It just hasn't had the impact that we've seen in other areas, particularly off Western Australia, where there was a hundred kilometre stretch of coastline that was completely wiped out of kelp summer 2011 marine heat wave. And so we are getting predicted of these more extreme heat waves happening over summer, and similar to the impact that we see on the Great Barrel Reef with those coral bleaching events, the same with Kelp is that they are very temperamental to changes in water temperature. They love the cold. So any persistent hot summer periods that we're getting is just too much stress for them. And so they're having that, I guess, localized effect after a marine heat wave where we are seeing it disappear and then the resilience of it trying to become, even though it can grow fast, it can't grow if the conditions aren't well, you know, recover back to that cold water. So we are seeing that slight increase in water temperature through time. And you know, there is that concern of where are we going to see this decline in kelp from those northern range tips of the Great Southern Reef start to condense down into the Tassie sort of region where the water is a bit colder. So it there is lots of different stresses, and the main one is that temperature driving change through time.
SPEAKER_02That's a real illustration of the public image deficit that kelp forests have. Everyone around the whole world hears about coral bleaching events on the Great Barrier Reef when there's a marine heat wave. But most people wouldn't know that 100 kilometres of kelp forest was wiped out by a heat wave event in 2011. So Yeah, it's a similar thing. 100 kilometres of kelp forest, that's a whole habitat for all the animals that need to live there. They've got no home now, they don't have anywhere to hide.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's just the beginning.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and down in Tasmania, 95% of the giant kelp has completely disappeared. So that's massive.
SPEAKER_02Tragic. Yeah, especially because it is a popular diving location. And I have friends who did go diving there, and I guess they went diving in the five percent that's still remaining. But yeah, it's just uh 95% gone. It's really scary. Yeah. But today uh we're here to talk about restoring specifically the golden kelp in Port Phillip Bay. So what methods are you using to try and do that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, so this particular trial that we did, we used a few different methods because it was a trial. We just wanted to try different methods that were known out there. So the first one was growing kelp on cotton twine, so twine that you would buy from bunnies. Another method we used was going to a healthy population and taking an adult and transplanting that to the restoration site. And then the third method was a technique called green gravel, which it sounds fancy, but it's exactly what it sounds like. It's basically small rocks seeded with the baby kelp, and then their idea is to then scatter it from the boat. So they were sort of the three three methods we trialled and looking at what the success was across those three different methods.
SPEAKER_02So before you can plant kelp back into Port Phillip Bay, you have to cull the urchins that are there, right? And clear the area, make it safe for the baby kelp.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right. Yeah. And so to do that, I mean there's two sort of ways that can happen on its own. So we do have a commercial urchin fishery in Port Phillip Bay, so they do go out and have a specific quota that they can collect urchins for. But in the areas that we were working in were marine sanctuaries, so there's no commercial fishing quota in these areas. And so the other option for us is to then cull these urchins, which is done through a scuba diver going underwater and smashing them with a hammer, which that sounds quite dramatic, but it does then create food for other marine life in that area. And the idea is that we weren't trying to remove every single urchin in these places because as I mentioned earlier, it's native. And so we aim to remove them down to a density where there's only two of them per square meter. So that way kelp can recover and urchins can also then coexist. We want them to be there, they're part of the macro or kelp forest, and so making sure that they're just reduced to the numbers that they can have that coexist in nature.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, absolutely. Professor Francis, we've been talking about the methods that you're using to try and restore the golden kelp in Port Phillip Bay. How exactly do you grow kelp? Do you go and snip off some leaves and put it in a jar? How would you go about it?
SPEAKER_03Well, it's uh I guess I can probably start from the start, which it has a very similar event, similar to the coral spawning that we were mentioned about earlier. And so I like to say that kelp has its own version. And so a mature kelp will actually release millions of microscopic swimming spores into the water. And it doesn't happen at any particular time of the year, you don't have to wait for the full moon at this time of the year, it could be all through the year. So, what we can do in the lab is collect that reproductive tissue and induce it and manipulate it so it can release those microscopic spores for us. And then those particular spores can grow into tiny male and female gametocytes, and we can put them on pause under red light, a bit like a seed bank. And we call it in the kelp world a living library or a biobank. And so when we're ready to plant, we use those gametocytes in that biobank to switch to white light, so it goes from red to white, and that white light is enough for them to start to reproduce. And so for about four weeks after that, we then have baby kelp, or we like to call them kelplings, and they're roughly a few kilometers in cute.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's that's awesome.
SPEAKER_03I know. I that's my only pun that I have. That's so cute.
SPEAKER_00Suddenly they became really, really cute little baby kelps with their little nappies on.
SPEAKER_02They're so kelpless.
SPEAKER_00Oh they're not kelping.
SPEAKER_02You guys are really good at that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well, we've had a bit of practice.
