Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E35: Muddying the Waters: Deforestation and the Water Pollution Crisis on the Great Barrier Reef
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Did you know Australia has one of the highest deforestation rates in the developed world? About 20% of Queensland's vegetation has been bulldozed since colonisation -- one million hectares in the last three years alone -- mainly for cattle farming. What impact is this having on the Great Barrier Reef, and what can we do to fix it? To find out, this week we're chatting with Dr Maximilian Hirschfeld, Water Quality Campaign Manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society.
Take Action:
- Sign a Submission to strengthen Australia's nature laws to prevent deforestation and other threats to our oceans
- Sign the Petition asking the Australian Government for a Stronger Water Pollution Reduction Plan
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Introduction
SPEAKER_04This is Word on the Reef, where marine science meets adventure. Join Tanya Murphy and Brett Goodvan who will plunge into the wonders of the Great Barrier Reef and explore the mysteries beneath the waves. Good morning everyone, and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver and marine conservationist Tanya Murphy. And joining me as always is Cairns Aquarium's marine educator and fish whisperer, Brett Goodburn. Good morning. Now, Brett, today let's step into our time machine once again. Oh. And travel back 176 years ago, just before the colony of Queensland was founded, and the first farms began to appear in Queensland. At that point in time, the coastline, along what we now call the Great Barrier Reef, is a paradise untouched by bulldozers or flowers. Free from fertilizers, pesticides, and herbicides. Thick forests blanket the landscape, teeming with birds and wildlife. These forests are the filters of the waterways, holding the riverbanks together, preventing erosion and soaking up excess nutrients. There are some sediments of nutrients in the water, especially during the wet season of life, but just enough to keep the nutrient cycle in balance and the waters of the Great Barrier Reef clean and healthy. Fast forward to today. Water quality on the Great Barrier Reef has declined so significantly that the World Heritage Committee has told the Australian government to take stronger action on water pollution or risk the reef being added to the World Heritage in Danger list. And believe it or not, the water quality impacts that we're seeing in the ocean are a reflection of what is happening on land. Yes. Of course, the reef is enormous and there are still many places, especially on the outer reef, where you can dive into water so clear you can see 50 metres, surrounded by beautiful coral gardens. But some inshore areas in particular are suffering severe impacts from polluted water and excessive settlement as a result of land-based runoff. So here to explain what's happening and how we can help fix it is Dr. Max Hirschfeld, Great Barrier Reef Water Quality Manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society. Good morning, Dr. Hirschfeld. Welcome to Word on the Reef.
SPEAKER_00Hey, good morning, Tanja and Brett. I'm really happy I can finally be on your show.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, thanks for joining us. This will be a really good chat, buddy. Thank you.
SPEAKER_04Great to have you on the show. First up, can you please tell us a bit about yourself and your background?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I actually grew up in Munich, Germany, so close to the mountains to the Alps in Europe. And I literally grew up running around through the woods and going hiking with my parents, wearing a little Lederhosen and everything. Oh, Lederhosen. Exactly. So it wasn't until 2008 when I went to the Red Sea to volunteer in a conservation organization there and learned to dive and dove into magnificent coral reefs there and was just blown away, of course. And since then I've been lucky enough to study and work in some really amazing coral reef systems around the world, including in the Indian Ocean, the Red Sea, of course. I spent a number of years in the Galapagos Islands, and I've worked with some really cool critter, also things like uh sharks and rays, sea lions, marine iguana, sea turtles, all of the good stuff, really.
SPEAKER_03Wow, that sounds amazing.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. It's only about nine years ago when I came to Australia to study a PhD at James Cook University up in Townsville, and looking at populations of coral reef associated sharks in the Great Barrier Reef and also in the Coral Sea Marine Park that's off the continental shelf into the Australian Ocean.
SPEAKER_03Wow. Well, that's a resume.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, we get the opportunity to be jealous of almost everyone that we're doing. Yeah, we do. Yep. Wish I could have lived every single one of those lives. Pretty cool. The Galapagos is definitely on my bucket list. It's one of the world's greatest aggregation sites for different sharks like hammerheads.
SPEAKER_03I'll get there one day.
