Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S3 E30: Can Cloud Seeding Cool the Great Barrier Reef? With Dr Daniel Harrison
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Scientists are developing powerful cannons which can spray a fine mist of seawater off the back of a boat into the sky, helping clouds form to shade and cool sections of the Great Barrier Reef.
But does it work? Are there any side effects? And is this futuristic technology going to be enough to save the reef in the face of worsening climate change?
To help answer these questions, our guest on this episode of Word on the Reef is Dr. Daniel Harrison, oceanographer and engineer at the National Marine Science Center of Southern Cross University. He's leading SCU's world-first research into marine cloud brightening.
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Bacterial Bloom on the GBR
SPEAKER_00Good morning everyone and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver and marine conservationist Tanya Murphy. And joining me, as always, is Ken's Aquarium's marine educator and fish whisperer, Brett Goodband.
SPEAKER_02Good morning, Tanya. Good morning, everyone.
SPEAKER_00Now, I don't know what you got up to in the past week, Brett. Did you get up to anything?
SPEAKER_02Okay, here we go. Here we go. Feel free to ask me what I got up to. Okay, Tanya, what did you get up to while between shows?
SPEAKER_00I uh spent a week at Magnetic Island.
SPEAKER_02Oh, isn't that lovely?
SPEAKER_00Did a lot of snorkeling. It was absolutely beautiful. I love Magnetic Island. We have already talked about it on the show. Beautiful spot. Previous guest. It was a really great experience. But something else interesting that's happening on the Great Barry Reef at the moment is a trichodesmium bloom. This is a type of cyanobacteria. Often looks pink. People often mistake it for coral spawn. But coral spawning hasn't happened yet. We've got to wait for a few days after the full moon. But already, for a while, there has been this cyanobacteria called trichodesmium has been blooming across the Grey Barrier Reef. And now this is natural. It often happens every spring. But while I was on Magnetic Island, a lot of the locals said it's the most they've ever seen. So it was interesting to see because they actually had to close Alma Bay, which is just one of the many beautiful beaches on Magnetic Island. Most of the bays were okay, but Alma Bay is just a small bay facing the direction that the bacteria bloom was coming from. So all the bacteria just washed into this small bay.
SPEAKER_02And they just got trapped in it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it was just spooky, muddy, really stinky, it all washed up on the beach and rotted, and it actually deoxygenated the water in that bay, which resulted in a lot of fish and uh stingray and some sea cucumers washing up death. So it was actually really alarming to be there and see that. And the locals were concerned because they did say it's the worst they've ever seen it. It is natural, of course, that trichodesmian does happen on the Great Bayer Reef. But when we posted about it online, we were getting comments all the way from as fun author as Port Douglas down to the Whit Sundays in Yapoon, and people were commenting and saying, Yeah, it's really bad here as well. So it's quite a big trichodesmian bloom this year. And although it's natural, it could be exacerbated by human factors like pollution because it does thrive off phosphate, which comes from fertilizer. The fact that seed surface temperatures are the hottest they've ever been might be. Well, who knows?
SPEAKER_02That might have a massive impact. It might have some impact.
SPEAKER_00Uh a lot of people have been commenting and saying, does this have any parallels with the algal bloom in South Australia? Hopefully not, because that one has been so devastating down there. But uh what we do know is that the algal bloom in South Australia is caused by an algae called Karenia.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_00So it's not the same as our tripod. But the parallels, there are some parallels obviously, in that pollution and climate change is also a factor that influences it. Yeah. And that was definitely the case down in South Australia from what they found.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that was just a catastrophic disaster, that one.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so this one is just one bay or a couple of bays that have been affected. So I still had an amazing time at Maggie Island because there were other bays where it was still safe to swim and not full of toxic bacteria. So I did do that. And I encourage everyone to still go to Maggie and check it out. It's a beautiful place.
SPEAKER_02If I get signed off to go diving again one day, Tanya, we can go diving down here.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Put it on the list. Interesting goings-ons. If there's anyone out there who's seen anything interesting from this trachodesmian bloom, if you've seen any animals being impacted or corals being impacted, feel free to send us a message. You can write to our Instagram.com slash word on the reef podcast or send us an email. On to today's topic.
