Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E21: SPOTTED: The Great Barrier Reef's first known Whale Shark Aggregation Site
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Whale sharks—harmless, majestic giants—have long been mystery visitors on the Great Barrier Reef, their movements shrouded in secrecy... until now. In a groundbreaking discovery, scientists have identified the Reef’s first known whale shark aggregation site. Join us as we uncover where these elusive creatures have been hiding with Ingo Miller—marine biologist turned shark detective. On a mission to find and protect the world’s largest fish before it’s too late, Ingo followed the clues to their secret gathering spot. Want to know where it is? You’ll have to tune in to find out.
LEARN MORE
- Biopixel Oceans Foundation Website: biopixeloceans.org
- Follow Ingo on Instagram: www.instagram.com/ingo.ben.miller
- Follow Biopixel Oceans Foundation on Insta: www.instagram.com/biopixeloceans
- Track the tagged whale sharks: biotracker.tv
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Hey there! Before we dive in, just a quick favour to ask. If you're enjoying the show, don't be shellfish. Please take a moment to rate and review it wherever you're listening. It helps more people find us in the big blue ocean of podcasts. You can also support us by hitting that follow or subscribe button, following us on Instagram at Word on the Wreath Podcast, and sharing the podcast link with a friend who might love it too. Thanks so much. Now let's get into today's episode. Before we start this episode, I'd just like to acknowledge the Gimoy Walubarayudinji people and the Irakanji people on whose land this podcast is recorded. As well as the other 70 traditional owner groups whose sea country makes up the Great Valley Reef, and pay my respects to elders, past, present, and emerging.
SPEAKER_03Good morning. Hey guys, how are you?
SPEAKER_00Now, Brett, I'm going to start today with a joke.
SPEAKER_03Okay, let's do it.
SPEAKER_00What do whales listen to to pass the time on long journeys?
SPEAKER_03I don't know. Hit me with it.
SPEAKER_00Podcasts.
SPEAKER_03Oh, okay.
SPEAKER_00So be like a whale, everyone. Tune in, listen to your uh Great Fairy Reef podcasts. But today we're not actually talking about whales, we're talking about whale sharks. And if you asked the average person whether they'd like to swim with a 60-foot-long shark, you might get nervous laughter. But the whale shark is actually completely harmless. They only eat plankton. Plankton. Hence the name, whale shark. And they are absolutely gorgeous, majestic, gentle giants. They've got beautiful galaxy patterns of white spots on their back, and tourists travel from all over the world to swim with them in hot spots like Ningaloo Reef in Western Australia. Have you ever swam with a whale shark, Brett?
SPEAKER_03I have. I had the privilege once, yeah, up in the Northern Coral Sea.
SPEAKER_00Tell us, how did you come across it? What happened?
SPEAKER_03Well, I was actually just filming off the corner of Osprey, and I was filming some sharks, and I saw this massive figure come out of the corner of the darkness, and I thought, yes, it's a big time, and then I realised it has a massive mouse and it didn't quite look like a tiger shark, and I went, Oh, she was beautiful. She just graced past and said hello and left.
SPEAKER_00Oh, beautiful. It's it's so nice when they naturally by chance Yeah, they just give you that look of hey gun, just passing through. Yeah, because I know in Ningaloo they use spotter planes and drones to help them find them to go swim with them. But for you and some other lucky people, when they just the whale sharks decide that it's time today for them to see a whale shark.
SPEAKER_03That's the best connection you can have, isn't it? That's when animals just turn up, say good-day, and then leave.
SPEAKER_00They bless you with their presence. Okay, well, yes, I have swum with a whale shark in the Philippines, but not seen one on the Great Barrier Reef, even though I've been diving on the Great Barrier Reef for 15 years. And that's because on the Great Barrier Reef, the movements of whale sharks have long been a mystery. Yes. Scientists have never been able to pinpoint exactly where and when they gather. Until now. Oh. That's right. Today's show is about a major breakthrough in whale shark science. Researchers have discovered the first known whale shark aggregation site on the Great Barrier Reef.
SPEAKER_03Oh, stop it.
SPEAKER_00It's so exciting. And the man who recently published his research about the discovery of the whale shark's secret hangout spot is in the room with us. Yes. Ingo Miller, marine biologist with Biopixel Oceans Foundation and James Cook University PhD candidate. Good morning, Ingo.
SPEAKER_03Good morning. Good morning, Ingo. Thanks for joining us, buddy. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_00It's great to have you on the show. And congratulations on winning the world's largest game of hide and seek with the world's largest shark.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's good. Thank you.
