Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E28: Corals' Last Stand: The Fight to Save Scott Reef
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Scott Reef, Australia’s largest remote offshore reef, is a breathtaking sanctuary for corals, fish, rare sea snakes, nesting turtles, and pygmy blue whales. But this natural wonder is under threat from a mega gas drilling and carbon dumping proposal. Fossil fuel campaigner Louise Morris from the Australian Marine Conservation Society joins us to explain what’s at stake and how we can fight back.
Plus: we unpack Australia’s new 2035 climate target with AMCS Reef Campaigner Lissa Schindler — and why experts say it’s not enough to protect our oceans.
Thumbnail Image Credit: Nush Freedman Photography
- Sign the Petition: Help Save Scott Reef from Woodside's Gas Plans
- Documentary Film: Coral's Last Stand
- Cairns Snap Action: 'Sleep-In For Climate,' Monday 22 September, 4pm
- Read the Australian Government's recently released National Climate Risk Assessment Report Summary & Sign the Petition
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Intro to Today's Topics & Guest
SPEAKER_00Hey everyone, we're working hard to bring you this podcast completely free and ad-free. But right now we do have a favour to ask. Can you please pause this podcast right now and click the link in the show notes to fill out our list of survey. It only takes a minute and at the end of September I will draw one of your names from a hat and I will transfer that person $100 Australian dollars via PayPal. That's gotta help in a cost of living crisis. Only 10 people have filled it out so far, so your chances of winning are extremely high. So if you go in the drawer, just pause this episode and take a minute to fill it out. We'll be right here when you're done. Thank you. This is Word on the Reef, where marine science meets the death. Join Tanya Murphy and Rick with Banks and one into the wonder reader and explore the mysteries beneath the wave. Good morning everyone and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver, and marine conservationist Tanya Murphy. And joining me as always is Cans Aquarium's marine educator and fish whisperer Brett Goodback.
SPEAKER_04Good morning, Woodback. We are back. Yep.
SPEAKER_00Now, before we get started, just a quick news update. Yesterday, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced Australia's 2035 climate target of 62 to 70% emission cuts by 2035, but experts, including the Climate Council, say it falls well short of what's needed to protect our oceans, our reefs, and ourselves from the impact of climate change. We'll be speaking with someone later in the show to unpack what this means for our oceans. But first, Brett, today we're taking a trip across to Western Australia again. To visit Scott Reef. Actually, it's Australia's largest remote of coal reef, sitting about 270 kilometers off the Kimberleef coast. Not only is it one of the most spectacular coral reefs in the country, it's also a critical factory for fibrillant corals, countless fish species, endangered whales, state nights, and a unique subtype of green state circles that come for next. Yes. Despite its beauty and importance, Scott Reef is under serious threat. To explain what's happening and what can be done to protect it, we're joined by a very special guest, Louise Morris, fossil fuel campaigner with the Australian Marine Conservation Society. Louise, good morning. Welcome to the show.
SPEAKER_02Morning, thanks so much.
SPEAKER_04Morning, Louise. Nice to meet you.
SPEAKER_00Great to have you on the show.
Growing up in Fossil Fuel Country: Louise's Background
SPEAKER_00Louise, I understand you're from Tasmania. What sparked your connection with protecting the ocean?
SPEAKER_02I currently live in Tasmania, which of course is surrounded by the Great Southern Reef, one of the lesser recognised reefs. But I spent most of my childhood up in the northwest of WA, so growing up everywhere from Shark Bay till the Pilbara coast as well. So really well acquainted with the fossil fuel industry and just the amount of havoc it's wreaking on that incredibly fragile both land and sea country of Northwest Australia.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
WA's Remote Gem: Scott Reef & Its Unique Wildlife
SPEAKER_00So Louise, for any listeners who aren't familiar, can you describe Scott Reef for us so we can sort of imagine it?
SPEAKER_04We can drift off.
SPEAKER_02Drift off. So Scott Reef is, as you described, incredibly far off the coast, which is one of its benefits from to date being protected from the worst of human impacts from a highly industrialized area. So Scott Reef, many, many, many eons ago, was part of an incredible reef system that stretched from Exmouth all the way up to the island archipelago's indo. And was sort of like you can imagine the WA version of the Great Barrier Reef, and then millennia ago as sea levels rose. You've got various atolls in that old, old reef system which have survived. So Scott Reefs, Ashmore Reefs, Rolly Shoals are some of those. And Scott Reef is one of the most intact because it was one of the high-rise, as you say, at areas of that point. And the importance of Scott Reef is because it comes off the shelf, it's also a site for a big upwelling. So cool waters are coming off the deep ocean up over this reef, which is where these high concentrations of acryla that the pygmy blue whale relies on as it does its monstrous trek from that Timor carving ground all the way down the West Australian coast and then end up in the Otway Basin off Victoria. And as we've been hearing, and it's heartbreaking, that the pygmy blue whales are really struggling finding food, and we are seeing year on year that they're getting skinnier and their behaviours are changing. So it's got reefs and protecting it from the seismic blasting, the 50 plus oil rig wells that are being proposed, and carbon pollution dumping. Critical for fo many species, and pygmy blue whale and krill, you know, from the top to the bottom of the food chain. So vitally important.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, yeah. It it sounds like its location and very similar to osprey, isn't it, on our side? Right right out in the deep there.