SPEAKER_04It's on our list. You will. It's on our growing and expanding
How Land and Sea are Connected
SPEAKER_04and very expensive bucket list.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Okay, so when people visit the Great Barrier Reef, most of us are really careful not to throw trash overboard or put chemicals into the water because we can see there's a beautiful ecosystem in the waves beneath us, but few people truly understand how our actions on land are impacting the reef. So how is what we do on land connected to the Great Barrier Reef, Max?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah, I guess as you say, a lot of people think of the Great Barrier Reef of something that's out there in the ocean and far away from the coast, looking pristine, clear water. And that's kind of the picture it jumps into mind when you think about the Great Barrier Reef. But yeah, I wanna paint a little bit of a picture here to make us think of the Great Barrier Reef and the entire region as a much bigger connected system. And I think it's interesting how we often say that the Great Barrier Reef is a similar size to some of the European countries like Italy and things like that. It's huge. But I think what's very interesting, yeah, it's giant and very long, of course. But I think what's really interesting here is that the area of the Great Barrier Reef catchment, so everything that includes where water runs off the land or through the soil into our rivers and streams that then ends up in the ocean and in the Great Barrier Reef Lagoon, that whole area is actually larger than the Great Barrier Reef area itself. And there's over 35 major river catchments, and some of them, including the Burdickan River, are over 700 kilometers long and reach more than 350 kilometers inland.
SPEAKER_03Because you got the Mitchell River as well, haven't we? That that can burst its banks 50 kilometers on each side in the wet season.
SPEAKER_02Wow.
SPEAKER_00Massive. Yeah, so incredible areas, and so everything that kind of happens in that area is intricately linked to what happens in the ocean and the Grab Barrier Reef.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you can't throw anything in the air around here without it ending up on the reef, pretty much.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Pretty much, yeah.
SPEAKER_04It all just flows down into the reef. So yeah, so uh weren't you telling me that we have a river here that's got the same volume of flow as the Yangtze River in China, that's famously one of the biggest rivers, I guess, in the world?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so the Burdigen River in the Great Barrier Reef catchment is actually the river with the highest volume of discharge that ends up in the ocean in Australia. And yeah, it's comparable to some of the big, you know, known big rivers in the world. And yeah, just kind of underlines, you know, how much of the stuff from the land ends up in the ocean.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right. And it's also important. I mean, a lot of people don't realise this, and I tell them at work when I do my river shows, is estimated 50,000 times the volume of Sydney Harbour lands in rainfall up on that Gulf Savannah every year.
SPEAKER_04Wow.
SPEAKER_03I mean, that's just a colossal amount of water, isn't it?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it does rain a lot here in the all heads out to the reef.
SPEAKER_03So that's that's why this connection is so important, isn't it? Yeah.
SPEAKER_04So, Max, what are the main sources of water pollution that are ending up
Where is all the Pollution Coming From?
SPEAKER_04in this catchment and ending up on the Great Barrier Reef? And how does each pollutant impact the marine ecosystem?
SPEAKER_00So overall, just in numbers, most of the major pollutants, so sediment and nitrogen pollutant and also many of fertilizers or herbicides, they come from agriculture. And again, to paint this picture, you know, that whole catchment area in the Greatberry Reef, more than 80% of that is under some form of agriculture. So it gives you an idea of the scale of things. So in percentage numbers, yeah, most of the pollutants come from that area.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, and it's also just for our listeners that uh because I hear this quite a lot at work where they say, Oh, you know, you've got to have high nutrient out on the reef, but that's not the case. High nutrient is not good for the coral, it's not good for the reef, is it?
