Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E13: Undercover Investigation: The Supermarket Plastics Trashing our Oceans
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
Did you know Aussies are among the worst plastic polluters on the planet - second only to Singapore for our use of single-use plastic packaging? Every year, 145,000 tonnes of plastic waste leak into our environment, and most of it comes from our supermarkets.
Many of these plastics are not recyclable, and even when binned “correctly," they escape - blown by wind, swept by rain - ending up in rivers, oceans, and inside marine life. From turtles mistaking bags for jellyfish to seabirds literally crunching from the plastic in their guts, our throwaway culture is devastating wildlife… and it’s coming back to poison us too.
But there are solutions.
This week, we’re joined by Tara Jones, Plastics & Packaging Program Manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society, who reveals the shock findings from her supermarket plastics investigation. It's infuriating and eye opening, but it also holds the key to what we can do to stop the plastic tide.
💙 Plus: Find out how to join our Fin Club and receive a personalised video message from your favourite marine animal at the Cairns Aquarium!
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Hey there. Before we dive in, just a quick favorite to ask. If you're enjoying the story, don't be self-fit. Please take a moment to write and review it wherever you're listening. It helps more people find us in the big blue ocean of podcasts. You can also support us by hitting that follow or subscribe button, following us on Instagram at Word on the Race Podcast, and sharing the podcast link with a friend who might love it too. Thanks so much. Now let's get into today's episode. Good morning everyone, and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver and marine conservationist Tanya Murphy. And joining me as always is Cannes Aquarium's marine educator and fish whisperer, Brett Goodband.
SPEAKER_02Good morning, Tanya. Hello, everybody.
SPEAKER_00Good morning, Brett. Now, I want everyone to picture this. It's Sunday morning, so you've got a roast in mind and you head into the supermarket for some fresh veggies. You're in the produce aisle when suddenly you're faced with an ethical dilemma. Do you go for the loose potatoes, free as nature intended, or the plastic wrapped ones? Same goes for the carrots. Do you buy them naked or in the plastic bag? What do you do, Brett?
SPEAKER_02Oh, well, look, the fruit and vegetation has its own skin, doesn't it? So I just put them in the trolley. They don't need a bag.
SPEAKER_00Exactly. So, but okay, plot twist. What if I told you sometimes the plastic wrapped veggies are actually cheaper per kilo than the loose ones? Stop it. And and let's say you're a struggling diver who's trying to feed your family during a cost of living crisis and every cent matters. So you heard that right, guys. In a world where we're we know we need to cut down on plastic to save our marine life, we're now being penalised sometimes for trying to do the right thing. So what's going on here? To help us unwrap this packaging paradox, we're joined today by someone who knows all the dirty secrets of the supermarket aisles. Tara Jones, the Plastics and Packaging Programme Manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society. Good morning, Tara. Good morning. Thanks for having me on. Good morning, Tara. How are you, mate? Yeah, great, thank you. Great to have you on the show.
How to get your personalised message from your fave marine animal
SPEAKER_00Thank you. But just quickly before we get into the interview, Britt and I also just want to send our salty salutations to our new Patreon supporters, Rodney Rasmussen and Alyssa Nuttall. Thank you so much, guys, for contributing to help us keep the good ship Word on the Reef afloat. And another shout out to our longer-term supporters, Gemma Renfrey, Ree Tollow Russell, and Emily Bochman. If there's anyone else out there who's listening who would like to become a member of our Finn Club, just head to patreon.com slash Word on the Reef Podcast. As members of our Finn Club, you get access to exclusive content from Brett and I, including a personalised video message from your favourite marine animal over at the Cans Aquarium. So the animals are waiting, they want to talk to you guys. So if you'd like to get a message from your favourite marine animal like Chang the Queensland Groupa or Trevor the Sea Star or any other animal, make sure you head to patreon.com slash word on the reef and sign up to become a FinClub member for as little as $5 a month. And once you sign up, you'll straight away have access to the messaging tool inside Patreon where you can send us a message and chat with us and get exclusive content.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, thank you so much, guys. We really appreciate it. Our family's getting bigger.
SPEAKER_00Yes, and it makes a big difference and it means a lot to us. It goes towards covering some of our ongoing costs like podcast hosting, music licensing, and editing software, which is all subscription-based rather than one-off nowadays. So the costs just keep coming monthly. And if you support us, our promise to you is that we will continue to make this show better and better, the best that we can be.
SPEAKER_02Absolutely.
How did Tara become a plastic investigator?