SPEAKER_02It's a good analogy. Yeah, it is that it's that shelf space where it goes from warm, light-filled reef to all of a sudden this glorious plunge where you know that marine snow intersection.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, or that upwelling, and then our humpies use it as a turnaround point when they migrate up to Queensland coast as well. So, yeah, very similar but on opposite sides of the country.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, it's so many correlations. And then, you know, the green sea turtles, it's their nesting site, and then we've got endemism up the wazoo there, where you've just got these reef ecosystems which have been sitting isolated for so many generations, and that's where we get the endemic dusky sea snake. And if anyone wants to Google it, it is one of the most charismatically beautiful little sea snakes. And I've got a big soft spot for those.
SPEAKER_04I'll be googling him very shortly.
SPEAKER_02Oh, they're beautiful. You can also watch Coral's Last Dan online, and the dusky sea snake gets in the face of every diver and every camera person.
SPEAKER_04It sounds like the olive sea snakes on this side, they get right up in the camera lens. They like shiny stuff.
SPEAKER_00Yes, personality, totally. I love sea snakes. Yeah, they're so adorable. And even though they do have venom, like their land snake cousins, they don't attack people. So as long as you don't try to harm it or touch it, then they'll swim over to have a look, and they're really curious and yeah, absolutely harmless. They just eat.
SPEAKER_03They wrap around your legs.
SPEAKER_00They really they really get all up in your business, don't you?
SPEAKER_04They do get up, and it's no personal space with a sea snake.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so we've got these incredible sea snakes. It's a migration point for pygmy blue whales. There is a sand cave on Scott Reef where turtles nest, and we know that turtles have this incredible superpower where they can swim hundreds or even thousands of kilometres all across the ocean, but then they are actually able to navigate back to the beach where they hatched from in order to lay their eggs once they're mature. So when they've only got this one small spit of sand on Scott Reef that they are honing in to go and lay their eggs on, it's so, so important that we protect that.
SPEAKER_04Oh, absolutely.
SPEAKER_00Especially given that sea turtles are endangered, the green sea turtles. And like Louise mentioned, it's coming up out of really deep oceans. So you've got these cool water upwellings which might be giving the Scott Reef a little bit of protection from the heat experience near the coast. Like on Ningaloo Reef in March this year had a fairly catastrophic bleaching event because of climate change heating up the oceans. And so a reef which is further offshore and has those cold water upwellings, has a chance to be a sort of a refuge reef. Is that right, Louise?
SPEAKER_02It is, yeah. And it's that's really what makes Scott Reef when we're looking at you know, you're going to talk about targets later in the show as well. Of we know we have some baked-in ocean warming there of Scott Reef is one of the places that can weather the storm better than so many other of our more shallow reefs. And then again, it's the species that you're talking about. And that sandy islet, as it's known, is this incredibly narrow but incredibly important sandy spit as part of this reef, which is like two horseshoes, if you envision it. The proposal for the up to 50 wells around Scott Reef, the issue there is that if this is allowed to go ahead, the extraction of that, you know, if liquid petroleum gas, we need to stop calling it LNG, would cause subsidence of the islet. So it's sucking out substance from below the reef, which will cause it to sink, and then of course that will sink the sandbar, the the genetically distinct subspecies of green sea turtle has been coming from time immemorial. When that goes, that population goes as well.
SPEAKER_04Just a very quick question on the turtles, because I have a lot to do with turtles at the rehab centre at the aquarium. As far as the temperatures go on that sand out at Scott Reef, have you have you found that because we're having that issue on this side with the temperature for the turtle eggs, the warmer the egg we get females, cooler we get males, and nothing's calling down out there as we know. Has there been any any studies on that at Scott Reef with the temperatures for the eggs?
SPEAKER_02No, because it is just so hard to get to that particular work hasn't been done, but I know it is on the agenda because it's a a super narrow islet. So could imagine so much of what you're working with would be a really similar story out there.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And this is just a population that's understudied, you know, I think they're quite happy having less of us around. But I'm sure we are seeing a population shift as well of lots of ladies and not so many boys.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's an issue at the moment.