SPEAKER_00And uh in case any listeners aren't aware, you're um related to some other people that we've had on the show. So we've had your brother Christian Miller was on our show earlier this year talking about his whale research. And the whale snot. And the whale snot and what we can learn about whales from their snot. That's right. And you also work with uh Richard Fitzpatrick, who was on our show just a few weeks ago talking about all other types of sharks like great white sharks and tiger sharks that he has spent a lot of time researching. But before we reveal where the whale sharks are hanging out,
An unexpected career path
SPEAKER_00all our listeners hang around if you want to find out where they are. But before we do that, let's circle back to the start of the story. You grew up in Germany, Ingo, which is not exactly known for its coral reefs. So, how did you end up devoting your life to the ocean and shark research?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so I guess my story is quite different from most marine bottologists that I know that have grown up by the sea and it's always been in their DNA kind of. Yeah, I grew up in southern Germany in the black forest far away from any ocean. And in fact, I was actually quite scared about anything in the water when I grew up. Partly because I grew up with jaws. Yeah, so I was just I was actually quite scared about sharks my whole childhood.
SPEAKER_00So back then you never would have guessed that you would end up what you're doing now. It's crazy.
SPEAKER_02No, no one would have. My career path hasn't been linear at all. So I I didn't leave school and went into marine bio. I was actually a car mechanic first, then I was in the army for a few years, and then when I was 30, I started to enroll at uni for my bachelor's in environmental management.
SPEAKER_00There you go, everyone. It's never too late to start your dream dream life on the reef.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and then uh for my masters, I wanted to get into marine science because in the meantime I've started scuba diving. Actually, my brother Christian he lives here in Cairns and he used to work as a diving instructor. So I came over and visited him and he basically signed me up for an open water course and uh threw me into the open water basically.
SPEAKER_00Um threw you and fed you to the sharks. Big brothers are so mean like that, aren't they?
SPEAKER_02So mean, yeah. But it actually brainwashed me, it changed my perspective. But when I saw a shark on my first dive, it was just amazing.
SPEAKER_03And then you had salt water in your veins from that point. Yes, he got into the soul.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. And then uh during my master's, I did an exchange semester at JCU and uh a research project, and that's where I got to know my now supervisor Adam Bonnet and Richard Fitzpatrick, and uh got into the shark science.
SPEAKER_00Awesome. And just briefly, though, I know you've done a bit of coral research as well. Can you briefly tell us about that before we get back to the whale sharks?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so for my bachelor's thesis, I looked into microplastics and hard corals, how they take it up, and uh we actually found that they build it up into their skeletons, which was quite new and uh kind of scary.
SPEAKER_00I've heard about that, and so you're involved with that. So the corals are ingesting tiny fragments of plastic and laying it down into their skeleton. How scary is that?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, that's horrifying, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00So we're gonna end up with instead of limestone corals, we're going to have plastic corals.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, hopefully not. Hopefully not.
SPEAKER_00That's that's what we've got to try and avoid.
SPEAKER_01Yep.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so let's talk about the whale sharks. So, Ingo, for any listeners who might never have
Why whale sharks are awesome
SPEAKER_00seen one, what is a whale shark and what makes them so special?
SPEAKER_02I mean, you perfectly introduced them already. So they they are not a whale, they are not shark, and they are in fact the biggest fish alive, and probably the biggest fish ever lived. And they grow up to 20 meters, weigh several tons, they have the thickest skin in the animal world, up to 30 centimeters thick. Wow. They grow slow, they mature late, and they are an endangered species, so they're globally endangered, and they're declining their populations worldwide. And they're just really, really pretty and gentle, and they're absolutely not dangerous to humans because all they are interested in is zooplankton.
SPEAKER_00So here's a fact I adore. What is the collective noun for a group of whale sharks?
SPEAKER_02So usually we call a group of animals that garter an aggregation. But for whale sharks, we want to make it a thing to call them a constellation, and that is a a nod to their star-like patterns that they have on their skin, and we can actually use those starlike patterns to identify individual sharks and match them against databases. And they look like star patterns. And the software that we use for that has originally been designed to identify star patterns.
SPEAKER_03I tell my guests during my shark show that we call a group of whale sharks constellation, and they just love it, right? Yeah, but it's just a much prettier name as well. So you're saying that you're using computer technology to be able to work out which whale sharks are which by the patterns of their stars on their skin. Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_00And and he said that it's the technology that was developed to recognize constellations in the sky. Yes. Is that what you said? Yes. Same technology is being used to recognize the the patterns on the whale sharks. How cool is that?
SPEAKER_03Pretty cool. Gives you goosebumps, doesn't it? So cool.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so before we dive
Where in the world are the whale sharks?
SPEAKER_00into the Great Barrier Reef part of this story, let's zoom out briefly. Where else in the world do whale sharks typically aggregate?
SPEAKER_02So they live in the tropical warm waters and subtropical warm waters around the globe, and we know of about 30 whale shark aggregations. And they're usually in coastal areas. You know, the thing is with whale sharks being a filter feeder, it's quite different from other filter feeders like whales. They migrate to polar regions. Colder water has much more nutrients, and that's where they feed. But whale sharks, on the contrary, they live in the warm waters, which are not very productive actually.
SPEAKER_00There's not as much krill.