SPEAKER_00No, yeah. So the nutrients in particular, what they do, they can create algal blooms, for example, and just growth of phytoplankton, so microscopic algae that lives in the water column. And what that does, obviously, it blocks out sunlight that can't reach corals, for example, and the corals need sunlight to photosynthesize, etc. And also seagrass, for example. The grape barrier reef has a huge amount of seagrass. The area of seagrass in the grape barrier reef is actually equivalent to what's there in terms of corals. So all of these systems are hugely impacted if there's too much nutrients and you have that algal overgrowth and less sunlight available to those ecosystems. Which again then has this cascading effect to other organisms such as iconic dugongs and sea turtles that really rely on seagrass meadows, for example, as a primary food source. Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Mm-hmm. Yes, we had a really great interview on the show a few weeks back with Dr. Tim Smith, who is doing seagrass replanting and restoration projects near Cairns and Marillion Harbour, because all of the seagrass, pretty much all of it, was wiped out by sediment and flood waters. And then that has the flow on effect to the turtles and dugongs that need to eat that. So the misconception that nutrients are good for the reef. I mean, 176 years ago there was a balance of the right amount of nutrients that the reef needed. The reef didn't need us to come along and pour more nutrients onto it than what it naturally had, and that's unfortunately what's happening now. So you're talking about 80% of the reef catchment is farmland. What types of farming are the main dominant ones?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so mainly sugarcane, especially further up north, and then where it gets a bit dry a bit further down south, we've got a lot of large cattle farms. So those are the primary ones, but then there's a lot of horticulture coming up, including macadamia, avocado farms, etc. But in terms of size and area, definitely the cattle and sugarcane is sort of the two primary ones.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, look, farming's really important to Queensland and we love our farmers. That's how we get our beautiful fruit and veg and food. But I suppose it's just the way that farming has historically been done and how we can do it better is what needs to be looked at. And so there's various inputs from farming. There's obviously herbicides, glyphosate, there's pesticides. But the big one that you find is nitrogen fertilizer. That's the biggest pollutant on the Great Barry Reef, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so both I guess nitrogen from the overuse of fertilizer that gets flushed out into the reef is one of the big ones, and then also sediment, which is practically just loose soil that gets washed off into the rivers and streams and ends up on the reef. So those are the two big, big ones that have changed very significantly over the last couple hundred years due to the development, also. And yeah, as I said, it's also what we've done over hundreds of years practically, and how we've changed the landscape. So it's not only what a single farmer is doing right now on their land, but it's also how we've changed the landscape so they can't really filter some of the pollutant before they actually end up in the waterways.
SPEAKER_04Yes, we've got a lot of historical issues that we have to fix. So some chemicals that were used in the past, even if we stop using them now, it's going to take a while before they sort of make their way out of the system. Some of those chemicals are known as forever chemicals, aren't they? So we've got a lot of fixing up to do from the things in the past. So I know there are some types of chemicals that are allowed to be used in Australia, which are actually banned in Europe, like neonicotinoid pesticides. They're banned in Europe because they're killing all the bees, which we need to pollinate our our farms. But those are still allowed in Australia. And yeah, I think there's various other chemicals like glyphosate is limited in some places of the world, and I know that it's still allowed in a lot of areas of Australia, but as you say, erosion and nitrogen fertilizer are the biggest ones. Dr. Hirschfeld, can you tell us a bit more about uh erosion and sediment impacts?
Australia's Dirty Deforestation Secret
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so sediment is one of the other big pollutants, and of course, if you think of sediment, it is ultimately soil, different sizes, etc. So it can be very fine, it can be a bit more coarse. But the idea is that it does naturally occur, of course, on our land and in our rivers, and some of it also in on the reef, but not in the volume that it's currently ending up in those systems. And so what that does it primarily comes from erosion, which is also because we have cleared too many vegetation from forests and particularly vegetation along our rivers and streams. Yeah, estuaries, mangrove areas, even far upstream inland on rivers and streams that stabilize the riverbanks, all the roots stabilize the soil, and so there's much less run-out of that earth into the reef ultimately. But we've changed a lot of that, and there's some efforts to restore these systems, which is great, but it's not going to be enough if we don't speed it up and also just make sure we're not clearing any of these really critically vegetation. And so this is where we need to work very closely with the landholders, the farmers, to make sure they're not clearing the really critical areas and that we can work together and restore some of the places that we've unfortunately lost.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah, deforestation is a big one. Twenty percent of Queensland's vegetation has been lost since colonization, and a lot of land clearing is continuing today, unfortunately. There are nature protection laws, but there's a lot of loopholes which are enabling tree clearing to continue, and the majority of it is for cattle grazing, for beef production. One million hectares of forest and bush land has been cleared since 2022 in Queensland, and nearly half of that was in reef catchments. So when we're trying to protect the water quality of the Great Barrier Reef, and we've got animals like the koala becoming endangered, it's just crazy to think that in the last three years we've cleared another one million hectares.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, it's just heart pinching.
SPEAKER_04This is a very um dear issue to my heart. The fact that Australia is one of the deforestation hotspots of the world, it's the only developed country on the deforestation hotspot list, and Queensland is the biggest deforester in Australia. A lot of people are shocked.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, a lot of people wouldn't know that.