SPEAKER_02Not so great for future generations. No.
SPEAKER_00For any listeners that aren't familiar, Bret and Louise are talking about the feminization of sea turtles because when they lay their eggs in the sand of the beaches, the sex of the baby turtles is determined by the temperature of the sand. And if the sand is too warm, which is mostly the case now because of climate change, all of the turtles are coming out female. About 99% on the east coast, according to one study. So at the moment we've still got so many green sea turtles we can snorkel with them on the reef almost every day here on the Great Barry Reef. But within the next decade, we're going to start to see that drop off if we don't address this feminization issue that's leaving them with difficulties in breeding. So now, Louise, you've touched on the threats to Scott Reef, and that is, of course, from this gas drilling
The Threat: Woodside's Gas Proposal
SPEAKER_00proposal. So Louise, can you tell us why is Scott Reef under threat right now? Yeah.
SPEAKER_02So Woodside and a bunch of joint venture partners have got a proposal to drill up to 50 gas wells about 3Ks off the reef. It's part of something known as the Browse proposal. But it gets better. There's another part of this, which is for carbon pollution dumping, also known as carbon capture and storage, to the southwest of the reef. So that's all part of the Browse proposal. So this Browse Basin, as it's known, has not had any fossil fuel projects in it yet, and we want to keep it that way. So this is one of those things that Woodside has been sitting on this place for 50 odd years, has never progressed it, has never got anything done, and factoring in, you know, almost 800 K's off the coast. It's almost closer to Indonesia than it is a city. It would be ridiculously expensive to build 800 Ks of pipeline for the gas and then another 800 for the carbon pollution dumping and then 50 odd rigs. And you can imagine the rig moral around that. So it's ridiculously expensive, ridiculously dangerous for both marine life and climate. And it really is one of those examples of the fossil fuel industry now at a point of desperation of having last gas proposals at projects that for the last 40 years have just been not worth it, we'll do other places. Now they're at that point of desperation of let's give it a crack, we can see we'll we'll do it. And with the approval of the Northwest Shelves, Woodside is seeing that as a little bit of a top-up to their aspirations to just have more fossil fuels and carbon pollution dumping in our ocean, which has never been allowed in Australia before. And if the Albanese government approves this, because both the carbon dumping and the gas drilling proposal are currently on the desk of the environment minister to make a decision through the Environment Protection, Biodiversity and Conservation Act. So this Browse project is currently with the Albanese government to green light or red light. And if there's a green light, this is yet another example of the Albanese government not taking climate action seriously.
SPEAKER_04So he can come out this morning and say that he's going to have 70% emission cuts. And then on the other side of his desk near his coffee cup is him to either approve or not approve these rigs around this magnificent reef. Is that the way I'm looking at it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, pretty much.
SPEAKER_04That's you know, I'll just call it spade a spade. It's just rubbish. I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_00It's just it's upset the bald head, I'm telling you. Brett's passed his judgment. It's not cool. Guilty. Yeah. Yes.
SPEAKER_02If this thing was approved, we are locking in billions, that's with a B, billions of tons of carbon pollution. And where the fossil fuel companies have cooked the books with all these new projects is by including things like carbon pollution dumping or CCS as a way of offsetting. So every time you hear something like carbon pollution dumping or CCS as part of a new project, because they all need it now, it's about cooking the books through offsetting to have a promise of, oh well, Barry, you know, maybe one percent of our projected emissions is a way of just going, oh look, less emissions than it would have been. So Browse is so important ecologically, climatically, and in the politics of the moment, that if the Albanese government approves this, they've just opened a whole new industry of fossil fuels of yes, gas, but also the first carbon pollution dumping project in our ocean ever.
SPEAKER_00Wow. There's many, many questions coming up. I just want I just Brett's got another one, but I'll jump in first. I just wanted to clarify because I described Scott Reef as being 270 kilometres off the Kimberley coast, but that is also 800 kilometres from Carratha, is that right? So that is actually where they are going to pipe the gas to. So they're not going to the Kimberley, they're going to pipe this gas all the way down to Carratha where the port and the processing facility is. So that is a mega long pipeline along whose length anything could cause a leak or something, I suppose.
SPEAKER_02Oh yeah, what could possibly go wrong at the end of the day?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, I should be right. Yeah. Well, just looking at it the other way as well, like it's it's the colossal destruction and disruption of the animal world out there. Just that audible noise and that disruption. So I mean these poor turtles, if they lose that location, it's not like our turtles on the east coast where they can go and if that beach is gone, they go, I'll go and check out Early Beach and lay my eggs there. They don't have another option.
