Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E17: Trawl Wars: The Great Barrier Reef Marine Park vs. The Fishing Industry
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The 1990s was a wild west era for fishing on the Great Barrier Reef. Even after being declared a Marine Park and a World Heritage area, more than 95% of the Great Barrier Reef was still being fished, and things were heading downhill fast. Then came a bombshell report that exposed what was really going on beneath the surface -- and all hell broke loose. What followed was a fierce battle known as the ‘Trawl Wars,' and unfortunately, it did not happen in a galaxy far, far away.
In this episode, we’re joined by legendary conservationist Imogen Zethoven, who was made Officer of the Order of Australia for her groundbreaking campaign to create the largest network of no fishing zones, also known as Green Zones, in the GBR Marine Park. Imogen shares how the fight was won -- and why the battle to protect our oceans is far from over.
Thumbnail Image: Imogen Zethoven in front of a van owned by a Mackay local at a meeting in the early 2000s.
Glossary of Australian Terms for our International Listeners
- Prawns = what we call shrimps in Australia!
- Tucker = a slang term for food
- Canberra = our capital city, where Parliament House is located (we know you've never heard of it)
- GBRMPA = Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (also known as the Reef Authority).
- CSIRO "Sigh-Row" = Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (Australia's national science agency).
- AFMA = Australian Fisheries Management Authority
Take Action on Overfishing:
-------------------------------
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Good morning everyone and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver and marine conservationist, Tanya Murphy. And joining me, as always, is Cannes Aquarium's marine educator and fish whisperer, Brett Goodbairn. Good morning, Tanya. Hi everyone. Today, I want you to picture yourself diving in a shallow tropical lagoon near a coral reef. You're floating over seagrass meadows, watching endangered turtles grazing peacefully. Now imagine a giant bottom trolling street. A massive weight of death thundered the crust of seafloor. Scooping up everything in its own and leaving behind a bad way. It's a devastating image and one that's been captured like never before in Sir David Attenborough's new documentary Ocean. If you've been living under a coral bomby and haven't seen it yet, make sure you check it out. It's streaming now on Disney Plus. At 99 years old, Sir David is going strong. And in this powerful film, he reflects on the dramatic changes he's seen in our oceans over his lifetime, particularly from industrial trawling. His message we need to protect at least 30% of the ocean from fishing. So what does that mean for the Great Barrier Reef? How do practices like trawling impact our reef ecosystems? And how can we strike a balance between fishing and marine protection? Well, joining us today is someone who's been on the front lines of these questions for over 30 years. It's not Sir David Attenborough yet, but still hopeful we'll one day have him on our show. But she's an ocean hero in her own right. Yes. Imogen Zeitoven, officer of the Order of Australia, led the historic campaign to create the world's largest network of no fishing zones, also known as Green Zones, in the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park. Her work was so impactful that she received both national and international recognition, including the Fred M. Packard Award, shared with the late Marine Park Authority CEO Virginia Chadwick, for their outstanding contribution to marine conservation. Thanks to their efforts, the reef today is one of the most protected marine ecosystems on Earth. But there is still more work to be done, and Imogen's experiences provide a powerful insight into how we might better fight for marine protections going forward. So without further ado, good morning, Imogen.
SPEAKER_01Good morning, Tanya, and good morning, Brett.
SPEAKER_02Good morning, Imogen. It's a real honour to have you on the show. Thank you.
SPEAKER_01Oh, thank you. I'm delighted to be on.
SPEAKER_00Yes, great to have you on the show.
Imogen's incredible career
SPEAKER_00So uh tell us a bit about your background and how you came to be so passionate about ocean conservation.
SPEAKER_01Well, I can't say I grew up next to the Great Barry Reef, but I actually grew up in New Zealand. I moved here in 1980, and of course the Great Berry Reef was the dream place to go to. And I first went there in the early eighties and I snorkeled actually on an outer barrier reef, which was just extraordinary. I mean in those days it was almost what you call pristine. And uh never forget it. I mean it's there as the benchmark in my memory as to you know how the reef has changed over the decades. And so I fell in love with it. And I was lucky enough to get a job with WWF Australia uh in about 2000, which oversaw the rezoning of the of the Great Bay Reef. So I was just there at the right time and I'm extremely lucky for it.
SPEAKER_00And that is something we're going to dive deep into today. But you have a very extensive CV in conservation. Can you give us a bit of a brief overview of all the different conservation campaigns and projects you've worked on over the years?
SPEAKER_02That is one resume.