SPEAKER_04Especially when I talk to tourists from overseas, they've have this shining reputation of Australia as oh, it's got so much unique wildlife, it's got the Great Barry Reef, it's got rainforests. Obviously, Australians must be doing a really good job of protecting it. People are shocked to find out that we have really high deforestation rates and that our koalas have gone endangered largely due to habitat destruction within the last few years. You know, it's one of our iconic animals, and under our watch, we've allowed it to go on the endanger list. And then, of course, the same with the Great Barry Reefs. So sorry, that's that's just uh I just admired it.
SPEAKER_03It's it's important, Tanya, because a lot of our listeners are from overseas as well and a lot of locals, and it's it's important for people to get the updates and understand what's going on at the moment. Yeah, it's terrible.
SPEAKER_01I agree. I mean, it's those particular things that people come to see, right? So just having an understanding of some of the things that are unfortunately still going on, and as you said, you know, almost half of the tree clearing is in reef catchment, and unfortunately it the laws and government oversight, the a lot of the tree clearing is actually happening in really critical areas, as I said, for example, along rivers and streams. So being able to close some of those loopholes and at least stopping deforestation in the areas that can cause the biggest harm to both terrestrial wildlife but also the reef. I think that's kind of where we need to head.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, you can you can really see the difference when you walk along riverbanks that have been deforested. They're just crumbling away every you know, wet season. They lose several meters of land into the river, and that all that mud's just going and getting dumped out onto the reef. A really confronting example recently of just how deadly that
How Extreme Rainfall Events are Supercharging Pollution
SPEAKER_04sediment laden water can be for the reef was unfortunately seen with extreme rainfall events and floods over the past few years. Can you tell us a bit about the impact of those flood waters on the reef over the recent years, Max?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, as you said, unfortunately the last two summers we've seen some really extensive major flooding along the Great Beiret coast and Which has been worsened by climate change, of course.
SPEAKER_04So the extremeness of the floods and rainfall is probably going to continue getting worse, and then that mixes with the water quality issues and what impact is that causing?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. As you say, I mean, unfortunately these events are increasing in magnitude and frequency. So yeah, floods existed in the past, of course, but just frequency and magnitude is increasing, and then just the amount of pollutants and sediment that's being washed off eroded land is just much higher now, and so that's really having a huge impact on the breeze. And so with a lot of heavy rainfall, obviously the fertilizers that are supposed to stay on land and on farms to uh be absorbed by plants is going to get washed off, and then a lot of the vegetation that's been cleared where there's fair land, and after the dry season, a lot of that stuff gets washed out. And last year we've had huge floods more in the central Great Bairie, and the flood plumes reached out a hundred kilometers offshore, and that just really highlights again how connected the land is to the Great Baries. And you could, you know, see big flood plumes with murky water reaching even reefs uh that are a hundred kilometers offshore and it was stretching along over seven hundred kilometers along the shore.
SPEAKER_03And it's probably important to remind everyone to stop thinking about the Great Barry Reef and land being completely different. It's just one big unit that needs to work together, isn't it?
SPEAKER_04Imagine if everything on the entire planet was one connected hole.
SPEAKER_03Oh that's deep.
SPEAKER_04We are all one. We you know, a butterfly flapping its wings on one side of the world.
SPEAKER_03It's just the reef can't survive without the land. And vice versa. So that's how people need to look at it.
SPEAKER_04Absolutely, everything's connected, and if we were to have listened to the traditional owners to begin with, we would have known that a long time ago. Okay, so you've mentioned these uh devastating floods with muddy, pollution-laders being washed out further than they normally do, all the way out a hundred kilometers offshore. And I've actually had to witness the impacts of that firsthand because these flood waters from after Cyclone Jasper washed over iconic snorkel sites like the Low Isles off of Port Douglas. Absolutely beautiful, beautiful place to go snorkeling. It still is, but I did see the before and after impacts of those flood waters. And within days of being smothered by this murky flood water, it pretty much died. And the giant clams died even though they were, you know, over a hundred years old, which means they've survived multiple flood events in the past.
SPEAKER_03Shows you how bad it was.
SPEAKER_04But this one killed them, and giant clams grow really slowly, so we're not going to see them getting to that big giant size again for a while in that spot.
SPEAKER_03It's devastating.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, a lot of people who've snorkeled at Low Isles before and after have been really uh troubled to see that impact. Of course, it's still an absolutely gorgeous place to visit, highly recommend, but we are definitely seeing the impact of uh increasing pollution. So let's talk a bit more about solutions.