SPEAKER_02Oh, there's no optional species out there. And this comes, you know, whether we're talking the dusky sea snake, endemic, the green sea turtles, locally endangered. And yeah, and the pygmy blues, the place where they're proposing these fifty wells is in the feeding and foraging ground. So the pygmy blues, you know, how do you do a good gulf of krill when you've got to navigate fifty odd gas drills with the noise? And we all know whales live in acoustic worlds, so sound is how they navigate the world. If you've got drilling, flaring, the boats, the pollution and everything on that, you're gonna move around that and they this is their stop off to refuel to make it all the way down to the next one, which is way down the coast of WA, which is no state.
SPEAKER_04To think that us humans get cranky if there's road works out in the front of our house for two days. Do you know what I mean? It's like, hang on a sec, champ, this is not this isn't how it works, this is their home.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, well they they've got to make that mega migration, they've come all the way up to the warmer waters to have their calves, which leaves them in a weakened state. Yep. And then they've got to deal with these disruptions and possible disruptions as well, and we've got to throw in seismic blasting as part of this mix, which you know, is it you don't get much bladder, it's two hundred and fifty decibels, you know, it all works differently underwater.
SPEAKER_02But if you do that really baseline easy equivalence, it's as loud as an atomic bomb underwater.
unknownYep.
SPEAKER_02And if this project is approved, there's the exploration blasting for gas and CCS. So that's months on end, 24 hours a day. And if this carbon pollution scam is approved, that will require exploration seismic blasting and then blasting every five years to monitor for leaks and spills of CO2 under the ocean floor. So not only do you have that acoustic monstrous impact, if the CO2 leaks, it causes localized ocean acidification and asphyxiation of marine life. So it's whichever way you cut this, it's an absolute disaster.
SPEAKER_04How loud did you say that that seismic blasting is?
SPEAKER_02Uh the equivalence, because you know, decibels perform differently above and below, about the equivalent of an atomic bomb underwater.
SPEAKER_04So 200 and something decibels.
SPEAKER_02250 decibels.
SPEAKER_00Well, it it damages their ears. There's been many times where whales have washed up stranded on beaches and the autopsy found ear damage, you know, bleeding ears. So the the noises in the ocean can be really harmful to the whales. Once their hearing goes, they pretty much can't survive.
SPEAKER_02So the larger cetaceans, you never see those guys wash up, they fall to the bottom. Yes, that's right. But the blues is an example, they operate at such deep frequencies, they are sitting in that 250 humpies, you know, a little bit above, but they will move around it, which also means you're pushing them out of all this foraging and the space. Well, you're pushing them out of migration into waters unknown.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's like you get home to your house and you want to go inside and relax, and someone's having a giant rock concert in there with the decibels turned up to eleven. I think we should put a speaker outside whoever's in charge of approving this project and blast them with two hundred and thirty decibels.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. See if you like it, champion.
SPEAKER_00What did you say?
SPEAKER_02Once every once every ten well, it depends on the the area, but everything from five to fifteen seconds, depending on what area they're surveying. So it's it's just constant. Twenty-four hours a day, five to fifteen seconds.
SPEAKER_00Wowza. So let's sum up the impact. So you you've mentioned that sucking all the gas out from under Scott Reef could cause the seafloor to subside down into the into the void, drowning the reef at a deeper depth and drowning the island where the sea turtles nest. We've got the seismic blasting, which not only deafens whales, but it can also kill krill, which the whales need to feed on and it can kill 1.2 kilometres from the blast zone. Wow, and and it can kill sea snakes by rupturing their lung, I understand. And also there's going to be light pollution. So if you've got 50 gas rigs, they're all lit up, they've got flames and floodlights. And so when the baby sea turtles hatch, they could be confused and heading towards those lights because they normally use the moon to find their way to where they need to go, right? So I understand that all those lights could be harming young sea turtles and causing light pollution.
SPEAKER_04Especially for the babies.
SPEAKER_00Yep, exactly. When they're hatching. Yes, that's right.