SPEAKER_01Well, when you get as old as me, you can have a resume like I hope so. I first well, I decided to change my life in the nineteen eighties because I felt that the world had reached this tipping point. There were so many global disasters emerging and coming to the spotlight of the general public in the nineteen eighties. Climate change, ozone depletion, there were you know chemical disasters uh erupting around the world, not to mention the threat of nuclear war and sounds a bit like today.
SPEAKER_00Not much change.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, unfortunately. It it does have the same feel about it. But in those days climate change uh you know, was just something new to most people.
SPEAKER_00There was still ti more time to act on it. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01There was a lot more time, exactly. And so I felt to make a difference I needed to go back to university and so I enrolled at the University of Adelaide and I did my master's in environmental studies, and then I felt equipped to to launch myself into the environment movement and try to affect policy and legislative change. So I started at the Australian Conservation Foundation and really I went from there, I spent three years after that working as an environmental advisor to the leader of the Australian Democrats, which at the time held the balance of power in the Senate. That was before the Greens did. And then I moved to Queensland and worked on I I ran the Queensland Conservation Council for five years, and that's when I moved to WWS and ran their first Great Berry Reef campaign. And at the end of that I really felt that I'd made a difference in terms of biodiversity protection, but climate change was still a greatest threat to the Great Berry Reef and all the world's coal reef. So I took up a a job running a global climate campaign out of Europe. And after that I moved back to Australia, ran a campaign for the Pew Charitable Trust to establish my goal uh censored by them was to establish the world's largest marine park in the Coal Sea. And that actually happened, although the zoning was disappointing, but that's another story. And then ran a global shark campaign for Pew out of Washington DC.
SPEAKER_00And then during your shark campaign you were in Sylvia Earle's Mission Blue documentary, which is so cool.
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's right. And had the absolute honour of spending a week with Sylvia Earle in in China talking about the need for shark conservation. And then came back to Australia again and worked with the Australian Marine Conservation Society again, running my second Great Breaker Reef campaign, this time with a strong focus on its world heritage status and the obligations that Australia has to protect it under the World Heritage Convention.
SPEAKER_02Wow.
SPEAKER_00So just a few things that you've just a couple. I mean, I'm I feel like the reef wouldn't be the ecosystem that it is without your contributions as part of all the people who have contributed towards it.
SPEAKER_02Thank you's not enough, is it?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, as always, it's it requires a huge collaboration um of people and ultimately public opinion swinging behind you. And you know, if there's one place in the world where you can be sure that public opinion is supportive of what you're doing, it's the Great Barrier Reef.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Such a global icon.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and we're all about encouraging our listeners to understand how important they are in supporting that kind of work. I mean everything you've achieved. I I think as we'll talk about later, depends so much on on the public and their love of the reef and their support of these campaigns. But the
No-fishing ('Green') Zones on the GBR
SPEAKER_00connection. Yeah. So we're here today to talk about protecting the Great Barrier Reef from overfishing, which was the zoning plan that you worked on. So can you please tell us about the green zones that are in place today to protect the Great Barrier Reef from overfishing? What is a green zone and where are they on the reef and what are their benefits?
SPEAKER_01So green zones are zoned as no fishing, no no take at all. And so really they're there for the purpose of protecting the biological diversity of the Great Barrier Reef and protecting its ecological integrity so that it works, it functions in a healthy way. So that's kind of the fundamental purpose of a green zone. I should also add there are pink zones as well. And they're even more highly protected. Pink zones are areas that are essentially no go, other than most of the marine an animals that visit there or live there. So no people are allowed there. And they're essentially pristine other than impacts such as maybe water quality or climate change. Um there's about a hundred and fourteen thousand square kilometers of the Great Barrier Reefs that are in green zones. And that comes to thirty-three point three percent of the marine park. I always point out that not 0.3% because it was very hard fought for it.
SPEAKER_02Every bit counts.
SPEAKER_00I feel bad now for all the times I've rounded to 33% because every fraction of a percent was fought so hard for.
SPEAKER_02And I promise I'll put the 0.3 in in my shows at work.
SPEAKER_00That's exactly one third, isn't it?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_01It is.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So that's you know, it essentially uh it covers all of the length and breadth of the marine park. It's the the way that the program was established was to make sure that say for example that 33.3% wasn't lumped in one particular area.
SPEAKER_00Spread out.
SPEAKER_01Evenly spread out throughout all of the seventy bioregions of the marine park. And of course they function incredibly well. They have worked despite you know, opposition saying that they won't work or that that they're very skeptical about them in the early days. They do work. In fact, two years after the establishment of the zoning network in July 2004, two years later there was a sixty percent increase in coral trout abundance. So you can see that they they really do work.