SPEAKER_02Yes, exactly. So they have to travel long distances to find pulses of plankton explosions, basically. And they occur seasonally, usually, and in coastal areas.
SPEAKER_03How much of these poor little planktons do they need to consume a day? I mean, they're pretty scared these little plankton when they see them coming. Oh probably. How much do they have to ingest to those things? Oh tons of it, yeah. A lot.
SPEAKER_00There's a lot of them in the ocean, I guess, is what we take from that.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, yeah. And there's aggregations that, you know, what the most iconic ones that we know of in Mexico, Yucatan, and Indonesia, and of course, most famously for us here in Australia, uh, Ningalu and WA. Yes.
SPEAKER_00But sightings of whale sharks on the Great Barrier Reef
Whale sharks on the Great Barrier Reef
SPEAKER_00have been quite unpredictable up until now, Ingo. Whale sharks are up to 19 meters long. How did they hide from us for so long on the Great Barrier Reef?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, good question.
SPEAKER_03They've been around a while.
SPEAKER_02Well, they've been around a while. There's uh there's a lot of evidence of whale shark sightings along the coast and on the Great Bear Reef, even as far south as New South Wales.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_02But it's very sporadically and it wasn't really predictable, and it's usually solitary animals.
SPEAKER_00On the Word on the Reef podcast, I've interviewed a diver called Tarn Miller from Wavelength Cruisers in Port Douglas. He was lucky enough just on an average day tour boat off of Port Douglas to come across a wild shark and swim with it. And there's been a couple of hundred people, I guess, that have had that experience over the past couple of decades. But it's always just been one. It's always just been passing through. Nobody knows where they go. So for your PhD, which started back in was it 2020?
Playing Shark Detective
SPEAKER_022022.
SPEAKER_00Okay. For your PhD, you basically became a sharp detective. But instead of tracking footprints, you are tracking fin prints.
SPEAKER_03Oh, I want I want that job.
SPEAKER_00So tell us how you did it. Did you tap their phones and record their conversations? Did you hack their emails? Did you bug their group chat?
SPEAKER_02Well, there was a few different steps that we had to do to find a segregation site. First of all, you can't just go out there and try to find them because it's going to be too expensive because they're so sporadically sighted on the Grabberry Reef. So we didn't know where to look for.
SPEAKER_00No, so you couldn't you couldn't swim the 2,400 kilometers and just swim around and look at it.
SPEAKER_02So we collected all the sightings data that was available on public databases like Eye on the Reef or Shark Book and others.
SPEAKER_00Shark Book? I've never heard of it. Oh, it's a good one. I'm closing down my Facebook account. The only book I want is Shark Book.
SPEAKER_02Facebook what? Yeah, so we collected all the information that we could find on any encounters along the East Coast, mapped them on a map just to find out where are they, when are they sighted, and how many. And just from that map, we found that there's just a few spots where there was more than one shark sighted. And we also talked to fishers because they go to spots where tourists don't go. Usually the sightings are at tourist spots, and fishers usually don't report their sightings because they have other things to do. So we talk to fishers, we talk to other scientists, like mammal scientists that do aerial surveys, all sorts of information, and we looked into other aggregation sites, what kind of environments they like to aggregate in, and looked at spots at the Great Bear Reef that match these kind of features.
SPEAKER_00Alright, so we can barely hold the suspense any longer. The
THE BIG REVEAL: The GBR Whale Shark Aggregation
SPEAKER_00moment of revelation has arrived. Drum roll, please.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00Alright, go for it. Where is the whale shark aggregation site on the Great Barrier Reef?
SPEAKER_02So it's a reef site called Wreck Bay in the far northern Great Bear Reef.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_02It is quite remote.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Right now. But okay, hold up, Brett. Before people start booking flights to go and see these whale sharks, Rec Bay isn't exactly just around the corner, is it? So how how remote are we talking? How do you get there?
SPEAKER_02Well you get there by boat from Cairns usually. And it takes about two days to get up there. And it is located on the outer reef, right at the shelf between Lockhart River and Rain Island.
SPEAKER_00For context, Lockhart River is a tiny community of only roughly 600 people, and it's 750 kilometers drive from Cairns to get to Lockhart River. But if you want to get there on a boat, then it's a two-day boat trip. So this is not much up there, is all we're saying.
SPEAKER_02No. How far off the coast is it? Oh, it's like 60 nautical miles off the coast. So it's not only remote as in distance from here north. So it's also quite wild.
SPEAKER_03Are we up as far as Osprey? Are we further down? Where are we in relation to that?
SPEAKER_02I think it's further north actually. Yeah, definitely.
SPEAKER_00Help us imagine that we are there. Paint us a picture. The first time you dived or snorkeled at Rec Bay and saw the hidden whale shark gathering, what was that like?