Introducing Dr Dan Harrison
SPEAKER_00In 2020, on the Great Barry Reef off the coast of Townsville, the scientists did something that has never been done before anywhere in the world. They used a powerful cannon to spray a fine mist of seawater off the back of a boat into the sky, helping clouds form to shade and cool sections of the reef. The aim is to lower water temperatures, reduce stress on marine ecosystems, and help protect the reef from the impacts of climate change and bleaching events. But does it work? Are there any side effects? And is this futuristic technology going to be enough to save the reef in the face of worsening climate change? To help answer these questions, our guest today is Dr. Daniel Harrison, oceanographer and engineer at the National Marine Science Centre of Southern Cross University. He's leading SCU's world-first research into marine cloud brightening. And we're very excited to have him joining us today. Good morning, Dr. Harrison, and welcome to Word on the Reef.
SPEAKER_01Good morning, Tanya and Brett. Thank you very much for having me on.
SPEAKER_02You're welcome. It's going to be a great chat. We're really interested in getting into this one.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's great to have you on the show. Now, before we dive into the topic of marine cloud brightening, can you please tell us a bit about yourself and your background?
SPEAKER_01Oh, sure. I grew up in the northern beaches of Sydney at Narrowbean. I went to school at uh St. Augustine's College, just across the road from the home of the Sea Eagles, Brookie Oval.
SPEAKER_03Yep.
SPEAKER_01I live up at Coffs Harbour now, but I grew up as the eldest of ten kids there on the northern beaches. Well a little bit of a crazy childhood. My dad was a big keen spear fisherman and fisherman, and so we sort of grew up taking holidays all over the place and camping and snorkeling and diving, and so that's really where my love of the ocean came from. So I guess that led me originally I started doing engineering at Sydney University and sort of a master's and a PhD in marine science and spent a few years working over in the US, in the University of Southern California, uh looking at the big fisheries of the oceans over there, looking at the tuna fisheries, for example, and the pelagic shark fisheries stretching across the Pacific Ocean. Wow. Had some fun jobs.
SPEAKER_02That's a resume.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and so you you mentioned growing up on the coast of New South Wales, and did you get a chance to spend a lot of time on the Great Barrier Reef before you got to this job of trying to protect it?
SPEAKER_01Because we had so many kids in our family, it was a bit chaotic, and we didn't get to travel too far generally, but we did eventually do a big road trip with the whole family all the way up to far north Queensland, and that was the first time I went to the reef, and it was just amazing. I absolutely fell in love and we were kind of lucky. My dad's big boat, the axle broke at Cardwell, and so we were stuck in Cardwell waiting for a new axle for I don't know, I think it was about a week or two weeks. And after the first day or two, my dad was like, Ah, you guys just take the boat, I couldn't be bothered. And so we were going out every day, just us kids in his boat and and snorkeling all over the reef out there diving and you know, pulling up on deserted beaches to have lunch and stuff. Yeah, it was I absolutely fell in love with the reef on that trip.
SPEAKER_00Wow, that's incredible. So you're the eldest of ten, so you were the responsible one.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Uh it depends who you ask.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you must have had a big bus to get the biggest.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's what I was thinking. How big was the car?
SPEAKER_01Well, so we had two Land Rovers and a Land Cruiser. I must have been about 18 or 19 at this time. So I was driving one of them, and we had dad's boat on one, the caravan on one, and the other one was towing the tinny for going up.
SPEAKER_02Oh, the family convoy heading north.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, Grid Australia, a camping trip.
SPEAKER_02That's great.
SPEAKER_00Amazing. All right, and so you're now fast forward two today, and you're leading a program of marine cloud brightening. So let's
Cloud brightening origins & rationale
SPEAKER_00dig into that. How did the idea of cloud brightening originate?
SPEAKER_01Well, so so it wasn't originally our idea. It's been around for around 35 years or so now, and it originated because when we started observing the oceans with satellites, the clouds over the oceans, scientists noticed that there there was these streaks of bright clouds, and it turned out that these streaks of really bright clouds that we never knew were there until we started looking with satellites were from ships crossing the ocean, and under the right atmospheric conditions, the extra little particles coming out of the ship's exhaust are acting as cloud condensation nuclei. So these microscopic particles floating around in the air. When a cloud forms, each droplet needs to form on one of those. Because when these ships were going past, we were getting these long lines of really bright clouds by adding these extra seeds for the cloud droplets.