SPEAKER_02The proof is there. Yep.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so for anyone that's not aware, green zone, also known as a no-take zone, basically means no fishing of any kind. And as Imogen said, it's more than 114,000 square kilometres, so it is the largest no fishing zone in the world. So David Attenborough would be pretty proud of that. That's right.
SPEAKER_01And the largest fishing network in the world, because there are uh areas that are bigger than that than a no fishing, but they tend to be large single areas, such as the Chagos, no-tate marine reserve in the Indian Ocean. So just to point out that the network was really important. And that's because the Great Barrier Reef is such an interconnected ecosystem.
SPEAKER_02And so it's important to protect all these different bioregions and habitats throughout the entire system to just for our international guests that might not know this, the Coral Sea Marine Park, isn't that the largest body of protected ocean in the world? Just under a million square kilometres, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01The Coral Sea Marine Park. Yeah, lying to the east of the Great Barry Reef Marine Park and immediately on the boundary of New Caledonia.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. Yeah, it is.
SPEAKER_00So a lot of people uh when they think about the Great Barry Reef, they think about the corals. But as you were just mentioning, there's actually more than 70 different ecosystems or bioregions in the reef, which includes the seagrass beds and the sandy seafloors and the all those other different benthic types. And so that's why the green zones are spread out in a kind of patchwork instead of just one big area. It was designed so that a little bit of each type of those 70 ecosystems could be protected, right?
SPEAKER_01Yes, that's right. The program that the Marine Park Authority ran was called the Representative Areas Program. And so one of the goals of it was to protect representative samples of habitats and ecosystem types within each of those 70 bioregions that you just mentioned. There are 40 non-reef dominated bioregions and 30 reef dominated. And um, it was a really important step forward to say that you know, we love the Great Bray Reef because of its stunningly beautiful corals, but it's so much more than that.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and and the corals that we love so much, and the fish that live on these corals wouldn't be the same if it wasn't for all the other ecosystems that are interconnected.
SPEAKER_02But that's true of all the migrations and the It's the connection word, isn't it? Everything's connected.
SPEAKER_01Exactly. It's the turtles that need to feed on grasses and so on, and float over the corals and we all love them. And yeah, exactly. It is all right.
SPEAKER_00Well for all those listeners out there, if you haven't seen the map of the green zones on the Great Barry Reef and you're interested, there's a free app you can download called Eye on the Reef. Download that, have a quick look at it, and you can see where those green zones are and look at the reefs that you love the most and see whether they are actually protected from fishing or not. And you might be surprised how some of those green zones are shaped and you know the amount of non-green zone that is in between all those protected areas can be a little bit confronting sometimes. You've just got these little areas like on your favourite reef that might be protected, but then a couple of kilometres on either side, it's it's not protected. So it's really interesting to look at.
Wild West: Fishing in the 1990s on the GBR
SPEAKER_00So we've been talking obviously about what the green zones are. 33% of the Great Barrier Reef is green zone, which is the largest network of no fishing zones in the world, which is absolutely amazing. And Australia has, I think, its shiny international reputation of having one of the best protected marine parks in the world. It seems like a no-brainer. It's so beneficial to protecting the reef and all of the vulnerable and endangered species. It's beneficial to the tourism industry, because obviously people come from all over the world, they want to see these fish and animals in a pristine state, and ultimately even the fishing industry benefits from it because it improves the fish stocks in the surrounding areas by giving them a safe place to breed and repopulate. Imogen just shared with us that within two years of increasing the green zones, the populations of coral trout exploded, and that's gonna obviously benefit the reef, but also benefit the fishing industry. So it's really a win-win situation. It seems like a no-brainer, but it wasn't always like this. So, Imogen, can you take us back to the nineteen nineties? What level of protection was there back then to protect the reef from fishing?
SPEAKER_01Well, back in the nineteen nineties, only four point six percent of the marine park was highly protected, which was, you know, very, very low, and a large part of that four point six percent was located in the far northern section. It was a cross-shelf transect. And so there was actually very little highly protected throughout most of the marine park. And on top of that, the extent of fishing was very considerable compared to today. So you had a lot of bottom trawling occurring throughout large areas of the marine park, and that trawling was often done by small scale trawlers who dragged nets along the seafloor and a lot of effort doing it very much. So the damage was really significant compared to their catch. And then you had very extensive line fishing. Line fishing was really increasing in intensity, and you had a lot of bill net fishing as well, which of course, as we know, captures inshore megafauna like jugons and turtles and inshore dolphins and sawfish. Um so there was a considerable amount of extraction occurring from the marine park. And there was also the first global bleaching event that happened that affected the Great Bear Reef as well. That happened in 1998. So there was really increasing pressure on the Great Brerie Reef and a recognition within the Great Barrie Marine Park Authority that the level of protection was just inadequate, even it was a World Heritage Area, and to it was inadequate to maintain the healthy functioning of the whole ecosystem with this dramatic increase over the years in all sorts of fishing types, and and then on top of that, climate change, on top of that, poor water quality coming from the catchment.