SPEAKER_00So, Tara, we're super intrigued to talk with you about supermarket plastics and how they impact our oceans. But before we get started, can you tell us a bit about yourself and how you came to be passionate about protecting our oceans from things like plastic pollution?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. So I was lucky enough to grow up in the beautiful northern rivers and I spent so much time in the water. The coastline really quickly became an incredibly important rounding place for me. I was able to connect with nature when I was faced with challenging times. I'd head to the coast to calm my nervous system and reflect on my place in the world. But I started to notice more and more plastic on our beaches, and before long, a relaxing trip to the beach inevitably ended up a scavenger hunt along the high tide line, collecting every little bit of plastic that I could find. So I went to university, I studied ecology and writing, I became an environmental consultant in the waste industry. I had the incredibly glamorous job of hand-sorting through waste and recycling all across Queensland to figure out what the composition of these waste streams are and provide advice to council about waste education and uh how to reduce the amount of rubbish that we're generating. But despite my best efforts, the landfills kept filling up, plastic pollution kept ending up in our oceans. And I started to work with the Australian Marine Conservation Society to tackle plastic pollution at its source. So I developed an audit of supermarket plastic packaging. We looked at their promises and their policies so that we could push them to stop using so much plastic packaging and help customers find better choices. So plastic has absolutely no place in our oceans or our environment. And I'm just so determined to use the best research and evidence-based solutions to make sure that our amazing marine wildlife can live in a plastic-free life.
SPEAKER_00Wow, we are just so grateful to people like you that are getting up to your elbows in people's dirty ewes, cups, bottles, and so on. Because with without you doing those hard yards, we we don't understand how to stem the tide, I guess. So thank
How big is Australia's plastic waste problem?
SPEAKER_00you. But before we dive deeper into the supermarkets and their plastic packaging problems, I just want to give listeners a bit of background as to why this is so important. We know that in northern sections of the Great Barrier Reef, a lot of plastic waste is washing up on our shores from the fishing industry and from our neighbouring countries. So as Australians, how big is our own contribution to plastic waste in our environment and our oceans?
SPEAKER_01That's such a good question, and it's a really important thing for us to consider as Australians. I think the perception generally in Australia is that we are such a small nation comparatively, and so therefore we don't have a lot of impact on this problem. But in Australia, there's about 145,000 tons of plastic that enters the environment every year. So that's about 250 kilos a minute of Australia's plastic ending up in the environment. That that's really, really significant. And if nothing else, if we just tackle that on our own shores, already that's having a huge contribution to reducing plastic pollution.
SPEAKER_02So how much did you say it was a second?
SPEAKER_01Uh it was about 250 kilos a minute.
SPEAKER_02250 kilos a minute. It's incredible, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01It is amazing. And Australians are using more single-use plastic packaging than almost any other country per capita. So we are number two behind Singapore in single-use plastic packaging. Yeah, it's very shocking, isn't it?
SPEAKER_00That is shocking. I mean, like people often think about more populous countries like America, for example, but we're actually producing more plastic packaging than them. Is that right?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah. Per capita, we're using more single-use plastic packaging than than those countries. And, you know, there is a huge problem, particularly in northern Australia, with plastic pollution coming from other countries, coming from cruise ships and fishing ships. But in some of our really densely populated areas, like the Gold Coast, for example, the vast majority of the plastic that they're finding on the beaches and out in the ocean is actually from Australia. So it's really important. I really want to stress that you know, our contribution to this crisis is not small, it's not insignificant. And we have a huge role to play. And when you think about the amount of plastic packaging that's on our shelves in the supermarket, for example, that's just one example of retail businesses in Australia. They're about a hundred and forty billion dollar industry at the moment. And you only have to walk down the aisles to see how much plastic packaging's been produced to know that we absolutely need to do something about it.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and that's it's taking the power back by I think looking at ourselves and what we can do. It's very much more empowering than worrying about uh what's happening in other countries when we have such such a lot of looking in the mirror of ourselves and our own plastic use to look at.
SPEAKER_02And that's always, you know, you usually find that when you bring this subject up with people and you talk about the amount of waste that we produce in Australia, the usual the comeback is but what about other countries like India and Japan and pla it's always pushed to another country. We're not that bad, they're worse than us. But when you look at those figures, it's it's eye-watering, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01It absolutely is, yeah. And I think it's really critical that we just have a good hard look at ourselves and what's within our power. And you know, there's there's other things that are happening on the global scale that we can hopefully chat about later. But you know, there's so much that we can do in our own homes and on our own shores that's going to make a huge difference for our beautiful marine wildlife.
SPEAKER_00Our guest today is Tara Jones, the plastics and packaging programme manager at the Australian Marine Conservation Society. And we've just been talking about the plastic waste that's washing up on our shores, and a lot of it is domestic.
What is plastic waste doing to our Australian marine life?
SPEAKER_00So us Australians are producing more single-use plastic packaging than any other country after Singapore per capita. So we've been talking about how we can address this problem. But first, Tyra, can you give us a bit more information about what impact is our plastic waste having on our Australian marine life?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. There is so much research about the impact of plastic on our marine wildlife. My favourite sea creature is the turtle. I fly every time I see them. I'm rather ashamed to admit. Absolutely. So the turtles, they are really susceptible to ingesting plastic pollution. So some research has shown that turtles have a 22% chance of dying from ingesting just one single piece of plastic. So that could be because it's harming their stomach or in, you know, any part of their digestive tract. Yeah, there's something of turtles ingesting like plastic bags and not being able to dive down for food.