SPEAKER_02I mean, it's amazing. But maybe for context, I gotta expand a little. So it's it's not like uh an accreation like in Qatar or so where there's hundreds of sharks just on the surface ready for you to find them. They're quite spread out and they're hard to find. So we need a spotter plane to find them, we need drones in the air, and it's it's logistically quite a mission to actually find them. But once you got them and you're in the water with them, it's just amazing. And I gotta reveal, I've never seen a bow shark before I started this research.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_02To swim with them is just so amazing. It's hard to describe, you've got to experience it. Probably those bell sharks up there have never seen humans before, because we have no evidence yet that they aggregate somewhere else. So they're quite shy. Uh so you've got to give them some time to get used to yourself.
SPEAKER_03That must have been just such an amazing experience for you. All this study that you've done, and then to be face to face with that beautiful animal in the water must have been pretty special. Yeah, definitely.
SPEAKER_00Rec Bay, it's a underwater bay, as in like it's a sort of a crescent shape of underwater reefs, which sort of forms an underwater bay, right? So that is quite big, and that's why you know the whale sharks are in Wreck Bay, but that is still a really huge bay, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and uh they're not hanging out only in Wreck Bay. It's just that the hotspot, which we know now from satellite tracking data. They are hanging out in a larger area around Rec Bay, north and south on the shelf. Right. So it's just a a large area where they seem to hang out.
SPEAKER_03So I guess the burning question is why? Why have they picked that spot?
SPEAKER_02So we think it's a feeding aggregation like most other Welsh aggregations globally. And they come to the coast to find these rich dense patches of zoo plankton to have a good meal. And uh so it's not reproduction because another thing that we found through our research is all of them are juveniles, so they're below eight meters, so they're not mature yet, they don't reproduce yet.
SPEAKER_00And uh most of them are just little babies hanging out.
SPEAKER_02Babies would be awesome. You're not babies, they're just uh teenagers.
SPEAKER_00So it is the hangout spot. It's like you know, behind the bike racks or whatever.
SPEAKER_03So were they all sort of laying on their back with their eye fish out? Tap and Google and shark.
SPEAKER_00Okay, so we've got juvenile whale sharks getting together for a feast of plankton. Okay, so how many of them are we talking about? Is it a small small gathering or a full full-blown Corey Worthington party of teenage whale sharks? So they're quite a lot.
SPEAKER_02It's not as many as other aggregation sites, but it's probably because it's a larger area. So we've photo-identified 59 individuals now over the four field trips that we've done up there. So it's compared to other sites that have been known of for longer, not many, but we just started the research there, and we only go up there for five days per season, and we can't go up there every year. So it's only a limited number of days that we spent up there actually during the season. But considering that we found quite a lot, and each time we go up there we find more sharks, so we seem to get better at allocating them as well.
SPEAKER_00So before and after these whale sharks
Tagging & Tracking: Where do they go?
SPEAKER_00aggregate for their secret meeting in Rack Bay, do you know where do they come from and where do they go? Where do they come from? Cottonide Ingo.
SPEAKER_03Oh, yeah, geez, you're pulling out the big guns today, right?
SPEAKER_02So obviously, we didn't only go up there to find them and take photos, we also put satellite trackers on them. So that enables us to, whenever they come to the surface when there's satellites around, they give us a location. And we know when and where they were. And uh from that data, so we have tagged just over 40 individuals by now. So we know they hang out there in November and December, and by January they start to leave into the Coral Sea. And once they left, they go just the individual ways, they don't hang out together anymore because they are solitary animals, they only come together for feeding and probably some somewhere for mating, which we don't know. And once they go, they disperse into the Coral Sea very far south and north and wide. Uh, some of them seem to go to the Gulf of Papua. There seems to be another hotspot because uh some of our individuals have been tracked up until then. They spend uh quite some time uh around the Port Moresby area. There's a lot of rivers, so there's probably sp some productivity going on as well. And some went even as far as the Solomon Sea before the tags ran out of battery.
SPEAKER_00How long do the tags last for?
SPEAKER_02Depending on which model we use, up to four years technically. But we use a clamp system to put it on a dorsal fin so they can also come off and get eaten or whatever. So um we have in Bashack research we do have a bit of a problem with tag retention times, uh like how long they last. But we have tracked one individual just over two years, which is pretty impressive. And that shark came back twice to Red Bay, so it was in Rag Bay at least three times uh in a row. And there's another individual that came back in the following year. Uh so we have some evidence of returning, which is great, so it's not a one-off thing for them individually, so they do come back.
SPEAKER_00It's an annual festival, a feast. It's like their annual Christmas party in Rat Bay where they all get together and uh argue about politics and ask their nieces why they're not married yet and things like that. Oh glad, I forgot they're all teenagers.
SPEAKER_03Yes, yeah, they're not worried about that yet.
SPEAKER_00So in order to tag all these whale sharks, you jump in the water and you swim down. How do you tag them?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we do that free swimming uh on snorkel. Not even use scuba gear or anything. We we need to be quick because they uh They swim fast.