SPEAKER_00Back in season one, episode nine, I interviewed Dianetti Hegel, who back in the sixties and seventies fought the campaign to stop oil drilling and coral mining on the Great Barrier Reef, which led to it being declared a marine park and the subsequent World Heritage Listing. And you think after that, you think, right, we've won, it's protected. But no, fishing was still allowed in more than 95%. So they got rid of the oil drilling, they got rid of the coral mining, but they still had all this fishing going on. And I think we'll do an episode specifically dedicated to gill nets in the future because that itself is a very destructive form of fishing. But today let's focus on the most environmentally destructive form of fishing, which you mentioned was at that time trawling around 80% of the reef was being trawled. And we've seen, you know, David Atman has shown us the impact that has on a seafloor, and it also was creating a lot of bycatch, which means turtles and things like that were getting caught in the nets back then in much higher numbers. So okay, so we've all heard of Star Wars, but you were involved in something back then called the Troll Wars, which sounds incredibly swashbuckling and exciting. Can you please explain a bit about what the troll wars were and do you identify with Princess Leia?
SPEAKER_01Uh well I'll leave that question blank. No, I don't, but anyway, I'd love to. Um the troll wars were really quite an intense period. And one of the things that I I remember more than anything was the deep involvement of the Premier in a positive way. He showed at the time that was Premier Peter Beatty, he showed a lot of interest in the issue, which was unusual because normally fishing issues don't really capture the attention of the Premier. And certainly not in a positive way if they do. So the trawl wars were, I guess, prompted by a major study that was undertaken or led by Cyro, Gorbin Four was involved, and I think also Asthmatra and Fishery Management Authority, and they did a a five-year study looking at the effects of trawling on the benthos, on the seafloor, and in the far northern section of the Great Barry Reef. And the conclusions were quite startling. They showed that up to ten tons of bycatch was caught for each ton of corns caught.
SPEAKER_00Oh my goodness. And when when we say bycatch, we're talking about turtles, mehanta rays, who knows.
SPEAKER_01All sorts of animals, seafloor animals, all sorts of you know, m water column animals can get caught up as well.
SPEAKER_00So you're killing ten tons of beautiful animals just to catch one ton of food.
SPEAKER_02That would be the equivalent of dropping a massive net over the serengeti, scooping up all the animals, giraffes, lions, tigers, rhinos, to get a particular ant and chuck everything back. Exactly. Do you know what I mean? Like if people can picture that in their head, that's think of it like times a million. It's just awful.
SPEAKER_01It was so shocking. And I think really what what it demonstrated was, you know, if you've got a pristine area that had never been trawled before, that is the extent of bycatch and cool, technically. But essentially, yes, it's the capture of innocent animals that are just caught in the path of these huge trawl nets. But you know, it it showed that if you keep trawling over and over again, then the level of bycatch becomes less and less.
SPEAKER_00Because it's already been removed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah. You've destroyed the Benthic community. And so this was quite a shocking report. There was also, of course, evidence of turtle deaths, turtles being caught up in these trawl nets.
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01And so the Marine Park Authority wanted to do something about it, and of course the the Queensland government was the fisheries manager. And also the Federal Environment Minister was deeply concerned about it too. So you had a lot of pressure to do something. And the other major factor in all this was that the United States had introduced a ban on the import of any pawns or shrimps from any countries that weren't protecting turtles.
SPEAKER_00Wow. How good was America back in the day. I can't imagine them doing that now.
SPEAKER_01And so, you know, to keep the US market open, Australia had to do something about it. And so the Queensland government brought in a statutory trawl management plan. It was the first time in a way a kind of a wild west industry was actually bought under management control.
SPEAKER_00And they did not like that.
SPEAKER_01They didn't like it. Um pushed hard to try to avoid things like turtle and excluder devices and bycatch reduction devices. Eventually they had to accept it and then there was a lot of haggle over what they look like, the design of them. Ultimately that the management plan came into effect and the the level of bycatch of turtles reduced dramatically. I think even the Queensland government would probably say these days by about ninety five percent successful.