SPEAKER_00So fascinating. So boats are leaving what resembles condensation trails as they spray up sea spray, and that's creating clouds behind them. It's it really interesting.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, in the case of boats, it's coming from the particles in the exhaust stacks, but a lot of the natural particles that are there for the clouds to form on are sea salt. So when the wind blows on the ocean and you get all those little white capping, tiny little droplets are spraying off of that, evaporating, and the salt crystals are getting mixed up through the atmosphere to seed those clouds to allow them to form.
SPEAKER_00So, Dr. Harrison, why was it decided to start this program of investigating marine cloud brightening? Why do we need it?
SPEAKER_01I guess everybody'd be pretty aware of the challenges facing the Great Barrier Reef over the last 10 years or so where we've had six mass bleaching events, and looking forward, we really expect these to sort of continue to increase in both their severity and their frequency. We've we've reached a kind of a crisis point, I think, for the trajectory of the current coral reef as we know it in this particular uh if you look over geological timescales. We we had a very interesting talk last week in my oceanography course from Dr. Jody Webster at Sydney University, who's looked at the entire history of the Great Barrier Reef over millions of years, but in its current form it's it's really facing a crisis just due to the ocean heating up from climate change.
SPEAKER_00Yep, and we are looking at a high probability of bleaching this February and March coming, unfortunately. It is there is significant bleaching happening in Baja California in Mexico right now. And that's because the northern hemisphere is just coming out of their summer. But as we move into our summer, there is a high probability according to the predictions. Um I don't like to crystal ball gaze too much because predictions can change, but that is it is quite a high probability that we're going to have another significant bleaching event this summer. So it's something for everyone to sort of prepare for and think about what we can do to contribute, whether that's just start documenting it, raising awareness about it, using our voices and so on. But even though we need to address the root cause, which is Australia's fossil fuel contributions, even though we need to do that, uh the amount of heat stress that is already imminent is something that we we need to also do local actions on. That's my understanding of why there's been so much interest in things like shading.
How does cloud brightening work
SPEAKER_00And so, Dr. Harrison, what actually is marine cloud brightening that you're doing and how does it work?
SPEAKER_01So the idea essentially is that when a cloud forms, each droplet it needs one of these little particles in the atmosphere to form on and over the ocean. Typically, about half of those are made up of salt crystals coming from the water, and the other half are uh come from phytoplankton in the ocean that produce a chemical called DMS, which then goes on to form sulfur-based particles in the atmosphere that each cloud droplet can condense on. It's quite amazing. There's a great video from a colleague down in Antarctica, and the air down there has so few particles that they take a steaming cup of coffee outside and there's no steam, and then somebody nearby lights a little cigarette lighter, and the particles that are coming from the combustion of the gas in the cigarette lighter make the steam appear, and so they're able to turn the steam on and off by supplying particles. So that's that illustrates how you can't have a cloud if there are no particles in the air.
SPEAKER_00That is so blown my mind. I think we learned back when we had an interview with Stephen Gill, he was talking about how the coral reef itself generates rain clouds with things that it releases, and also the rainforest as well.
SPEAKER_01So that's that same chemical DMS corals produce it as well, and so that sulfur that the corals produce in the water, it's a gas, it goes up, comes out of the water, and it forms particles in the atmosphere that allow cloud droplets to form.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, which is why you're you often look off the coast, you know, you're standing on the beach and you look out and you see a row of puffy clouds just sitting above the reef. So they've sort of formulated their own shade. Isn't that amazing? Nature form forming its own umbrella, but of course now it needs a helping hand, I suppose.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so I mean the other reason that occurs is because the water on top of those reefs warms up, and so that gives you another key ingredient that you need, which is an updraft. So clouds form when air is rising up, and then as they lift, the temperature drops as you go up in the atmosphere, and so that forces the water vapor, which is a gas in the air, the humidity, to try and come out of being a gas into a droplet, and that's when they need those seeds for that droplet to condense onto. But there's you know, it just so happens that over the reef during summer, when the bleaching tends to be worse, the air coming in onto the Great Barrier Reef, it comes from very remote over the Pacific Ocean a lot of the time when the trade winds are blowing, and so there's very low numbers of those cloud condensation nuclei, those particles in the air for the droplets to form. And so you get clouds, but they're not as bright as they could be. If you have more of those particles, then when the same cloud forms, it forms with a larger number of droplets, and that reflects more sunlight back into space.