SPEAKER_02We're bad for it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah, so I saw some videos of how you keep the kelp reproductive spores in a what looks like a cabinet with only red light inside. And so that stops them from growing until you're ready to grow them. And then you introduce them back to the normal light spectrum, which resembles sunlight, and then they start to grow.
SPEAKER_03That's right. So that red light, they still grow similar to your backyard grass grow. So it vegetatively sort of grows and bulks up, so you get lots and lots and lots of these males and females. But when you want them to become a mature kelp, you then switch it to that white light and away they go. So I would sort of say we've got kelp on tap.
SPEAKER_00So that's an uneducated kelp question. How do you tell the difference between a male and female kelp?
SPEAKER_02Ah, good question. Like inside their nappy.
SPEAKER_00I'm trying to be scientific, Tony. You're not helping. Okay.
SPEAKER_03Male and female gametophyte stage, it's sort of physically they look a little bit different. They're microscopic, so you still need a microscope to sort of see the differences. But the male tends to be sort of more long and gangly, and the female will be shorter and will develop an egg on the end of the actual gametophyte structures.
SPEAKER_00Right, okay. Shorty kelp.
SPEAKER_03Similar to, I guess, male and female. Physically look a little bit different.
SPEAKER_02So how do you plant your kelplets back into the bay? Kelp kelplings? Kelplets? Yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_03So when we're growing them, we'll seed them onto either that cotton twine or the green gravel that I was mentioning before. And so for this particular project, we always used a scuba diving team to deploy them because we wanted to know where we're actually putting them. We had specific plots set up and we wanted to go back two months, six months, twelve months down the track and monitor them through time. So the twine would be unraveled. So if you can imagine the twine's been wrapped around a PVC pipe to grow it in the lab. And when it goes out into the ocean, that pipe will go into the ocean with the diver and they'll unravel that as they're deploying it on the seabed, finding ways to wrap it around different surfaces. And then the green gravel technically would just be thrown off the edge of the boat and away it goes. But for our particular project, we also hand delivered it with scuba divers to our plots so we could then track it through time.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, okay. So if it works, you might scale up to throwing it off the back of boats to try and cover bigger areas over a shorter space of time because it's a lot of work to go and hand place all the gravel, I suppose.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right. And that was the idea of the green gravel particular method, is that it can be scaled up and not need scuba divers to go in the water because that obviously adds adds to the cost of the restoration. The only downfall of the green gravel is in a lab it needs to be laid out in trays, so it actually takes a larger footprint to grow compared to the twine wrapped around that PV sip pipe, which can grow more in that vertical sort of growing as opposed to the horizontal.
SPEAKER_02Maybe you can train storks to fly over and drop off all of the baby kelps into the water.
SPEAKER_03Penguins could do zooming.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, but my mum taught me that's where that's where babies come from. So yeah, I heard that too. So have these methods been used anywhere else in the world?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, the green gravel particularly. So there is an international green gravel action group that we are part of and we meet collectively a few times a year and we share our successes, our failures, and that really helps us to move the science quite quickly because you know restoration is needed now. And so there's different variations of what people are doing with green gravel across the world, whether it's bigger size gravel pieces or the type of gravel that they're using. Their twine method is something that's been used down in Tasmania for the giant kelp restoration. So they are methods that we are known to use. And what we were trying to do is figure out which particular method or is all methods could be used in our localized situation because it seems for restoration with kelp it's very dependent on the location as to what will succeed in that spot based on you know wave dynamics and other stresses that might be pushing onto that system as well.
SPEAKER_02Is there any entanglement risk from putting all that twine down there?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, well the reason why we use cotton twine was the idea that it would naturally biodegrade and not cause a huge issue down the track. And the way that we deployed it were if you can imagine in a plot of say two metres by two metres, it was put in the triangle shape and it was ducked down next to the rock. So there was no way that anything could sort of tangle up with it. In our trial, we actually went back and removed twine that we could remove. But the idea was that is as the kelp grows, the holdfast will grow over the twine and onto the rock. And so you could then remove the twine after it was no longer needed once the kelp was growing naturally on the rock. And the same with the gravel is that we matched the gravel to the rock type of the local area. So that way if it did go off and stumbled off into a rock crevice somewhere, it would still be a natural part of that system because it matched the rock type.
SPEAKER_02Yep. And so you've carried out these first trials in Port Phillip Bay. Are you seeing results yet, measurable results to know whether it's working and how high is the survival rate of the kelp that you've planted?
SPEAKER_03So we started in 2022. So the project was actually a two-year project. So it's wrapped up now, but we are still keeping an eye on the sites, and the good news is yes, it can work. Some of the kelp that we would grew in the lab has now reached upwards of 80 centimetres, which uh is really exciting. And we've documented some of our outplanted kelp being reproductive as well, which is a big milestone because that means the kelp can help produce the next generation on its own.