SPEAKER_02And then there's another one on that is based on woodside zone paperwork, an oil spill from any of these fifty odd rigs would encompass the entire reef system. And you know, Montara was that disastrous oil spill back in 2009, and I was living in WA when it happened, it was horrendous. It was not that far off, and it was just due to dumb luck of ocean currents that it went out to sea rather than hit the coast. But it happens a lot and is normally unreported. So you can pretty much bank in. There is going to be spills of various degrees, whether it's off the side of boats or you know, just random effluent that comes off these 50 odd rigs. You've got a pollution issue there as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, there have been multiple accidents at oil and gas rigs off the coast of Australia. And for any listeners that aren't familiar, the Montara spill in 2009 was, I think, the worst in Australia's history at the time, or at least in Western Australia's, it was devastating. And it was big enough that it could have devastated Australia's coast, but like Louise said, because of the wind at the time it drifted in the opposite direction, and instead it poisoned West Timor in Indonesia. So the local fisheries were devastated. Indonesian people and children were ill from being in and on the ocean. So those impacts, if they happen again, not only could it impact Scott Reef, it could drift the other way and end up on Karatha or some other community of Australia, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, it's just it's just gorgeous up that way.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Yeah. But you're looking at how much a humpy can about one and a half tons of krill a day just to keep moving per whale. I mean, that's a lot of feed, isn't it? That they that could ultimately just go. Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_02Such an important food base for all of them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for anyone that's been following Word on the Reef for a while, back in season one, episode nine and ten, I interviewed Di Tart and Eddie Hegel, who led the campaign back in the 1960s, to stop oil drilling on the Great Barrier Reef over on our side. And it was a mammoth campaign and a mammoth fight with a lot of government support for the oil drilling on the Great Barrier Reef that they were up against. But they were ultimately successful and they managed to stop it. And so now we have instead of lying on the beach in cans looking out and seeing a bunch of hideous oil rigs.
SPEAKER_04Oh god, just a thought of it.
SPEAKER_00Can you imagine?
SPEAKER_04No, I can't just no.
SPEAKER_00So that's what we would have had here if if we didn't have these passionate campaigners fighting that. But now to think that that sort of thing could still happen on the West Coast is very alarming. And of course, the gas will get pumped down that 800km pipeline to Karatha and processed. And in that area, the processing facility is also very close to some ancient Aboriginal carvings, which are also being impacted, aren't they, Louise?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and this is the part of the world I grew up on, so I'm quite passionate about this realm. This is a place known as Murajuga, and it's one of the most incredible petroglyphic rock art sites in the world. So this is tens and tens of thousands of years of cultural heritage. And the petroglyphs out there, there is carvings of stylocenes back in the day where stylocenes were up in the Kimberley area.
SPEAKER_00That's the Tasmanian tiger, for anyone that's not familiar, and they are now extinct.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah, we we managed to kill them all. Well, you know, and just species that are no longer there, and there's even a carving of someone saw a tall ship climbing. So you can you can really gauge how long this place has been used as a recording and an art and a cultural spot, from phylocenes to tall ships, are all documented there, and also people doing portraits of themselves, and of course, you know, hand, and there's wallaby and goanna and marine life. So Mora Jugger, it has to be seen to be believed. It is just incredible. And then the fossil fuel industry stuck a great stonking processing hub there called Northwest Shelf, which has a number of companies involved, Woodside being key amongst them now. They put in an application to extend the life of this gas hub out to 2070. And Friday of last week, the Albanese government, after so much opposition from so many parties, just went, Oh yeah, okay, you can extend it out to 2070. That said, a gas processing hub can only process gas if it's coming down the line. So yeah, it may even give an approval out to 2070, but it won't keep operating out to 2070 if there's no gas. And this is where it becomes so important that we stop these new gas proposals becoming approved and really get cracking on the no new fossil fuels towards a phase that if we have any hope of keeping climate change under 1.5, which is where we need it for the human animal to keep surviving, never mind, reefs and everything else.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, which, you know, there's so many direct impacts of this project from the drilling itself on the reef that we haven't even really uh talked about the climate impacts very much yet. But the fact that the Australian government is setting a 2035 climate target to phase out fossil fuels, but then with the other hand potentially approving this new gas proposal, it just doesn't really match up, does it, Louise?
SPEAKER_02Oh, it's completely cooked. Like there is no it is such an incredible example of cognitive dissonance of saying one thing, doing another, and then just trying to spin it in some media cycle of we're serious about climate action. If you're serious about climate action, you stop approving new fossil fuels, you get on with the business of transitioning to a renewable energy economy and work towards a phase out. We know what is causing catastrophic climate change. It's burning fossil fuels.
Does this Gas Project Have Any Benefits?
SPEAKER_00Well, it's clear that the project is going to have a devastating cost for the Australian people and our pristine oceans that we rely on so much. Who is actually going to benefit from this project?