SPEAKER_02It is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's still a problem, but imagine it being ninety-five percent more. Like there was a big gap in the turtle for a few years there, and they said that I I saw the news that there was one of the most successful turtle nesting seasons recently in certain parts of the reef, and it was attributed to it's been twenty years since the turtle exclusion devices were introduced on trawlers. And so with with seeing the population coming back. Unfortunately, turtles are now facing other issues like climate change. But for any listeners that aren't aware, the turtle exclusion device or TED is, as the name suggests, something that trawlers were mandated to use, which has a sort of flap that allows the turtles to pop out when they're catching the prawns.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so it was a big advance, and and I think that's kind of relieved some of the pressure. But the reality is you you say from certainly from that David Attenborough film is that trawling is inherently destructive. And you know, my personal view is it shouldn't happen in the Great Barry Reef.
SPEAKER_00Yes, well, there's a lot of people involved in the fishing industry in Queensland today, but back then it was an even more inflammatory issue, hence why it was called the trawl wars.
SPEAKER_01And we'll had the Federal Environment Minister and the Premier putting out dueling media releases about the troll management plan. So it became very heated, but ultimately it had a very good outcome.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, 95% of turtles saved by those mandates of the bycatch and turtle exclusion devices. So that was one win. But of
The Battle for the Green Zones
SPEAKER_00course, another thing that was identified in that time was the need to increase the area of no fishing zones, also known as green zones on the reef. So between the years of 2000 to about 2003, the Marine Park Authority and a number of other organizations worked together to come up with the new improved zoning plan. But that plan almost never came about because it could not go anywhere unless it got approved by the government, especially the environment minister and the prime minister who was John Howard at the time. And they were facing a ton of resistance from people who did not want the green zones to be expanded. So, Imogen, can you tell us who were some of the players who were so opposed and vocally against the increasing of green zones to protect the reef?
SPEAKER_01Ah, well, there's quite a few of them. There were a number of different fisheries, as we've just discussed, it was sure. But it was also the line fishery, gill net fishery, uh crab pot fishery, harvest fishery for corals and aquarium fish, sea cucumbers. But there was also recreational fishing, and there were thousands of recreational fishes up and down the coastline. There were industry organizations representing all of these different sectors. And then there were bait and tackle shops, seafood processing companies. So there was a a a huge diversity of interest groups and people and businesses who were deeply skeptical about the rezoning. They didn't want it and they weren't convinced that green zones would work because there weren't that many in the world at that stage. I mean it was a relatively new thing. And so we didn't have the evidence to show that actually they do work. It was assumed it would work they would work.
SPEAKER_00I mean it's a it's a bit obvious really that no fishing.
SPEAKER_01And yes, I mean you're right, Tanya. If you stop fishing, if you stop taking fish out of the water, there will be more fish in it. I mean i you know, it's not rocket science.
SPEAKER_00No, it's not. I bet there were some very creative arguments against there would have been some crackers.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and there were arguments about the sustainability of their jobs, of their businesses. So there were fishing businesses that were impacted, of course. But there was an awful lot of hyperbole and claims that you know thousands to be thrown out of work and people would be left homeless and I mean some of the claims just were almost ludicrous. But they had a lot of political effect and some of the members of parliament who of course hold marginal seats and they did in those days anyway, up and down the reef coastline really swung behind particularly the commercial fishermen, but also the recreational. And they lobbied the uh Prime Minister uh and other members of parliament very, very hard.
SPEAKER_00Which politicians were lobbying against the expansion of green zones to protect the reef?
SPEAKER_01Well, as most of your listeners would know, uh Warren Inch was definitely one of them. There were also others, such as Deanne Kelly, who hasn't been in federal parliament for some time now, but she was based further south in the seat of Dawson. There was Senator Ron Boswell, he's no longer a senator anymore, but he was very, very active trying to minimize the uh extent of green zones. And then there was a senator from the Northern Territory, funny enough, Senator Nigel Scullion. His interest was that he was the only member of federal parliament who hadn't been a commercial fisherman.
SPEAKER_00So he was helping his mates.
SPEAKER_01He was absolutely helping his mates, you were spot on. And th the four of them were very, very influential uh and very active. And you know, we had to counter the effect of of their advocacy within the Liberal Party. Um so we had to do a lot of advocacy as well where we made frequent trips down to Canberra and sometimes I would go down with the tourism industry, sometimes I would go down with key scientists, and we would do our own lobbying and put the alternative case. But we would also do a lot of work up and down the coastline, meeting community members, meeting recreational fishing groups locally, commercial fishers who would speak to us.