SPEAKER_00They have huge tails.
SPEAKER_03Yeah, one flick of that tail and they're gone.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, once they kick there, it's hard to follow.
SPEAKER_00Out there swimming around the ocean chasing after whale sharks, trying to catch them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so we use the spotter plane to locate them first, and then they give us a location, then a drone comes in and locks onto the shark while it's on the surface, and then we on the tender go out with the tagging team, find the shark, and then we go in the water. We take photos first because that's the easiest thing to do. Then we have an ID on the shark, and we can match it against the global database to find out if it's been spotted somewhere else, which is good to answer questions about connectivity, stuff like that. And then we put a satellite tag on, and it is on a clamp, so we just slide it onto their dorsal fin so we don't, you know, there's minimal harm. Minimal harm to an animal, and also we you know, it's swimming, we can't do we can't do much, and we don't want to catch that big animal, so we just slide the tag on.
SPEAKER_00So you're not just gonna like grab it with a hook like Richard Fitzpatrick does with his tiger shark?
SPEAKER_02Uh no, not not with these ones.
SPEAKER_00Just to probably sink your boat. I saw really cool uh research in Western Australia where one snorkeling researcher scratches the whale shark around its mouth, which they accept because it's what the cleaner fish do. Yeah. To and then it will slow down. So the other snorkeling researcher can go and do the whatever they need to do. So maybe you've got to try that technique.
SPEAKER_03I've tried that. Yeah. So just pretend that you're a big cleaner ass.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because whale sharks will let other fish pick the parasites out of their mouth and things like that. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, that's a as a human if you do a motion like scratching its mouth.
SPEAKER_03You need to dress up in like a big clean arass suit.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. With a sexy stripe down.
SPEAKER_03Dress up in a big blue shark suit and scratch the front of her.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I think you should try it. I'll give it a crack.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Our guest today is Ingo Miller, marine biologist with the Biopixel Oceans Foundation, and part of a team of scientists who recently discovered the Great Barrier Reeves first known whale shark aggregation site. And we were just talking about how Ingo and the other researchers needed to dive down and attach tracking devices to these whale sharks and were able to track where they went and also take photos of them and they can use the spots on the whale sharks to identify individuals. Ingo, did you get to name the 40 whale sharks that you tagged?
SPEAKER_02No, I actually haven't named any, but they do have names. But the satellite tags are usually sponsored. Um they get to name them. Okay, so you've got Coca-Cola whale shark and Pepsi Shark and Well the first one was actually called GBR1.
SPEAKER_00GBR1. Patient Zero of the Great Barrier Reef Whale Sharks. But but there's one called Ingo, isn't there? Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, one of the things that you're doing with the smile on his face is like, yeah, there is.
SPEAKER_00So you have one named after you.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Well I didn't do that. I would never do that.
SPEAKER_00No, no. And you said that you had the ability to track your spotty friend Ingo. Can you just look on your computer at any point in time and see where he's hanging at?
SPEAKER_02Yes, I can, but you can too. So we have a website where we put our tracks on and it's live tracking, so it's updating every morning. So just Google BioTracker Sharks and you will find it. There's also all sorts of sharks that we track at BioPixologians Foundation are up there.
SPEAKER_00I'm gonna go and check out and find out where Ingo is after this show. So I understand while you were in Rec Bay,
Shark Body Cam: Day in the life of a whale shark
SPEAKER_00you put a camera on a whale shark to film what it was up to. So can you tell us what you saw on the shark body cam?
SPEAKER_02So it was actually quite hard to get this camera on. We had several goes. We wanted to do this on the first day up there, but it didn't work. The camera came off all the time. And so we had to leave it to the last day to put this camera on, which is not ideal. And that camera is supposed to come off after two hours, which it didn't.
SPEAKER_00So it's supposed to float to the surface and then with the GPS you can break down.
SPEAKER_02Yep, exactly.
SPEAKER_00It the whale shark was holding onto it. It's like, nah, you're not getting this back.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, but we didn't know because we thought it can't be because it was like hour after hour, and it can't be that it's still on, like physically it can't still be on because the clamp dissolves and and comes off. Right. So we had to look for this camera floating somewhere on the surface. So we were we feared that maybe the shark went out into the call Z quite far, and we just couldn't get a signal. But then by nighttime, that's when we get the best satellite coverage, we actually got a signal, and then uh we tracked down that signal and we found a shark on the surface and had this attack still on, so we had to jump in the water and get this tag off the animal in the middle of the night. There was like no moonlight, nothing. But we got it back and we had the full four hours of battery life and memory of footage on it, and it's quite cool. So that shark was just hanging around in Rag Bay during the day, coming up to the surface just sometimes, not a lot, and seemed like it was keeping himself busy by following other animals around. It saw another shark, another bell shark underwater. Yeah, it followed around some silver tip sharks under reef. Oh, he's just hanging out with his mics. Just hanging out there, like just skilling so cool.