Solutions: Farming for our Future
SPEAKER_04And I guess it sort of, as you've mentioned, falls into two categories. There's uh trying to help farmers to improve farming practices, and then the other category is uh stopping deforestation and replanting trees. So, starting off with the farming practices, what are some of the ways that farmers can help out and reduce the rent off of nitrogen fertilizer and other chemicals? And actually, I should mention that farmers love the reef too. One of our Patreon supporters of our radio show and podcast, our good friend Rodney, is a cane farmer from Port Douglas and and from a long line of multiple generations of farmers, and he is a big supporter of our podcast and a Patreon supporter, and he also volunteers for the Marine Conservation Society. So, you know, he's just one example that you know Rodney's got a boat, he likes to go out to Low Isles, he saw the impacts himself. So yeah, farmers love the reef too, right?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right. And I've had over the eight years that we've been open at work, I've had multiple conversations with farmers from up on the tablands, north, south, that have had to chat to me afterwards and told me about the practices that they're putting in place because they realise that you know Cannes only survives on two things it's tourism and farming. So one has to help the other, and they understand that. I've had some great conversations with local farmers.
SPEAKER_04Everyone's trying to do the right thing.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, absolutely. Um maybe there's a few people that are sort of um there's a few rogues that need to be yeah, slowly moved into line well as quickly as possible. But yeah, it's important to note that there are some some amazing farmers out there that are doing a great job.
SPEAKER_04That's true. So so Max, what are some of the things? I mean, we've had, you know, nearly two hundred years of old school farming practices. How do we come back from that?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's not a very easy one, but I think the big point here is really compared to climate change, for example, water pollution is a very local issue. Mm-hmm and we can do everything that's in our power right here, right now, to reduce water pollution ending up in waterways and the reefs. And as you said, I think many, many farmers genuinely are very interested in the environment and keeping it as pristine as possible. And so what we need is to obviously support them as much as possible on their way to uh sustainability and having less impact on the environment and that's what many farmers want to do. As you said, maybe there's a few rogue ones as you you get always, and we do have since 2019 the reef protection regulations, which are pretty much intended just to set some very minimum basic rules to prevent some really harmful practices are sort of um under control.
SPEAKER_04So just for any listeners that aren't familiar, the reef regulations are uh an act, a law that was introduced in 2019, right? To enforce some some minimum standards, which was a big step forward. I mean, only six years ago it was kind of just trusting industry to do what they wanted, I guess. And that's great when when we know that many people are doing the right thing, but unfortunately not everyone does.
SPEAKER_03Just on uh another note, so I know there's a fair bit of aquaculture up this way as well. Do you know
Aquaculture: Sustainable or Not?
SPEAKER_03much about that or whether the impacts of that are affecting this as well?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's a good question. So there's uh of course the potential of aquaculture introducing, for example, uh nitrogen into the waterways.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But as of today, what we know is that most of them operate really well. So whatever comes out of their facilities is treated beforehand and has good water quality. So it doesn't is not a major contributor to the pollutants. What we need to do in the future though, make sure that as we may be expanding to have more aquaculture, yeah, that they're really well located and that they're complying as as uh the farmers have to do with the regulations to make sure that they're not contributing to the pollutants, but they're actually part of the solution too, because some of the fishing practices that we don't want out on the reef, for example, maybe trawling for prawns, aquaculture could be a a a good alternative.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's right, that's right. So they get a gold Nemo sticker for their efforts then aquaculture. Yeah, good job.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, things can go pear-shaped though. I've like I've heard a recent event where an aquaculture farm had a bit of a leak, but as Max was saying, we need to make sure that they're being uh regulated and and compliant so those sort of things don't happen. And and in that case, they can be sort of an eco-friendly alternative to the other.
SPEAKER_03And there can also be the risk of those those animals that are bred in aquaculture getting into our natural environment too. Yeah, that that's a big issue if that gets into the natural world, because they're they're different. So yeah, it's important.