SPEAKER_00You have been very brave, Imogen, going out and talking to all those fishers when you know how opposed they are to your proposal.
SPEAKER_01Yes, we did a three-week road trip up and down the coastline, stopping off at all uh towns and cities down the coastline, and it was really rewarding, exhausting but rewarding to just to sit down and say, want to listen to you, but we want you to listen to us as well. And let's talk about it and you know, really putting the case that this is a win-win. And you know, I think I think people now, most people agree that it is a win-win. There's always a small element of the population that will feel aggrieved and they continue to it's almost no matter what the issue is.
SPEAKER_00They just can't please everyone.
SPEAKER_02And you know, those fishermen would have appreciated that though, sitting down and and hearing both sides of it. You take away all the noise and you know, all the the hate.
SPEAKER_00You can't beat a face-to-face.
SPEAKER_02No, that's right. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01You can't, especially with you know, good tucker. I mean, we would always stop off food from the local bakery and and put on tea and coffee and cake. And I think kind of creating a warm and friendly atmosphere like should help tremendously.
SPEAKER_00Who can get mad over tea and cake?
SPEAKER_02Well, look, wars can stop over a good sausage roll, that's all I'm saying.
SPEAKER_00Try that, try your uh peacemaking uh suggestions, Imogen.
SPEAKER_02Bring me a sticky bun and I'll change.
SPEAKER_01Yes, stakeholder meetings where everyone's sitting around, you know, with with folded arms akimbo and looking across the table at each other. When you take people out of that atmosphere and just create a more informal atmosphere, that's where things can change. Yeah, you know just human rather than representing an alternative group that's opposed to each other.
SPEAKER_00Wow, the power of human connection is so important.
The Tourism Industry to the Rescue
SPEAKER_00Okay, so what role did the tourism industry play? Because they helped with your campaign to get the green zones expanded, didn't they, Imogen?
SPEAKER_01They did. They were really great. I worked with the Association of Marine Park Tourism Operators, Amto, up in Cairns, who was led by Cole Mackenzie, and he was fantastic to work with. He really understood the power, the benefit of green zones to his industry and to the reef anyway. I mean, he was in love with the reef. And then the head of the Queensland Tourism Industry Council at the time was Daniel Gishwind. And he also had a great love for the reef and recognized the enormous benefit of a healthy Great Ferry Reef to the Queensland tourism industry. So they were really fabulous to work with. They were active advocates to the federal government, and they were really influential in their own right in making making the good outcome happen.
SPEAKER_00I read in Gabrumpa's report after the rezoning that I think more than 80 tour operators sent in submissions about supporting the green zones. So their, you know, economic clout and lobbying clout is so important, and it's just another example of how important the tourism industry is as an ally for reef conservation. Because, you know, it'd be great if politicians would protect the reef purely for its ecological importance, but a lot of politicians are very focused on the economy and jobs. And so if you can show that we're gonna have a much more valuable economy and jobs by protecting the reef for the eco-tourism industry than by harming it, it's just such a powerful industry to help with the protection of the reef, I believe.
SPEAKER_01I can yeah. And in fact, there was a really important report, it came out in the same year that the zoning plan was approved, 2003. It was by the Productivity Commission in Canberra, and they did uh uh an analysis of the value of the various industries in the reef because up to that point, you know, everyone had thought, oh, it's the fishing industry, that's that's the one with the mite and the clout and the economic weight. The Productivity Commission found that the commercial fishing industry at the time was worth about 190 million per annum, the recreational was about two hundred and forty million, but the tourism industry at the time was four billion. So all of a sudden it just totally changed the perception of which industry was really the most important and which industry should be really well protected. Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely.
People Power saves the Day
SPEAKER_00So a big theme on this show is also to let listeners know that anyone out there can help protect the ocean, and people power makes a big difference. I saw in the Marine Park Authorities report that over 10,000 submissions were sent into the government in the consultation period. So the government obviously did consult with all these different groups to inform the rezoning plan, and they did it was very democratic. They took everyone's submissions into consideration, they received over 10,000 submissions, and the largest percentage of demographic, 37%, was from environmental groups and their followers and supporters. So it just goes to show how much weight is we can influence these sort of outcomes when we sign petitions, join a environmental group, join a campaign to protect the reef, and every single submission or petition signature or letter to a politician all counts, and it all added up. And in the submission period, the greatest number of submissions were they obviously got a lot from fishing industry people, recreational fishers, they had a good amount of consultation with traditional owners and various different groups, but the largest submitters of submissions on the green zones were from the environmental perspective and from these environmental campaigns like yours, I bet thousands of those people were probably your followers of your campaign imagination. So, yeah, how much how much do you think volunteers and general members of the public helped with the campaign and how important were they?