SPEAKER_00Guys, guys, wait, wait. Yeah, try to make friends.
SPEAKER_02At one time it came to the surface and we could see our research ship. It's looking at you, it's stalking you. Yeah, we are out there trying to find them, and they just like in the distance looking at us.
SPEAKER_03And then he's just showing small fish at you.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Uh yeah, that was quite exciting. That was the first camera deployment that we did. It's quite interesting because we only get them on the surface, so we don't really know what they do, and the fact that we need a plane to find them, and we know it from the tracking data, that they don't spend a lot of time on the surface during the day. So we think they feed at night, actually. We've actually observed it. So it's cool to see what they do actually. They're just killing time during the day, apparently.
SPEAKER_00Just ran a few errands, just hanging out, you know.
SPEAKER_03Hit the coffee club, couple lattes.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So do you have any idea whether the Great Barrier Reef whale
Mysteries yet to be discovered
SPEAKER_00sharks are the same population as the ones seen in Western Australia or elsewhere?
SPEAKER_02So we don't know yet exactly. So we would need to do DNA analysis to do that, but we haven't gone that far yet. But it's probably so it's suggested that the Ningaloo population and the Indo is the same subpopulation. So it would make sense that ours are probably belonging to that population as well genetically, but we don't know yet. And we have no evidence as of yet that there's any connectivity. So we haven't identified any Ningaloo sharks on the Great Bear Reef or any of the Indo sharks at the Great Bear Reef and the other way around. So we are still waiting. We need to collect more data to get their full movement range to find out that story and oh what a shame.
SPEAKER_03You're just gonna have to hang out with them for a bit longer. Oh yeah, it's such a shame.
SPEAKER_00Here's what I want to know: where are the parents? Why are these juvenile delinquents being allowed to hang around in Rat Bay by themselves?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's how irresponsible. That is the number one question we all want to know. Yep. We don't really know where the where the adults are, where they're made, where the babies are.
SPEAKER_03And that's something you're still trying to work out, right? So that's the big question.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's what every well shark researcher is trying to do. Where are they having their babies? So there's there's one well shark aggregation in the South Atlantic, Santa Helena, where there is adult females and males, but it's in the middle of the ocean. It's so we assume that they're probably mating somewhere in the middle of the sea. An island in the middle of nowhere, that's a good spot to find both sexes of adult sharks. But that research has also only recently started a few years ago. Uh so there's so much more to find out.
SPEAKER_03That'd be so cool. Because we know that the courting behavior of marine animals is so spectacular. And imagine being able to catch that. That would be amazing. Wow.
SPEAKER_00What zoning or level of protection does
Humans and the GBR's Whale Sharks
SPEAKER_00Rec Bay have with regards to fishing activities and visitation? And do you think the whale sharks are safe there?
SPEAKER_02So most of Rec Bay is actually in a green zone. So that's good. It's a no-tag zone, so fishing shouldn't be an issue right there. But obviously, they're not just hanging out there, they only come there for a few weeks and then they move away across international waters and other zones in the Coral Sea and whatnot. And so as for fishing here at our aggregation site, I don't think it's much of an issue. It's also not heavily visited, so because it's so remote, there's only a few boats going out there. But there is a very busy shipping lane going past that aggregation site. So there could potentially be an issue. That's one thing we're looking at.
SPEAKER_00Is that on the inside or the outside?
SPEAKER_02It is actually on the inside. I thought it would be on the outside, but it's it's the inside.
SPEAKER_00There's thousands of bulk carriers, particularly for coal export as well as uh imports and exports of other things. But we have thousands of coal export ships plowing the waters of the Great Barrier Reef every year from ports like Mackay and Gladstone and Abbott Point. So yeah, the Great Barrier Reef, sadly and surprisingly, is a mega highway for giant ships. Yeah. And so what impact do you think that might have on the whale sharks?
SPEAKER_02We don't really know yet. So the fact that it's going on the inside is probably a good thing because they're not moving into the aggregation from the inside, I guess. They're coming from the outside and from the south.
SPEAKER_00So it's probably a good thing that it's on the inside, but we have to do some modelling and because you said they spend time feeding on the surface, and that's when strikes could be a problem, right?
SPEAKER_02And strikes is actually one of the biggest issues for bile sharks globally, um, apart from fishing and climate change is another obvious one.
SPEAKER_03I guess that's the other side of it now, also, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02It's trying to work out how climate change is affecting their behaviors and their patterns and then that's a hard thing to do for marine animals because sea surface temperature is gonna increase, so they might shift south, but they could also just dive deeper. But it's also very important to find out what is their prey gonna do. How is that how is that important site, that habitat changing with climate change, is it still gonna be so productive, or will they have to find a new site?
SPEAKER_03Yeah, food supply is gonna change as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's why this baseline information is important, so we can see how it changes in the future. Or it may have already changed. Maybe they used to hang out just off of cairns and they don't anymore, you know.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00So do you think we'll see sustainable tourism operators one day taking people out to see the whale sharks at Wreck Bay like they do in Western Australia?