SPEAKER_02You're a kelp grandmother. Your babies have had more babies. A kelp mark.
SPEAKER_03You know, there's we're also seeing there's a catch to that. So since 2022, we're now four years on that some of the urchins are now moving back into these areas because it hasn't had that ongoing culling. And so the lesson is that restoration isn't necessarily one-off planting, it's more like looking after a garden. So if you plant it and walk away, the weeds come back, it needs that ongoing care and ongoing funding. So it's not that short-term project. So that's what we're grappling with at the moment is looking at it restoration like it is a garden. It just needs this constant, constant care until that stressor is under wraps, particularly in Port Phillip Bay.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_02That's uh constant battle trying to keep on top of all these climate-related and pollution-related issues. But yeah, so when you've been monitoring your kelp babies and you saw how much they were thriving, that must have been really exciting.
SPEAKER_03Oh, absolutely. Our first outplant actually didn't work. The weather that time of the year and the size of the kelp, everything was against us. So the second attempt succeeded. And then when you saw these photos coming in from the dive team after each monitoring trip was just so satisfying. And four years later, when we're getting these photos of 80 centimetre length kelp that are still there from us doing that trial is really satisfying. You feel like you've proven that it can work and there is this concept and this idea, and now it's about taking it to that next level, that next step.
SPEAKER_02And what were the logistics or what are the logistics of carrying out kelp restoration? How much does it cost? How many hours and how many people does it take to restore? Well, you restored 26 hectares, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, yep, that's right. Yeah, so it it's a big question. So urchin management in its own is laborious and expensive because it does require scuba divers. So you could be looking at $25,000 per hectare just to do urchin removal.
SPEAKER_01Wow.
SPEAKER_03And then if you're looking at adding that in collectively with growing the kelp and outplanting the kelp, and depends on what method you use, of course, and how much diving team you have, it can be anything from $35,000 to $350,000 for half a hectare of restoration. So it's expensive and takes time. So, you know, your team of growing kelp in the lab, you need a team for deployment, you need a monitoring team, it requires boats and divers and permits for all that. Having said that, the silver lining is we've had such a positive community response down here in Victoria, and we're now seeing, and even down in Tasmania, we're now seeing dive clubs that have been trained in restoration methods. So the University of Places is still growing the kelp, but the dive clubs are coming in and deploying the kelp themselves as part of their dive stays as a community, and they're also helping to monitor the kelp after it's been outplanted. So that's a really great way to see how community and scientists can be working together to try and bring those costs down moving forward.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's awesome. One big team.
SPEAKER_02Amazing. Yeah, exactly. Are kelp restoration projects like this going to be enough to save the Great Southern Reef?
SPEAKER_03I think on its own, no. Given that the Great Southern Reef is so big after and our trial is only 26 hectares. If you put that in perspective of footy ovals, because everyone likes to put things in perspective of footy ovals, that's about a dozen putieovers. I mean, that sounds big to us thinking about it, but when you put that in comparison of the whole 8,000 kilometres of reef, it's not a huge space. And so restoration, I think, buys its time, but also the long-term future depends on the biggest issue of tackling climate change.
SPEAKER_02Yep, absolutely. And it'll be great to see some of the main drivers of climate change, like fossil fuel extractors and miners being taxed at a higher rate to uh pay for some of the damage that needs to be remedied. But at the moment, a lot of it is just the community in their spare time going and helping and volunteering to plant these things and to make this sustainable. Yeah, we really need to get more funding for these projects and stop the problem at the source. And as you said, it's not just something that we can just say, oh well put it in the too hard basket because kelp is producing oxygen for us, it's uh protecting m much of our ocean biodiversity.
SPEAKER_00I guess it's also about education for divers and everyone in this country to realise that we don't just have the Great Barrier Reef, we have the Great Southern Reef. And since I've been starting to talk about the Great Southern Reefs in my coral shows at work, the big deep reef shows, and explaining to them, look, you know, our reef's bigger than Japan, and it's only 2,300 kilometres long, Great Southern Reefs, 8,000 kilometres long. And 90% of the customers just look at you with that stunned look on their face and go, we've never heard of it. But we have now. And we've got such a massive dive community up here that need to know more about it as well. You know, the more people that know about it that go down to visit, and then those funds go into helping restore it and tourism, etc. etc.
SPEAKER_02You know, well that's one value of it that we didn't even quantify yet. We talked about its value for the ecosystem, for the planet, for carbon sequestration, but even for governments and so on who care mainly about economics. It must be of such a huge value to the tourism and fisheries industries, right?