SPEAKER_01Well, I I know definitely that the public submissions were absolutely critical at WW if we then worked really hard to try to generate public support. We knew it was out there, it just needed to be activated. And so there were actually two phases of public consultation, and I think the total number were up 31 and a half thousand, if I remember correctly.
SPEAKER_00And wow, 31 and a half thousand lots of people cared about this issue, and the majority of them were were pro-green zones. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yes, absolutely. And it was the largest number of submissions that had ever been received on an environmental issue up to that point.
SPEAKER_00Wow. Good job.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, and and it had an impact. You know, we were able to argue that most people really, really wanted a great level of protection for the And it's almost do you think that the uh the opposition to this didn't see that coming?
SPEAKER_02Were they sort of expecting that the general public wouldn't really know what was going on and were too busy to care, but then got a big reality check?
SPEAKER_01I think that's absolutely right. And I think there was one final reality check that they may not have realised was coming, and it was crucial actually. It was just before the zoning plan proposal was taken to federal cabinet for approval. We decided to commission an electorate-based poll to find out what the communities were thinking. In the electorates where the MPs were working hard against it. So we did a poll in the seat of Leichart. Those polls at an electorate level are quite expensive, so we just did it once and we did it just before the final decision was made in Canberra.
SPEAKER_02Oh, good move.
SPEAKER_01We did it in the Ann Kelly seat in Dawson as well. What it showed was that the majority opinion in those electorates was actually contrary to what their own elected members were saying.
SPEAKER_02Oh, that's a bit disconnected, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01It is a bit disconnected.
SPEAKER_02Oops.
SPEAKER_01And we were told afterwards that that was a really influential poll. We had it published in the Australian the morning it went to Federal Cabinet. That that really helped to tip the cabinet over the edge to support it.
SPEAKER_02Wow, good move.
SPEAKER_01Just using a toolbox as a campaigner. But it yeah, there's no doubt that public opinion was enormously behind this.
SPEAKER_00And campaigners like you help to educate people to inform that public opinion as well with all the media and all of the public lectures that you give and going on radio interviews like this, but back then would have really helped to build that public support for the green zone. So I know how much work it is to do these campaigns. Kudos to you, and I just want all the listeners to understand that when you support even to this day, any campaign where you can sign up something or send a letter off that does actually go somewhere and when there's thousands of people that jump on board, it makes a big difference. Just like it did back then.
SPEAKER_01It really if I can just back you up there, Tanya, that when an issue is controversial, which often environmental issues are, and you've got a minister, an environment minister who wants to do something, for them to be able to go in cabinet and say, the majority of people support this, and particularly if it's an electorate-based thing, it really is helpful. So you may feel individually it's really not worth it, but collectively it is, and it's really an important thing to do to mobilize that public opinion.
SPEAKER_00Mm-hmm. Well, we're into the last nine minutes of the show, so let's make uh rapid fire through some of my my last questions.
Favours and Payouts
SPEAKER_00So, how much did the fishing industry influence the final layout of the green zones? Because I understand even though we did get the green zones expanded, many concessions were made in the layout of the green zones to compromise with the wishes of fishermen and and fishing women.
SPEAKER_01Yes, I mean it was, and I remember being briefed about it and I I have to say I burst into tears. Nothing happened very often.
SPEAKER_00Because it could have been better.
SPEAKER_01It could have been better. And you know, even now I think everyone realises that it could be better, but I guess that's a conversation of what we could do in the future. But at the time, you know, it had to be done because otherwise the whole thing would have collapsed and it wouldn't have happened. So I had to kind of bite my tongue and recognise that you you can't there's never a perfect result. But it was as good as it possibly could have been at the time, given the policy.
SPEAKER_02Could you imagine? Like I don't even want to think about what state that reef would be in at the moment with what's happening with the ocean's temperatures rising, and if we if if you hadn't put all that hard work in back then, where where would we be now?
unknownYeah.