SPEAKER_00So it's kind of like a thicker, thicker cloud, like a thicker fog instead of just a light misty cloud.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you can certainly think of it that way. Yes.
SPEAKER_00Looking out the window at the clouds, I'm like, yeah, they look they look moderately bright today. They're gonna be cloud experts now. How does it actually work with the technology that you've invented or gotten a hold of?
SPEAKER_01So this idea has been around for 35 years that you could add extra cloud condensation nuclei, copying this natural process of atomizing seawater that the wind does. And by doing this, you could sort of fight climate change. And most people thought about it over that time period as something you do on an enormous scale, enough to cool down the whole planet by doing it over the major ocean regions. What we're looking at for the reef is quite different. It's the same fundamental idea, but we're looking at whether you could do it intermittently and just over the reef when the reef has a marine heat wave and take some of the edge of that heat off to cool the coral down. And so we've developed over the last five or six years these big water systems based like on a snow cannon, and we take the water and it's it's really it's quite incredible. From one shot glass of water, about 30 mils of water, we produce a thousand trillion droplets per second.
SPEAKER_00That's a very uh fine mist. I'm just imagining. It's a very fine mist. Oh my god. When you have a squeezy bottle and you fill it up with water and you spray your hair or your pot plants with it. It's just basically it's just doing that, right? But just at a much finer level.
SPEAKER_01Yep, exactly. Yeah, there's no other ingredients, it's just seawater. But when that seawater evaporates after you spray it, the droplets are so small that the salt crystal that remains is is nano-sized.
SPEAKER_03Right.
SPEAKER_00I had no idea that a salt crystal could become so light that it could float up into the clouds. We're learning so much today. Mind blowing.
SPEAKER_02Okay.
SPEAKER_00So we've got salt in the sky, but then oh, so many questions. Like when you get salty rain, does that not ruin things on land? You know, you don't really want salt water falling on your garden.
SPEAKER_01So it's one of the really interesting things is that a lot of the salt crystals that are floating around in the atmosphere are actually much, much larger than the ones that we're making. And so even though the number that we're producing is is really quite high and it can brighten the clouds because you only need a nano-sized salt crystal to act as a cloud condensation nuclei, it's insignificant compared to the amount of salt that's already in the atmosphere. It's like point something of one percent, even if you did it at full scale.
SPEAKER_00Wow, so you so you're using this cannon. Do you just have one or do you have multiple boats with multiple cannons? I suppose it depends when you scale up, because you're in the trial stage right now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so at the moment we're very much still in in the science phase of investigating the underlying technology. Like all of that research over the last 35 years until we came along was completely theoretical. There's been modeling, lots of theoretical studies, but no one had actually gone out and tried to test whether this really works. So we've finished a project that ran from 2020 to the middle of this year. And the goal of that project was to build a system and actually go out and test it and see whether it works. So we've been a single ship, but with two of these cannons on the back, and that's enough to impact clouds in just an area a few kilometers by a few kilometers. And then we've got a research aircraft where we actually fly back and forth through the clouds and then through other clouds nearby to compare them and to see how much we're brightening them and how strong is the effect.
SPEAKER_00Wow. So it's someone's job is to compare how white and fluffy the clouds are. That's really cool.
SPEAKER_02Can I sign up for that?
SPEAKER_00Cloud assessor.
SPEAKER_02Yes, incredible fluffiness scientist.
SPEAKER_00No, it's it's really it sounds like a
Is it practical?
SPEAKER_00fun job. So, how effective is this method that you've been trialing? Did it actually cool down the reef? Did it reverse coral bleaching, or did you measure the sea temperature and find out that it was cooler? How did you measure whether it was working?