SPEAKER_02I'm not sure if it's gonna be that busy as over there, because it's not only remote, it's also far away from the coast. Yeah and there's nothing up there. Yeah, so I'm not sure. But some of the boats going out of cairns, they go to this area. They go up to Saunders Reef and Mantis Reef and in Wreck Bay. So they could potentially, you know, when they go up there during November and December, they could have an eye on it and find them.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so there's only a couple of tourist boats that go up as far as the far northern reef. It's further north than the ribbon reefs, right? Like way, way further. Yep. It's probably somewhere that Spirit of Cans or Mike Ball might occasionally go to. Those are two. Geez, you'd need your sea legs. Yeah, it's a it's a long, long way there and a long two days just to get there, two days just to get back, and then if you want to have time to actually see stuff, then there's a few more days in between. So it's like a minimum week uh cruise that's thousands of dollars. So any anyone out there that's that's uh ready to jump on a plane, come see the whale sharks, it might be not the most accessible place, which isn't necessarily a bad thing. Some people are probably thinking, why can't we just leave these whale sharks alone to have their secret meetings in peace? But from a scientific and conservation perspective, why was finding these whale sharks and their aggregation site important?
SPEAKER_02So, as I mentioned before, whale sharks are an endangered species globally and also regionally here in the Indo-Pacific region, and they are protected species in Australia, and this whole part of an ocean like the South West Pacific, east of Australia, has been a blind spot in the global distribution of bell sharks. So they have been missing from past population assessments and and frets assessments. Uh so the data that we gather here that will be important for future assessments. And well shark scientists around the world are actually they're really interested in what's going on here because it has been a blind spot, but it was obvious there must be an aggregation somewhere because we have balsharks on the East Coast. So yeah, it's good that we know of now. I don't think it's a good idea to just keep it a secret and hope for the best because they are endangered, the populations are declining, yeah, and the threats are not going to go away from them just by ignoring the fact that they're here.
SPEAKER_00Let's expand on that a little bit more.
Threats to whale sharks
SPEAKER_00They are officially endangered. So we touched on it before, but what are the main threats to them and what needs to be done to protect them?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So main threats globally are fishing. It's often by catch.
SPEAKER_00So they will get accidentally caught in fishing nets.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, and tuna fisheries, for example. They're actually partly target. It's not happening as much anymore, but it uh historically they have been targeted because well sharks are like big fish aggregation devices. Right? So there's where there's well sharks in their open motion, there's tuna. And so they targeted well sharks because they're easier to see. And then they just put their nets around them so they can end up in bike hatch.
SPEAKER_00Not eating tuna is is is probably gonna be helpful.
SPEAKER_02I just yeah, I just struggle to see how anyone can do something like that. Yeah, and then the other big the big one is shipping vessel strikes. Yeah, in busy shipping lane. These big ships, they can't slow down even if they saw the shark in front of them. Yeah. It just takes too much time. And but the thing is with wild sharks, they they don't beach, they sink. When they die, they sink. So we don't have much evidence of actually of of wild sharks dying from ships, but we have a lot of photo evidence of injuries and aggregation sites. So that's a big threat. And then climate change is another big one.
SPEAKER_03I guess would that be something to look at, like getting on board with some of these big bulk carrier companies and the shipping companies to highlight when they see them or if they accidentally strike them to sort of get an idea?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, definitely. So I think that's something for the Great Bear Reef Marine Park Authority, I guess, to to manage as well, if we find that this is a a potential risk. Um, you know, they could slow down the ships during the time they aggregate or which I think they're doing with whales, aren't they overseas at the moment?
SPEAKER_03Somewhere in Europe they're doing that with the big ships where they've got like a detector on the ship that can tell when the whales are moving and the orcas are moving around and they can go around them and avoid those areas so they don't strike them.
SPEAKER_00That sounds like a good idea. So uh now that you've cracked the case, what's next? More research, more field trips to hang out with your giant spotty friends?
SPEAKER_02Uh yeah, hopefully. So we'll be looking into doing more research up there, but it's yeah, it's obviously pretty hard to obtain the funding to go up there every year because it's quite expensive. But we hope we can continue. I think we need to track many more to get their whole movement range. And uh hopefully the Great Bear Reef Marine Park Africa is going to be a bit more interested in this aggregation side soon because they haven't shown much interest as of yet. It's puzzling. Some reasons. And for me, the next thing that I'm currently working on is uh assessing the risks, like shipping climate change, microplastics actually as well.