SPEAKER_04We should definitely get someone on who's an aquaculture expert at some states. So we'll write that on the list. We can talk about that in more detail. We always get so many
Farmers Can't Solve this Alone
SPEAKER_04different tangents and topics from from one topic. So yeah, improving farming practices is something that's been going on over time, especially since the regulations in 2019. So that there can be better fertilizers, there can be better timing of the use of fertilizers to avoid those wet season floods washing them away. We can have better irrigation to reduce the nutrients and chemicals being washed off the farm into the water. And this all ends up benefiting the farmers in the long run because they do want to retain their chemicals on their farm. They don't actually want it to be washed away into the river after they've spent so much money on all these fertilizers and chemicals. They don't really want it to get washed off onto the Great Barrier Reef. But there just needs to be some certain practices and sometimes better application machinery and methods can really help with that. But those improved farming practices can only get us so far, can't they, Max? What else do we need to do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. As as you say, there's a lot of innovation going on and there's a lot of farmers really pushing towards uh really good practices, which has great outcomes for the farming businesses themselves. But we need those protection regulations just to keep everybody in check because otherwise we're undermining really the good work that the ones that are leaving the field, the good work they're doing. And so we just need those who have that base level. But more important than that, I guess, is since we have changed our landscape so much, there's only that far the changing farming practices can get us. So we also need to really focus to restore the critical ecosystems that we've lost. That includes coastal wetlands that can act like water filters and absorb some of the nutrients. And they have really good what we call co-benefits. So they can also increase biodiversity, they can increase cultural values for traditional owners, they can increase values for ecotourism and and all of these other things. But yeah, we need to definitely have a bit of a shift in thinking and also government investments towards more restoration because we just have changed the landscape too much to keep pollutants out of the waterway in the reef.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so replanting trees along streams and riverbanks is so important because they can actually soak up a lot of those nutrients from the farms and stop them from ending up in the water. And also it's it's a good idea for farmers if they have some land near the river that is becoming unstable and sort of unviable by stabilizing it with trees, they can actually protect their land. But also, Max, you were telling me that a lot of consumers would prefer to buy products like beef that has been grown sustainably and which isn't impacting the reef, right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. I think that's where we're heading. It's quite common now in the beef industry that when you can label your products as sustainable and not having an impact on the environment, particularly for exporting to, for example, the European market, etc., that's an extra bonus. So it's actually something that can really support the agricultural businesses. And ultimately that's what consumers want too. Often we maybe don't take enough time to make that conscious choice. But if you would ask somebody, do you want 10 cents less, cheaper sugar, but you know, having a big impact on the reef versus you paying ten cents more and do you know that you're doing something good at the same time, then usually the answer is quite clear. So I think that's kind of where we should be heading, and I think that's something that can really benefit the farmers as well, and that we need to continue working together. And I think you made a really good point about there's a lot of land that maybe is now a very marginal, so it's maybe inundated, maybe there's some saltwater inundation because it's close to the coast, etc. And so a lot of that land is not very productive, but the farmers need some incentives and they need to have the technical know-how working with scientists and researchers and for example natural resource management groups to be able to do something really good, which could be restoring natural wetlands. They used to be there, but of course they just can't do that on their own. So we really need to have a big focus on that in terms of investment and effort. Um, how we can help them the best and how we can pitch them together to restore those really critical systems.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, protecting the planet is always a win-win because if you have degraded eroding soil, you can't grow very good crops and and it's not good for the environment either. So protecting your soil, protecting your land and your vegetation, it's a resource win as well as an environment win. So is fixing the Great Barrier Reef pollution issue both a state and a federal
85 Years Behind Schedule: Government Must Step Up on Water Quality
SPEAKER_04issue with the government, Max?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so because it's all comes down to the Great Barrier Reef World Heritage Area. And so that's uh responsibility of both the federal and the Queensland State government. And in terms of water pollution, they have both investment programs for better management of reducing water pollution in the Great Barrier Reef and its catchment. And I think what's really important here, just recently they released a new strategy, a government strategy, so a joint strategy between Queensland and federal government. And that is supposed to lay out what are we going to do over the next five years to reduce water pollution and reef catchment. And it's just out now for public consultation and only until Wednesday next week, actually. And I've talked to many scientists, to people from the agricultural industry, from tourism, and many environmental organizations, and everybody is quite disappointed of what has come out. And as we said earlier, we have now so much learning from decades of trying to improve farming practices, of decades of trial and error in different programs and projects, and we've got much better knowledge about restoring ecosystems and really good science. We have excellent reef scientists in Australia. So there's no really no excuses to come up with a very weak plan. Yeah. So I think what's going to happen now is we need to have, as many people have, their say on the public consultation, make use of our right as citizens and organizations to have our say, and hopefully then we can have a better outcome, a better strategy that really lays out well, what are the most important things to do, where the investments should be going over the next five years, and how can we get closer to these water quality targets. So they're very specific targets that have been set that both governments have committed to, but we're really not making a very fast progress towards meeting those targets. The targets just mean those are levels of water pollution that the reef can handle, that the ecosystems like seagrass and coals can handle. So they're less susceptible also to the impacts of climate change.