SPEAKER_02Well, 80% of gas from this area gets exported to South Korea and Japan and a few other emerging buyers. Japan is a working example. It's not like they actually use it for their own domestic use. They on-sell it to a global market. So it's the shareholders of large fossil fuel companies who are benefiting. And yet another example of fabulous economics of fossil fuels where the profits are privatized and the damage and the harm is left to the public to pick up on whether that's from rising sea levels, worse cyclones, loss of ecosystems, oh, and a business that pays no tax, so doesn't contribute to any of our health systems or others, and is basically the gas industry is taking the picture.
SPEAKER_04How did they how did they get away with not paying tax? That's not cricket, I pay my tax.
SPEAKER_02Oh yeah, but you're not a fossil fuel company, are you?
SPEAKER_00Well So the big sell that they try to sell the benefits to the Australian people is the jobs, but I understand it's going to create 800 jobs. Sounds like a lot, but it's minuscule, you know, compared to Oh look, yeah.
SPEAKER_02If you do the jobs, if you're breaking it down to, you know, how much does say the health or the education or the fossil fuel industry employ? If you go on pure percentage, ninety-nine point, I think last I heard of eight percent of jobs in WA are not in the gas industry, put it that way.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Um pay tax, they don't pay royalties, they don't pay their petroleum resource rent tax, so they are absolutely taking the and this is an example of what happens when a government has been carbon captured. The fossil fuel industry is calling the shots, the state and federal governments in these very fossilized systems are doing what needs to be done to keep the donations going, to keep the relationships going. And we need to remember that the past five federal environment ministers, when I mean sorry, resource ministers need to clarify that. The past five federal resource ministers, when they finished in government, they went and worked for fossil fuel companies.
SPEAKER_00Wow, like I wonder what the connection could possibly be.
SPEAKER_02Honey. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00What a coincidence. So regarding the jobs as well, like 800 jobs for gas is it would be nothing on how many people depend on the ocean. We're talking about if there's an oil spill, it could be wiping out fishing industries, the tourism industry, you know, there are probably thousands of people. Yeah, local local communities. I mean, you can't put a price on children's health if they can't go for a swim in the ocean and be safe. And of course, you know, Ningaloo Reef just had that catastrophic bleaching and and the impact that that's having on tourism because of fossil fuel-driven climate change is obviously a cost way higher than
Can This Gas Proposal be Stopped?
SPEAKER_00the benefits. So is it possible to stop this proposal going ahead?
SPEAKER_02That is a very short, sharp answer of yes, it really is. So this is still a proposal and it is beset with so many problems, not only, you know, the stuff we've been unpacking of the environmental and climate, but 800 Ks of pipeline under sea, that's risks at a kilometer level. 50 gas wells of the engineering and the technical challenge there and the the cost. Like this is incredibly expensive. And as the world is transitioning away from fossil fuels and we're pretending that the world is just going to keep buying up our gas, there are a number of hurdles, shall we say, that the joint venture partners for this project really need to examine. And politically as well, if the Albanese government really wants to host COP 31 next year and look like we're being vaguely responsible with our Pacific partners, approving this carbon bomb and carbon dumping in our ocean is absolutely a step in the wrong direction. And I think they know they will lose a lot of skin if they approve that and then try and host COP and pretend to be doing something vaguely forward-looking on climate change.
What is Carbon Dumping?
SPEAKER_00Actually, just for any listeners that aren't familiar, we've we've already talked a bit about carbon dumping. But can you sum up what actually that is? What does it mean?
SPEAKER_02Ah, carbon dumping. So it's an absolute scam of a system where a, in this case, fossil fuel company looks to capture some of the CO2 waste from their mining, burning, whatever it is, hypercondense it. So that means taking CO2, which is normally a gaseous form, and cooling it to such extreme levels that it turns to liquid and condensifies and then inject it under the ground in some geological formation, which normally for fossil fuels is they've sucked something out, gas or petroleum, and then they're looking to pump CO2 back in. How this came about was in the North Sea back in the day, it got to a point where you can only suck so much gas out of a reservoir before the pressure's so low it's hard to get the last 30%. The engineers came up with a cracking idea of if we take some of that CO2 waste, push it back in and increase the pressure, it'll do a thing called enhanced well optimization and help us pump the last bits of oil or gas out of there. So you can see how it's the you know the most perverse version of the circular system. So that's how it was invented. What it's being used for now in the case of say Browse or Biound or Bioundan Bit EOR and others, is a way of dumping some CO2 under the ocean to cook your books to pretend it's not as a high polluting project as it really is. It also just doesn't work.