SPEAKER_01I'll explain a little bit more deeply. So no, unfortunately at the moment, with just a sort of a single boat and a and a single experiment, uh, we're still just looking at how the cloud physics actually change. You'd need to scale this up significantly before you could start looking at how much the water cooled down or to actually protect corals with it. That's very much where we're headed. But the way it works to actually cool the water down is you need to do it continuously over weeks and months. And what happens is only a very small change to the amount of the sun's energy going into the ocean each day. But when you do it continuously over a summer, you gradually cool that water down. And it works quite well in the case of the Great Barrier Reef. We've modeled all of this but not done it at scale yet. And that's because the water, it's quite shallow, the Great Barrier Reef, right? The average depth is only about 40 meters, and so the water is sort of trapped in there in an oceanographic sense. You can think of it as like a shallow puddle on the beach, and so when it's getting a lot of sun, it heats it up very quickly. If you take away a bit of that sunlight, it cools down fairly quickly because you've got that high resonance water sitting in there for quite a long time and a fairly slow exchange with the rest of the Pacific Ocean.
SPEAKER_00Wow, so theoretically it will need to be done continuously over weeks and months. That raises for me what are the cost and logistics for carrying that out? If you have to be spraying these cannons and I assume using a diesel generator for weeks and months, how does it stack up logistically?
SPEAKER_01Certainly at the moment in the research phase, we do use the power that's just available on the ships that we charter to go and do this, which which does come from diesel generators on board. The longer term vision is then we're doing research on this various ways that you might be able to do it with renewable energy. Even in an absolute worst case scenario, one of these units running for a couple of months a year over the summer, you know, it's probably the equivalent of having one truck on the road for one year or something. And so it is a bit of a trade-off there. Obviously, it we're very interested in trying to find ways to do it with no emissions, but by the same token, it it's something that we might have to move towards over time, just like decarbonising the rest of our fairly energy-intensive systems that we use in the world. How would we do it? So we're doing a fair bit of research into that at the moment. We're sort of concentrating on a on a target region around Cairns that might be the pilot deployment. It's all hypothetical at the moment, but that's a region obviously that there's a lot of activity and a lot of economic activity on the reef, so it's maybe a good starting point to protect. And so that region of about 13% or so of the entire area of the Great Barrier Reef, it looks like you could do that with about 20 to 25 vessels that would go out there and do this over the summer.
SPEAKER_00Wow, 25 vessels sitting there all summer spraying, creating clouds. It's a very, very interesting future to imagine.
SPEAKER_01One of the other things that we're looking into, but it's a little bit harder because it's less targeted, is using ships of opportunity. So people are very interested in whether you could use the waste heat from ships that are already sailing around the world, including up and down the Great Barrier Reef and past the Great Barrier Reef up to Asia. And in that case, you'd maybe get the energy for free.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so what if all the tourism boats put their hand up to create their own clouds? Imagine that, going out on a dive boat, and they're like, Oh, don't mind the sea mist that was spraying into the air. That's just so we can put up an umbrella for you while you're snorkeling. That's so cool. Shade clouds.
SPEAKER_01Could that happen? It's something that we're looking at. At the moment, the tech isn't small enough that you could easily fit it onto a boat that small. Um, but we shouldn't rule it out forever. They'd more likely either be using much larger ships of opportunity, like sort of cargo ships or dedicated vessels at this stage, it looks like.
SPEAKER_02I guess also some of the companies still have big pontoons out there, don't they? So when the dive boat leaves for the day and the pontoon's just sitting out there waiting for the next shift, you could have one on the end of that, pumping it out as soon as the boat leaves to come back to Cairns. Like I think there's still a few big ones out there.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that is something we've considered. I guess it's fairly early at looking at the exact implementation scenarios. We've got people working on that now. And other options are you rather than having dedicated ships, could you have sort of moored pontoons and a workboat that kind of just went around and serviced them and put them out at the start of summer and brought them back in at the end of summer?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, just like a floating station to put a little floating something.
SPEAKER_02And and the cost involved in creating one of these machines, it'd be high watering, wouldn't it?