SPEAKER_04So I've seen some of those reports come out where the government reports how they're tracking on their goals towards that World Heritage commitment to reduce water pollution on the Great Barrier Reef. And I saw that we're tracking very poorly. We're nowhere near meeting the water pollution targets, are we, Max? Where are we up to on those?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so for some of them we're about halfway there. But I guess the take-home message is if we do everything as we're doing it currently, in the case of nitrogen pollution, it would take us another 90 years to get there. And what Australia has promised to UNESCO to also keep it off the endangerless is to meet those targets in the next five years.
SPEAKER_04So we're only 85 years behind to pick up your game. Wow.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. So we need just a a really clear plan for clean water. That's what we need.
SPEAKER_04Well, it makes you lose hope a bit. It's like obviously we're not going to be able to do it in the next five years, are we? Or could we? Is there something dramatic we could do within the next five years? I mean, just halting tree clearing is something that could be done overnight. The environment minister could make an announcement this afternoon and say, that's it, no more tree clearing. And that would go a long way towards the towards helping things.
SPEAKER_03Well it'd be a dirty great big step, wouldn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah. It's a very ambitious goal, that's that's for sure, considering how far we've gotten until now over the last 20 years. But we have such good knowledge now. So it's really about being very transparent on what we're doing, where we're doing and why we're doing it. And also we do need more investment overall. It's not going to be enough what has been invested over the last 20 years. It's probably around a quarter of what we need to invest to meet those targets. And if we want to meet 2030, then we definitely need some more public funding that goes into improving water quality in the reef. Having said that, it's super important to be transparent but also make sure that any of that money that's being spent is highly effective. And I think we kind of owe that to the public.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I think someone else explained this to me before. If you've got even just a car, you need to invest money into it to keep it running. If you've got something like the Great Barrier Reef, which is worth tens of billions of dollars to our economy, you need to put some some of that back into it. It provides 77,000 full-time jobs. I mean, it's hard to even put a price on the value of it. Deloitte recently, in their recent economic assessment of the Great Barrier Reef, they've just updated that and said that if the Great Barrier Reef was a company, it would be the fifth largest employer in Australia. So you really need to invest in it. And like just saying, they've only invested about a quarter of what the science shows we need to invest, especially in terms of restoring those damaged wetlands and ecosystems, which you know, it's going to be lovely to have more trees and more wetlands and more ecosystems there, not to mention the flow and effects of the reef.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and to communities as well, because many of these systems obviously provide services to the communities, such as protection from cyclones and storms and flooding and everything. So it's all connected, as we said.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it improves fisheries. Coastal wetlands are uh nursery grounds for fisheries. We learned about this all in last week's episode, where which was all about mangroves and and the huge carbon sequestration, they uh prevent erosion, they protect our coast from storms and storm surge and then filtering the water before it enters the Great Barry Reef.
SPEAKER_03It's just literally a no-brainer, isn't it?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, and and and Max, you you told me it the economics weighs up that every dollar spent on restoring coastal wetlands ends up getting way more bang for your buck than most other things that you could be pouring money into and not seeing as many results in terms of helping the reef?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there's been some analysis coming out that just show how cost-effective restoring wetlands is, particularly to uh reduce water pollution, get nitrogen, for example, out of the system before it ends up in our ocean. And so that's really encouraging. Um, what we do uh need now is increased investment, but also making sure it's in the right places. You know, not every wetland is the same, not every location is going to work the same way. So we need to use the science that we have to place them really, really well and make sure, yeah, we can really show outcomes from public investment. I think that's one of the big things for me is that we need more transparency from our government.
SPEAKER_04What are they actually doing? How are they actually gonna use the science to fix this problem?
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Exactly. What are we achieving from those investments? And everybody needs to be able to see that, and I think particularly the farmers, you know, we do owe it to them also. Uh that the ones that are trying really hard, if they see that, you know, another five years from now, independently of what they did, their water quality hasn't improved significantly, then that's not a good outcome for anyone. So we we need to be able to have finer scale monitoring also in in the reef catchment. So farmers can actually see that their actions they're taking, you know, within a few years from now have a significant impact and significant increase in water quality. And that's what we want to see, and I think that's gonna really drive them to do their best.