SPEAKER_04Correct me if I'm wrong because I'm I'm new to this bit, but wasn't that what happened to that deep water horizon rig that in the States that had that catastrophic explosion and fire that it had they were doing that back into the wells and it compressed and blew the whole thing up?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, Deep Well was a gas reinjection system and that's fairly normal. They do it a lot in the southeast of Australia, where it's almost like a um siphoning and re-injection and storage for when you need it later. But similar, you know, really similar issues if you are still pumping highly condensed and volatile substances in and out through pipelines. So, yeah, that's a real thing. CO2 won't go boom in quite the same way, if it's more of an issue if it'll suffocate whoever comes in contact with it.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so uh whoever's in charge of thinking this is a good idea, we need to put uh 230 decibel blast noise outside their office and then pump some CO2 under their desk for storage and see how they how they go. And then they can tell us that.
SPEAKER_04Just playing Justin Bieber over and over and over and over again.
SPEAKER_00230 decibels Justin Bieber.
SPEAKER_04Just nonstop. Or any music that was made after 2000.
SPEAKER_00Rett's going as a mate.
How Can People Join the Fight to Save Scott Reef?
SPEAKER_00All right, so what can people do to help support this campaign and help you protect Scott Reef, Louise? How can we make this better?
SPEAKER_02Thanks for the plug on that one. So our immediate short-term kind of solve on this one is Murray Watt, who's the Federal Environment Minister, has the power to reject these under the EPBC Act. So this is a federal government call of they can stop it now and stop it from you know progressing any further, costing us any more money and time, and protect Scott Reef. It really is a case of this is a decision that can save Scott Reef. You can head along to the Australian Marine Conservation website and hunt down, just put in Scott Reef as a search item, and that will give you both a bit of a visual of what's out there with lots of photos and images and links to various videos and the action to both the West Australian and the Federal Environment Ministers because they both currently have paperwork on their desk right now which they can either reject or approve.
SPEAKER_00Wow, so the time is critical, everyone. Make sure you go and sign those online petitions, which we'll send off to the ministers that Louise mentioned, because they are making that decision right now. So we need to be loud. We need as many people as possible to save Scott Reef.
SPEAKER_04If we start with every single certified scuba diver in the country, you guys go first, right? Get online, sign the petition, tell your mates to do it, anybody. Just get on and sign it. Let's get this done.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_04Let's get it done. This is just a joke.
SPEAKER_02If you're feeling super passionate, you can drop Minister Watts' office a call and just let them know that um deep support of him taking some proactive action to save Scott Reid from Fossil Field.
SPEAKER_04Otherwise, a delivery of a big speaker and Justin Bieber's on the way.
SPEAKER_00Google the Environment Minister's phone number, call him straight after this show, everyone. I've called many ministers before. They are obligated to take our calls, or at least their assistant is. So you can just leave a message for the minister with whoever takes the call. And yeah, make sure that you mention how passionate you are about protecting the marine life and that you would like the government to not approve the gas project on Scott Reef. So we've also got a documentary about the campaign to save Scott Reef. It's called Coral's Last Stand. And there's many screenings happening across Australia. So if you want to find out where one is near you, you can go along. Not only will you see this amazing documentary with all this amazing footage from Scott Reef and learn more about it, but you can obviously get some drinks and pizza and mingle with other like-minded people and uh get involved in some action and join the movement to save Scott Reef. So we have a screening of that DOCO in Cairns next Wednesday, 24th of September, 6 pm at the Salt House RSVP online if you're interested in coming and search for the Save Scott Reef campaign and the documentary film Coral's Last Stand. You can find a screening in many areas across Australia as well. So get involved. Louise Morris, Fossil Fuels Campaign Manager for the Australian Marine Conservation Society. Thanks so much for all your amazing work. Best of luck with the campaign. And thanks for joining us on the show today.
SPEAKER_04Yes, thank you, mate. Thank you for all your incredible work so much.
Our Second Guest, Lissa Schindler, on Australia's 2035 Climate Targets
SPEAKER_00Now, Brett, yesterday, Prime Minister Anthony Albanese announced Australia's 2035 climate target of 62 to 70%. The experts, though, say this falls far short of what's needed to protect our oceans and ourselves from the impacts of climate change. Here to explain more is Dr. Lisa Schindler, Great Barry Reef campaign manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society. Good morning, Dr. Schindler. Welcome to Word on the Reef. Hi, thanks.
SPEAKER_04Good morning.
SPEAKER_00Great to have you on the show. Now, Dr. Schindler, what does this target announcement mean for our oceans and our reef?
SPEAKER_01This target is really quite disappointing. So Australia and all other countries by the end of the year have to come up with this thing called a target, which basically shows what their commitment to cutting greenhouse gas emissions is to abate climate change. And really Australia's target puts us in line, especially at the 62% range, which is the bottom that they've put as their range. It puts us at around if all other countries did the same as Australia, we'd have about 2.4 degrees warming.