SPEAKER_01It's certainly not cheap. So the most recent estimates for doing that region of 13% or so of the Great Barrier Reef, uh order a hundred million dollars a year. Right. It's not cheap. No. But you know, the Great Barrier Reef brings in order of seven or eight billion dollars a year to the Australian economy, so it's a good investment when you look at it that way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, just saving her without a cost value is important, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00Yes, it has economic value and intrinsic ecological value, of course. Absolutely. I guess you know, scientists have been shouting about climate change for decades. If governments had to pulled their finger out earlier, we could have averted averted this and uh saved ourselves that cost, but it has got to this point now. We need to invest into protecting it.
Possible side effects
SPEAKER_00Dr. Harrison, are there any side effects or potential negative impacts of this cloud brightening process?
SPEAKER_01I actually find looking into the risks one of the most fascinating parts of the research, and we've been lucky to be working on that quite hard over the last year or so with an independent risk review group that was formed at the Australian Institute of Marine Science. So everybody involved is completely separate to the project, no conflicts of interest, and experts from all around the world covering everything from coral genetics through to atmospheric physics. So there are lots of things that people worry about, of course, and we've been working our way through those and evaluating them. You mentioned one before, which was a really good one actually, because it was actually engagement with the community and consultation with the community where they said, okay, well, we're worried about this salt blowing over the land and potentially causing problems with agriculture or rusting our cars and these kind of things. And so that actually prompted us to go away and do research. Okay, where does that stand? How much salt is it? And we found, as I mentioned earlier, that it's a really an insignificant amount of salt, less than 0.1% of what blows in off of the ocean anyway by mass. But people also worry about things like could it change rainfall patterns? So we've had the CSIRO doing a lot of modelling on that. And so far, when they run the scenarios, they use the same model that the Bureau of Meteorology uses to predict the weather, which some people might criticize. Uh, but it's the best that we've got, and it's sort of independent. We're not building the model, and they can't see any change to rainfall above the noise in the model. So we're pretty safe on that front, it looks like. But we are very actively investigating the risks. I think in interestingly, one of the ones that we sort of haven't been able to put to bed yet is quite an interesting one. And it's the risk if it works too well, and then we're taking this stress off of the corals. Could we be unintentionally robbing them of the ability to naturally adapt their genetics over time to deal with the extra heat? And that's a really tricky one because there's a balance there, right? Their genetics are not adapting quickly enough, it looks like, and so we're seeing reefs around the world degrade. And I think we're probably will be okay on that risk in the final assessment because cloud brightening is far from perfect, right? It's not like you just do it and it's magically removes all of the stress. The clouds are in different places at different times, every heat wave is different, and so it's more about taking off the edge of that stress and allowing more corals to not die to lower the mortality rate, really. And so I think that that one will pan out okay as well, but it's something that we're still looking into.
SPEAKER_00In the future, if this goes ahead off the coast of Cairns, is it going to be sort of a we're gonna go out on the boat and we can't really sunbathe anymore because the whole sky is going to be cloudy?
SPEAKER_01No, that average change to the light is something like three to six percent. So you you would not even be able to notice this unless you were sort of close enough to see one of the cloud brightening machines operating because the spray is so concentrated at the point of release, you can kind of see a mist coming out of the boat. But it looks like that disappears within a kilometer or a few kilometers, but in reality it's just dispersed. And since the individual salt crystals are nano-sized, as soon as it's dispersed a bit, you can't even see it anymore, and you wouldn't notice the change to the clouds either. It's within the natural variability, well within the natural variability of a cloudy period to a non-cloudy period.
SPEAKER_00So you will still be able to see blue sky. It's just invisible particles are there.
SPEAKER_01Yes, which they already are, of course, anyway. We're just upping them a little bit.
Timeline and funding
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. And so when are you hoping this will be deployed if it passes all the approval processes and things?
SPEAKER_01Oh, that's a good question. It depends a lot, I suppose, on the commitment to the project, funding-wise, and how quickly we want to develop that. It's still a while away because we still need to overcome some technological hurdles in scaling up the equipment. We really only have built equipment so far to allow us to test the concepts, and so far that looks incredibly promising. If we decide that we really need this, then we really do need some sort of intense investment over probably a five-year period or something to actually develop the technology to a kind of readiness level that you could go out and start doing it.