SPEAKER_03And that that goes down to people doing what they can at home as well. You know, if people can see you know get these updates on how it's working and see some sort of result,
How You Can Take Immediate Action to Reduce Water Pollution
SPEAKER_03it's just gonna encourage them to keep doing it, isn't it?
SPEAKER_04Yes, that's right. We've got listeners interstate and overseas, but everything you do can impact the ocean, even if you live quite far inland. So everything that goes down the drain in your shower, in your toilet, in your kitchen sink, everything that goes down the drain after you wash your car. Water sewage treatment plants do some work in terms of sort of sterilizing that water to make sure there's no diseases, bugs, viruses, and bacteria, but they don't actually remove a lot of the chemicals. So we've seen studies where turtles have been blood tested and they've found everything from from the human household, including what is getting flushed down our toilets after we go to the bathroom, including human medications, contraceptions, gout medication, recreational drugs, all of those chemicals are ending up inside turtles. So be careful what products you use, you know, even rat poison if it washes down the drain and fertilizers and pesticides, try to choose eco-friendly products in your home. But as we've discussed, on the sort of reef-saving scale, it is mainly agriculture, is I think about 70% of all the pollution is from agriculture. Is that around the right number, Max? Yeah. So we've only got just over five minutes left. But the main action that needs to happen right now, there's a couple of things that the Australian Marine Conservation Society are doing, isn't there, Max? And one of them is there's a campaign to stop deforestation and tree clearing in Australia and Queensland, especially by closing the loopholes that allow tree clearing to continue by improving our federal nature laws. So everyone who's listening, please head to fightforaurreef.org.au. There's a button you can click on called Take Action. Yeah, so click on take action and sign one of those petitions because those nature laws which determine the tree clearing are being decided, could be as soon as within the next couple of weeks. So just go and sign it now before you forget, guys. Fightforaurreefs. And at the moment how it stands is not really going to solve the water pollution issues. So you're encouraging people to be part of that public consultation by sending in a submission. It's really easy because the Australian Marine Conservation Society just has a really great submission form on your website, don't they? Tell us about it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. As you say, I mean we should really take advantage of the opportunity to tell our governments they need to do a little better or a lot better. But in this case, yeah, it's just a public consultation and we've also prepared something where people can really easily and very uh quickly make a submission through our website. And so that's easy, and that's really based on all of the latest scientific knowledge and working on this letter for uh a couple of years now, together with many stakeholders from the farming industry, with scientists, etc. So really distilled that down a few major points. And the take-home is really that we need a better plan. Our governments need to not just say, you know, we have a very broad vision for what would be nice to have, but they need to show us how we're actually going to get to meet water quality targets and protect the reef in the future. So that's really the take-home. They need a plan of how they're actually going to deliver what they're promising.
SPEAKER_04Mm-hmm. And so what people can do as well on that same website I mentioned earlier, fightforourreef.org.au, when you click on take action, there's one there for addressing water pollution, and that one will actually send off to the public consultation to the government. So it's really, really important because when there's a public consultation, every single submission they receive has to be taken into consideration and read and logged as part of the consultation process. So it's it will make a difference. So before you forget, anyone who's listening, fightforourreef.org.au, head there right now, click take action, send off a submission, and take this chance. They don't often consult the public on what they're going to do about pollution. It's it's and comes around every now and then, not very often. So take that chance now because we need urgent action within the next few years, don't we? Respond to it. Yes. All right, well, we've only got two minutes left. So I think we'll wrap it up there. Dr. Max Hirschfeld, Great Barrier Reef Water Quality Manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society. Thanks so much for all your amazing work and thanks for joining us on Word on the Reef today.
SPEAKER_01Thanks so much for having me. Now I can put those leather hosen back on and test it.
SPEAKER_03Thanks, Max. It's been great. Have a great day. Thank you. You two. Thanks, Mike.
SPEAKER_04And thanks to you, all our listeners, for joining us on Word on the Reef. I'm Tanya Murphy. My co-host is Brett Goodburn. And we will be back on Canada FM 89.1 next Friday at 10 a.m. with more awesome marine science events. Don't forget to follow us on Instagram, Instagram, and the Skype.