SPEAKER_00And what does that mean if we reach 2.4 degrees of warming?
SPEAKER_01So on Monday we had this really important report come out for the first time in Australia where it actually assesses all the different impacts that climate change will have in Australia based on the different temperature ranges. And what it shows that as we go beyond two degrees, we start to see really big impacts happening. So a lot more coastal flooding inundation. We see a lot of coral reefs being lost. There's modelling already that once we hit two degrees, that we will see 99% of some coral reefs lost. Incredibly distressing, especially when you live in areas like Cairns where many livelihoods depend on places like the Great Barrier Reef.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. We've got breaking 64,000 full-time jobs in Queensland depending on a healthy Great Barrier Reef. So from an economic perspective, it's very alarming to not have the highest climate ambitions. But it's also Cairns is also low-lying. We we had floods during Cyclone Jasper. So the sea level rise that we'll see at over two degrees of warming is going to be devastating for the community and not to mention people's insurance prices and and so on. So yeah, that was all revealed in the National Climate Risk Assessment report that you mentioned, which came out earlier this week. So the government's released this report saying that we've got these quite dire consequences for Australia if we don't take urgent action on climate change. And then later the same week they're announcing these targets which, as you say, may not be adequate for preventing those catastrophic effects. But Lisa, the climate change minister, Chris Bowen, has said a 2035 target above 70% is not achievable and claims the government's new goal is aligned with the global aim of limiting temperature rise to 1.5 degrees. So the government says they're doing everything possible. Do you agree?
SPEAKER_01Absolutely do not agree. And you will see that all the climate scientists that came out yesterday really slamming that target also don't agree. 62% is not in line with 1.5 degrees warming, and 70% even then is still not. Yes, 70% will be difficult, but there is analysis from experts showing that Australia could achieve more than 80% emissions reduction. It's ambitious, but we're at this point in time now. You know, we see the Great Barry Reef, there's been six mass bleaching events in the last nine years. Last year was the biggest coral loss on record. We're beyond business as usual, we need to be ambitious, and Australia needs to take the lead on this. We can't be saying, Well, other countries aren't doing that, so therefore we shouldn't. If Australia doesn't lead as the custodian of the Great Barrier Reef, who will?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. That's right. We can't be asking everyone else to protect it if we're not taking the lead ourselves. So Anthony Albanese had a landslide victory back in May, and it was evident that climate change was a top election issue, especially for young people. Since being elected, how well do you think Anthony Albanese is performing on addressing the climate concerns of the Australian people? Report cards so far.
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, just before they announced the climate target this week, last week, they gave the final approval for a gas project called the North West Shelf, which will my children will be in their fifties when this one runs out. So to then approve that and then release that report of what's at stake for Australians and then come out with a lower climate target than what they could have. It sort of speaks volumes as to where the government's priorities are.
How Can People Help Fight for Stronger Climate Targets for our Oceans?
SPEAKER_00Is there still time for this target to be changed? And is there something people can do to help?
SPEAKER_01Well, I mean, this is just one point in time and it doesn't mean that just because this target has come out today that they won't improve it in the future. I think the biggest thing Australians can do at the moment is discuss how this is not good enough, let the government know this is not good enough and that we expect more. Obviously, between now and 2035 there will be many elections to show governments that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. So if there's any listeners out there that want to find out more, I encourage them to check out the Australian Marine Conservation Society website. There's some petitions you can sign to send off and make sure we keep letting governments know that we want the strongest possible climate action to save our reef and ultimately save ourselves. So, Dr. Lisa Schindler, Great Barry Reef campaign manager for the Australian Marine Conservation Society, thanks so much for your amazing work and thanks for joining us on the show today.
SPEAKER_04Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Have a great day.
SPEAKER_00And for all our Cairns listeners, the Australian Youth Climate Coalition and the Cairns and Far North Environment Centre are hosting a peaceful action outside our local Federal MP Matt Smith's office on Monday at 4 pm with the theme Labor is asleep on climate. So asking for those 2035 climate targets to be strengthened. Wear your pajamas and meet outside the electorate office on the corner of Mulgrave Road and Ormuller Street if you're interested in uh letting the government know that you'd like stronger climate targets and for them to not snooze on this issue. That's 4 p.m. on Monday. There'll also be lots more information in the show notes with some of the links to the topics we discussed today and more actions you can take to help. All right. What a jam packed show for it.
SPEAKER_04Well, we can start with the so much going on. Environments, we've got a stake here for a little fixed.
SPEAKER_00So thanks to you all the listeners for joining us on Facebook. Thanks to everyone, and don't forget to follow us on Instagram at Instagram.com slash follows at all.