SPEAKER_02Well, and is this is this known anywhere else in the world? Like is this your baby? Is this Australia's instigated? Is anyone thinking of doing this anywhere else in the world?
SPEAKER_01It's a good question. So we're absolutely leading the space, Australia and being the first one after 35 years of theoretical research to go out and actually start pushing this forward. But the rest of the world is really jumping to attention now. And actually, right now, since our Australian project just finished in the middle of the year, we're funded at the moment by the UK government for our continuing work right now. They're so interested in this tech.
SPEAKER_02Um, good on you guys.
SPEAKER_01Uh all around the world, the sort of research space into these ideas is really exploding just on the back of our complete and utter failure to do anything serious about.
SPEAKER_00It's a bit embarrassing, like we have where the UK people in in Europe are looking over and going, you guys need some help.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, just let the motherland you give you a little poke.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I'm just thinking the UK's got enough clouds they can lend us some of theirs.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_01So China's just launched a research program, India's in the process of launching a research program into marine cloud brightening, the US has one. It's because other people are also interested in the idea for protecting other ecosystems. Uh there's a lot of interest in whether you could potentially use it in the Arctic to help with the sea ice loss that they're seeing there.
SPEAKER_00Wow. So this is the future, potentially, everyone. And it would be nice to see fossil fuels being taxed at a high rate to help us find this and not let it all fall onto the taxpayers of the UK or or what
How effective will it be?
SPEAKER_00have we? You said it's uh still too early to measure if the clouds that you brighten are cooling the water. But uh if you roll out that program across 13% of the reef near cairns, what difference do you expect it'll make? Do you think it'll reduce the water temperature by a certain number of degrees? Or do you think it'll completely prevent bleaching in that area or just reduce the severity of it? How effective do you think it will be? I mean, it's in the future, but people must believe that it's going to have a certain amount of effect, otherwise we wouldn't be investing in it.
SPEAKER_01Sure. So yeah, we've done the sort of smaller targeted area is starting to think more about the roadmap potentially to implementing this. So we've done a lot more work looking at scenarios of if we actually did it were doing it over the whole reef. And that's research we did with the CSIR a few years ago, and that's all peer-reviewed and published and everything, and it's quite remarkable. It shows that if you did do marine cloud brightening over the whole reef, then it works as well as best estimates of of how well we think it'll work based on what we know. If you also have strong action on climate change, so we modeled it with a Paris-type climate future out to 2070 or something. And under that future, if you add the marine cloud brightening, it's enough to really stabilize coral cover on the reef and help it it actually recovers a ways from where it is now and then stable into the future layout to 2070 or something. But conversely, when we modeled it with a business as usual future, the story was nowhere near as rosy because there's only a certain amount of cooling benefit you can get from doing the cloud brightening, and only a certain amount of stress you can alleviate. And under a business as usual scenario, it helps for a few decades, but climate change obviously just keeps on accelerating under a business as usual scenario. And eventually the benefit that you can have with the cloud brightening is overcome in a few decades' time, and then the reef goes into decline again. So it's a really important lesson, I think, that we learned in that modeling is that it's something that could maybe help us and and buy us a little bit more time to get our act together, but it absolutely does not replace the need to reduce emissions. It could go hand in hand and help us essentially give us a bit more time to get our act together, I'd put it.
Is it a distraction?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. Australia remains one of the highest per capita carbon emitters in the world and is the world's third largest exporter of fossil fuels in general since the reef restoration adaptation program, which is what this marine cloud brightening is part of. Since that was launched in 2020, the federal government of Australia has approved several new fossil fuel projects, including major gas and coal expansions. Is there a risk that marine cloud brightening projects like this could be distracting us from that need to cut emissions and transition away from fossil fuels?
SPEAKER_01Look, I don't think so. This has has kind of, I suppose, been a concern for a long, long time, even going back to sort of adaptation and when people are starting to research technologies to try and remove carbon dioxide back out of the atmosphere. I mean, I think scientists are looking into these options out of desperation, right? Because we can look at the data and we've known about climate change for over 50 years now, and we've had how many international agreements to reduce emissions, and the line just keeps tracking up, right? And so, at least from my point of view, I don't think anyone could argue that the reason that has happened is because we thought some magic new technology was going to come along and save us from having to reduce emissions. It's just because it's such a difficult transition that we need to make to the entire global economy and our entire way of lives that we've been unwilling to make it so far. So I personally, my opinion is you know, anyone that would claim that we can keep emitting fossil fuels because, you know, these technologies like cloud brightening that's only going to take some of the stress off the reef anyway for a kind of limited period of time would allow us or give us an excuse to keep doing so. It just doesn't stack up to any kind of reasonable scrutiny, I don't
Community perceptions & flying sharks
SPEAKER_01think.