SPEAKER_03Oh a hundred percent. And it's been estimated that the industry down here is upwards of ten million dollars per year. So it is contributing a significant amount to the Australian economy and if it's at threat and those fisheries and tourism is not going to be there because I know with the harmful algal bloom in South Australia, the tourism sector was hit really hard because they could no longer take tourists out to see the giant cattlefish because they weren't there anymore. Yeah, we've got that are at really seen it, their businesses are collapsing. So trying to protect this and be proactive rather than reactive to these issues is what we need.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's such a huge amount of people in Australia whose jobs and livelihoods depend on tourism and fisheries and protecting our natural ocean habitats. You know, if we look after kelp forests and coral, they will provide those services forever, theoretically, you know, rather than just grabbing resources now which are going to run out, and then we won't have anything left if we just destroy everything now. So yeah, we could we could go on forever about the importance of protecting the ocean. It's not just for the fish, it's also for everyone.
SPEAKER_00Kind of things like, I don't know, uh oxygen is a big one. You know, let's call it spade a spade. I quite like breathing.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So you know I enjoy living on a livable planet. Yeah, I'd kind of like being able to breathe good oxygen. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So what can listeners do to help protect kelp forests?
SPEAKER_03Well, I think just what you were both touching on before is just knowing the Great Southern Reef exists. So having this conversation is amazing that it's reaching different audiences than what it would reach down here along the Great Southern Reef. And so, as we know, most Australians have never heard of it and we can't protect what we don't know about. So telling somebody else about it today is a first start. But secondly, why not eat an urchin? So if you come down to Melbourne, purple urchin row is delicious, so you might find it on some of the menus of our amazing restaurants in Melbourne. There's actually urchin popcorn that is quite delicious as well.
SPEAKER_00Uchin popcorn. Sounds spiky.
SPEAKER_03But I think maybe sounds adventurous. And the thing is what you can do wherever you are in the world is acting on climate because warming is our long-term threat to every Celp Forest. And so if you're ever near the southern coast, come and join a citizen science group or a dive club and help join in monitoring the beautiful reefs that we have down here.
SPEAKER_00Well, that's one of the beautiful reasons why we do this show. So the word is out there on Word on the Reef to all our listeners all over the world and Cairns, all our dive buddies and dive family. Do as much research as you can on the Great Southern Reef, get down there, support the tourism, go diving.
SPEAKER_02Yep. Brett's going to find your own.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'll get myself a submarine, but I'll be down. When it's built, I'll head down.
SPEAKER_03I'll have a dry suit ready for my.
SPEAKER_00Well, hopefully that won't be too far away.
SPEAKER_02Speaking of eating urchin, I never have. I mean, everyone do some research before you follow my advice. Don't want anyone to get sick. But I do know that you can just eat it like sushi. You can just crack an urchin open and just eat it on the spot. So with the cost of living crisis, putting food on the table, just go out for a snork or grab an urchin. I mean, check which ones are safe to eat, make sure you know what you're grabbing. But it is possible, isn't it, Purie?
SPEAKER_03And have a fishing permit.
SPEAKER_02Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_03Especially here in Victoria, we need a rec fishing license to collect urchins. But yeah, that's exactly right. We've got a catch limit per day that folks can go out and collect their own urchins and eat them. And also there is a really nice idea that my colleagues at Deacon are working on is urchin ranching, where the urchins that are in these barrens aren't the ones that have been targeted by the commercial fisheries because the row inside is quite small because they're not feeding on the healthy cup forests. So they're sort of reduced to eating, and that means their row is also reduced. And so the idea with urchin ranching is to take those urchin barrens urchins out and put them into an agriculture facility, feed them up with an amazing diet that makes them that urchin row fat and delicious, and then use them for export or wherever they might end up in the menus here in Australia. So there's there's solutions that are there that have been proven. It's just now a matter of putting those solutions into play.
SPEAKER_02Wow.
SPEAKER_00Good advice.
SPEAKER_02So many, so many innovations to get behind. Professor Francis, where can people head for more information?
SPEAKER_03The Great Southern Reef Foundation website is a fantastic resource to learn more about the reef with lots of wonderful videos and teaching resources. But also, if you want to learn more about the research that my lab is doing at Deacons, you can head to my website, which is www.frufrancis.com.
SPEAKER_02Well, that's all we have for today. Pre Francis, Associate Professor of Marine Science at Deakin University in Melbourne. Thanks for all your amazing work and thanks for joining us on Word on the Reef today. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_00Thank you so much. This chat has really helped us.
SPEAKER_02I love it. And thanks to you, all our listeners, for joining us on Word on the Reef with me, Tony Murphy, and co-host Brett Gulban. This show is broadcast from the Kansapem studio, which is on the land of the Gimoy Wallabaru Dingi people. We'd like to extend our respect to Elders Past and Present. And don't forget to follow us at Instagram.com slash Word on the Reef podcast. That's all for this week. Best fishes, everyone. See you next time.