SPEAKER_01That's right. That's absolutely right. There was a last minute concession to charter fishermen. They lobbied very, very hard. And so there was a a zone that was established around the Ribbon Reef area that just allowed them to operate.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, they got their own little special spot. You told me about that, the khaki coloured spot. Khaki coloured spot. Not green, but khaki. Yeah. Okay, so next one. I understand there was a bit of a scandal about how much taxpayer money Prime Minister John Howard gave away to some members of the fishing industry to appease them about the reduction of their fishing areas.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, there was an absolute scandal. You're right. There was an estimate done that the cost of the zoning plan would probably be around ten million dollars. That was a cost of buying out, structurally adjusting the industry so buying out fishing licenses from displaced fishermen. In the end, the government didn't give away ten million dollars, they gave away two hundred and fifty million.
SPEAKER_00Oh, cracky.
SPEAKER_01That that is a fairly massive increase in 25 times what they should have done. And that was because there were so many claims and counterclaims and so much hyperbole about the effect that would have, and everyone was putting their hand up for compensation and for being bought out. And there were limits set, and then those limits would change and they would be higher and higher and higher. Uh and it just became an absolute scandal. And I think that that's the one unfortunate legacy of this, that it ended up being a massive pork barrel up and down the coastline ahead of an election that you know the Prime Minister of course wanted to win. And so he overruled the treasurer and kept raising an amount of money to be given away. And so the ultimate result was that the cost of protecting the Great Barriers Marine Park was much, much higher than it should have been. And that flows over to other Commonwealth Marine Parks that are to be protected in the future.
SPEAKER_00And you told me that a lot of those fishers kept on fishing anyway after they got the money.
SPEAKER_01Many of them you know improved their infrastructure. New gear, stronger engines, more powerful engines. So, you know they did have some unfortunate effects. But I guess it's important not to lose sight that, you know, we have this network of no fishing and um Yeah. Rich and wealthy country, so we can actually afford it, even though it was scandalous. I guess the countries that look on and go, can we do this are countries that are not as wealthy but do want to protect their uh exclusive economic zones, their ocean.
SPEAKER_00Well, transitioning fisher people into tourism is a big tool that they're using in developing countries.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_00And I don't know if people in Queensland did that as well, but
The Final Showdown
SPEAKER_00let's talk about how it all finished in the end. How was this campaign ultimately won after probably more than three years of hard work? What clinched the win? And can you tell us about the moment when you realised that you'd won and the green zone expansion was going to be legislated and how did that feel?
SPEAKER_01Well, it felt wonderful. And as I said, that poll that was published in The Australian the morning that Cabinet approved it was absolutely critical. We were absolutely delighted to attend the press conference in Canberra when the minister announced it. Even to that day, he had resistance from the elected representative that I just mentioned earlier. But it was announced it was a great, great victory really for marine conservation and for the coral reef area. And it's been seen as a shining light around the world for what could be done to protect coral reef. So it really put on the international stage, they won a lot of accolades for it. And I personally and WWF have felt great pride in being involved and we were so lucky to be there at the time and to to make the most of it. But you know, the story isn't finished because we're now what what is it, 21 years later, we've had six leaching events in the last nine years and the reef is under even more pressure now than it was then, and so we we need to take that next big step now of protection.
SPEAKER_00So now, thanks to you, we've got 33% of the reef is part of this network of green zones, which as you said is a massive win. I think for a future conversation, we can talk about you know how effective is that today in protecting the reef now that there's so many more threats and things are changing, what could we do better going forward? That's all a will be a great conversation for another day because we've only got just over a minute
What can people do about overfishing today?
SPEAKER_00left. And so I guess let's finish off with if there are any listeners out there who want to do something to help protect the Great Barrier Reef from overfishing nowadays, um, what sort of campaigns or organizations can they get involved in?
SPEAKER_01Uh well, I think they can definitely get involved with a campaign that the Australian Marine Conservation Society is running. AMCS runs a Great Barry Reefs campaign and it really focuses on trying to reduce fishing pressure, such as stillness, which was successful, but also they're working on the coral harvest industry as well. So you could get involved with that campaign. And WWF also runs a Great Berries campaign. They're focusing on climate impacts and trying to get a better, um more ambitious emissions reduction target. So that would help the Great Bayer Reefs enormously. So I would encourage anyone to get involved with either or both of those two groups. They're both fantastic and they do wonderful work.
SPEAKER_00Fantastic. Imogen Zaythoven, officer of the Order of Australia, leader of the historic campaign to create the world's largest network of no fishing zones, also known as Green Zones in the Great Barry Reef Marine Park. Thanks for all your amazing work and thanks so much for joining us on the show today.
SPEAKER_02Thank you so much.
SPEAKER_00You're a fishy superstar. Have a great weekend. Thank you.