SPEAKER_00So we were just talking about the threats and then we got sidetracked. But back to those threats, what are the impacts of climate change on whale sharks?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, so there isn't that much research yet. So what we do is we do some models, we use sea surface temperature and try to estimate how their distribution is going to change in the future. But I think there's much more to be done and the models have to become better. But it has been shown, and that's just what happens with most other species. It's predicted that the more climate change progresses and the more greenhouse gases we put into the atmosphere, the the higher the likelihood is of the sharks having to move further south because it's just getting too warm. Um so that's I ran some models as well lately, and it's showing the same thing on the current pathway of a climate change scenario that we are currently on, with not doing much about it. Rag Bay is probably not going to be very suitable for them anymore by the end of the century.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it's along with the coral bleaching and some other impacts, it's our urgent call to cut carbon emissions.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And so for any listeners out there who are inspired and want
How to protect whale sharks
SPEAKER_00to help protect whale sharks or sharks in general, what is there things they can get involved with or just things they can do in their own life? And what advice do you have?
SPEAKER_02Well, one big advice is vote for the right people in government, the ones that are actually, you know, listening to science and trying to do something about the issues. Climate change is a big one. If we don't get that in check, not just for sharks, for a lot of species, that's trouble. It's going to be trouble for us, and we need healthy oceans. Another thing, just for bell sharks, if you see a bell shark and you get to take a photo of them off their site, above their pectorial fins, and you get like a picture of their star patterns, really, uh, you can submit that photo to sharkbook.ai, and then we can use that information to match them against the database and see if it's been spotted before. Or you report it to I on the reef. And even if you don't have a photo, just the occurrence itself without a photo is also very good to know. And if you see more than one shark, we really need to hear about it. Another thing to do is probably like uh personal choices, you know, like reducing your emissions, uh food choice. Don't eat shark fin, so give flake a break. Flake shark fin.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's something a lot of people don't know is when you go to the fish and chip shop and you you don't know what kind of fish it is. Sometimes it is shark. That's right. The Marine Conservation Society actually did an experiment where they tested the meat from all different fish and chip shops and found some endangered shark in there and some other types of shark.
SPEAKER_03Critically endangered hammerhead meat.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so you you've got to find out, and you know, if you're gonna eat tuna, I don't know if there's any such thing as sustainable tuna, but you've got to check.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00What about you said microplastics? So the whale sharks, they eat tiny little things called plankton. So they're swallowing tiny little things called microplastics.
SPEAKER_02Is that yeah, potentially. I mean, where there is aggregations of plankton, it makes sense that there's also other floating stuff there, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And there's some evidence of sharks having ingested plastic. So that's why I want to look at at this issue. And you know, you talk to my brother Christian, uh, they're doing beach cleanups in the Cape York area up there, in these remote areas. And there's so much plastic on the beaches. Uh kind of makes it.
SPEAKER_00So anything that's floating other than plankton is potentially just gonna get scooped straight up.
SPEAKER_03By a catch for them.
SPEAKER_02Yeah. So I sampled that area for microplastics uh to see how much there is and if that could potentially be an issue. So that's one of the things that I'm doing now.
SPEAKER_03It looks like they could almost swallow an Olympic-sized swimming pool in one mouthful. Yeah. But just that volume, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00They're like just a swimming scoop net with a tail. So uh what's the most important thing that you want people to know about whale sharks as a takeaway?
SPEAKER_02They're not scary. Um, they are really gentle, cute big animals that are really nice to hang out with. So don't be scared of them. Spread a positive story about these animals and other sharks as well. That's right.
SPEAKER_00And where can people head to check out your research and learn more about whale sharks and Biopixel and the research that you do?
SPEAKER_02Uh so you can find me on Instagram, but I'm to be honest, I'm not very, very active. So better to follow BioPixelOceans on Instagram. That's where we put our updates on, and that's where you find me as well. Check out BioTracker to see the satellite tracks.
SPEAKER_00Yes, I'm gonna log on right after this and when Ingo the Whale Shark is hanging here.
SPEAKER_02There's a reach out as well.
SPEAKER_00Oh, then we can find out where Richard is. Okay, so Ingo Miller, marine biologist with the Biopixel Oceans Foundation and James Cook University, PhD candidate. You were part of the team which discovered the Great Barrier Reefs first whale shark aggregation site. Thank you so much for your incredible work and thanks for joining us on the show today.
SPEAKER_03Thanks for having me anytime. Thanks, mate. It's been great.
SPEAKER_00And thanks to you, all our listeners, for joining us on Word on the Reef. I'm Tonya Murphy, my co-host is Brett Woodburn, and we will be back next Friday at 10am with more awesome marine science adventures. Um, we've actually got time for a joke. Who's got a marine themed joke?
SPEAKER_02I'm German, I'm not funny.
SPEAKER_00That was funny enough. That was good like that. How many Germans does it take to change a light load? One, because they're very efficient and not very funny. Okay. But you should want to tune in to MZFM and 9.1 to listen to the show next Friday. And you can text in your questions if you like, and don't forget to follow us on Instagram and Instagram.com slash word on the wreath podcast. That's all for this week. That's fishes. Bye, have a great week. See you next time.