SPEAKER_00I know you've been doing community consultation, which we touched on earlier. What has been the general attitude of the community towards the idea of cloud brightening? Because when you first hear about it, it sounds a bit alarming, to be honest, but that's because people might not know what it is. But yeah, what has been the general reaction of people towards this idea?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's it's really quite interesting, isn't it? When we sort of do our community consultation, it is a lot of these new ideas, it is very common that people are sort of skeptical and worried about it, and then once they learn more, and you know, once they understand what's being proposed and why and how it works, their acceptance tends to go way up. But even aside from that, that's through a sort of an actual consultation process. Even aside from that, JCU is part of the research program under the reef restoration adaptation program. They've done two surveys of both the Australian public and of the more local public in the area of the reef catchments. And in both surveys, they found that people are sort of cautiously accepting but really want the research done. I think it's something like 80% of people or more support doing the research or are not opposed to it. I think people want to see the research done and and have all the risk assessments and understand how well it's going to work before they're sort of supporting going out and implementing it, which makes perfect sense. But certainly doing the research is quite overwhelmingly supported.
SPEAKER_00Does anything else get sucked up and sprayed out of those cannons besides water and salt? Could they be plankton or other things getting sprayed out of this guy?
SPEAKER_02More auls.
SPEAKER_00Sharks, flying sharks. Sharks being fired out of the colour. Yeah, exactly. Well, that cloud looks like a shark. Wait a minute, it's getting closer.
SPEAKER_02It doesn't look happy.
SPEAKER_01But um so look, all of this research is obviously done under the very close scrutiny of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority, and they have provisions in our permits so that we have to make sure that we're excluding marine life and everything from from sort of getting sucked up. Plankton, however, uh probably caught in the filters because we have to filter the water quite finely before we can spray it. But I guess the point there is just a very small amount of water. Like the entire system only uses about eight litres of water a minute. So we're talking about an incredibly small amount of water again. Like I said, it's a shot glass of water makes a thousand trillion droplets.
SPEAKER_00Well, we're glad that no sharks were harmed by this project.
First Nations perspectives
SPEAKER_00So I understand First Nations people have been consulted and they're okay with this being done on their Sea Country.
SPEAKER_01Uh, absolutely. We don't do any research on Sea Country without the express free prior and informed consent of traditional owners. But we've also been working very, very closely with them from the beginning. So we have we haven't done a single field experiment in all of those years without involvement of traditional owners in actually doing the research and welcoming us to sea country and being involved with flying drones and operating the sprayers and right across the board doing science back in the labs as well up at Ames in Townsville. So, yeah, look, we've never been refused consent so far, and we work very closely with the traditional owners. And I I think they're really quite supportive of the researchers in what's always been expressed to us, and I I think they like the way that it sort of replicates natural processes, whereby the oceans creating the clouds anyway, we're sort of just enhancing that. And so it's actually some of the other research interfering with life on country and moving corals and things around that they've often expressed a greater concern
How can listeners help & Find out more
SPEAKER_01about.
SPEAKER_00What can listeners at home do to help protect the Great Barrier Reef and our oceans in general? And where can people find out more about this and learn more about it?
SPEAKER_01Sure. Well, I I think the thing we really need is more advocacy, and you guys seem to be doing a great job of that. You know, talk to your local politicians, harass them. You know, we need to take climate change much more seriously than we are. But if you'd like to find out more about marine cloud brightening, where just you can go to www.scu.edu.au forward slash mcb.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, awesome. Sadly, that's all we have time for today. Dr. Daniel Harrison, oceanographer and engineer at the National Marine Science Centre of Setting Craft University. Thanks for your amazing work and thanks for joining us on We're on the Wave today.