SPEAKER_02Yep. And and that's something that I see every day because I do the tours for the Cannes Turtle Rehab Center at the aquarium since we opened, and educate hundreds of people a week on turtles. I've got three really sick turtles in there at the moment. And what people don't understand is that some of our turtles biologically are set up to not be able to regurgitate that bag out once they've eaten it. So they ingest it thinking it's a jellyfish. So it's sort of they get trapped inside their gut, and sometimes you can see 20, 30 plastic bags inside them, and then they get what we call floaters. So they end up stuck on the surface, and then they get hit by speedboats, jet skis, or tiger sharks get them. So I see this firsthand every day. It's just awful.
SPEAKER_00So what you mean by floaters for anyone that's not aware is when they ingest so much plastic it makes them float, so they can't dive down to the bottom to eat the seaweed they need to survive, and when they can't dive down, they also can't avoid boats and propellers as well.
SPEAKER_01So devastating to see, you know, to such beautiful creatures. There's also been some incredible results coming out of a drift lab based on Lord Howe Island. So Dr. Jen Labis and her team, they've spent decades researching stable shear waters or mutton birds and the plastic pollution and how it's affecting them. So uh you might have seen some news articles recently about one of their recent studies. It was truly devastating. One of the quotes from there is that there is now so much plastic inside the birds, you can feel it on the outside of the animal when it's still alive. As you press on its belly, you hear the pieces grinding against each other.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I've seen the footage. It's pretty devastating. They touched its belly and it crackles and crunches. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02It's just awful.
SPEAKER_01It's astounding. And when you think about the way that a lot of seabirds feed, you know, they'll fly along and scoop up things off the surface or close to the surface. Plastic floats, it can be hard to tell whether it's plastic or food. And they broke a devastating record in this most recent research piece that almost a fifth of this bird's body weight was plastic. In seeing chicks that are less than 90 days old ingesting hundreds and hundreds of pieces of plastic. And some of them are too big for them to regurgitate out as well. So their recent study, they had to split the birds into low plastic ingestion and high plastic ingestion because it's incredibly difficult to find a bird with no plastic ingestion. So that's just absolutely devastating, and I can't imagine how hard it is to work with those birds year after year and see the amount of plastic that they're ingesting increasing. And then a little bit closer to home for you is the impact of plastic on reefs. So this is still being investigated. But we do know that corals that have been in contact with plastic are far more likely to become diseased. And larger pieces of plastic, such as bags and ropes, can physically damage the reef. They can become tangled up in the structure, they can break off corals, they can smother them. Discarded and lost fishing gear is a really big impact on reefs, but they continue to indiscriminately trap animals like a wall of death as they float through the sea. And we're ingesting so much micro and nanoplastics on a daily basis. The the studies are starting to show how these particles are harming our own health. And the fact that plastic has been found in every organ in the human body, including the brain, which is terrifying.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, because the plastics in the environment, it goes into the plants and animals that we eat, and then we end up with it uh in inside our organs, which is terrifying.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. And through our packaging as well, the packaging that's around our food, you know, every time you open a single use plastic bottle of water, hundreds or if not thousands, of microplastics fall into the water.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01And when you drink that, you know, you've got fresh fruit and vegetables wrapped up in plastic. Every time you scrunch or, you know, handle that package, there's pieces of plastic that are shedding off that and getting into our food. So it's massively problematic for our marine wildlife, but it's actually really harming us as well.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, we put in a water fountain about two months ago at work opposite the first tank, the River Monsters tank, and every show I remind people to please use that to fill up their reusable water bottle that they've brought with them. Keep using it, keep using it, keep using it. And there's a little digital readout in the top corner, and every time someone fills up their reusable water bottle, it counts how many single-use plastic water bottles haven't hit our oceans. And in I looked at it yesterday, it was like 890 something already. So yeah, it's just the little things that we can coax people in the right direction, every bit helps, doesn't it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, and because of these stats, I I am uh very wary about eating anything that's touched or drinking anything that's touched plastic. So reusable water bottles are amazing, but even using like a steel one or trying to get food that hasn't had any plastic fragments touching it, but it's hard, and that's what Tyra's going to be able to tell us more about. But
How much progress has been made on Australia's single use plastic bans?
SPEAKER_00we have made progress in recent years, haven't we? So we need to look at the wins. So in the past decade alone, we have seen lots of types of single-use plastics banned to varying degrees in different states in Australia, from plastic shopping bags at the checkouts to plastic straws and other things. Can you tell us a bit about those campaigns and where we're up to on those single-use plastic bands?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so encouragingly, every state and territory in Australia now has some single-use plastic bands in place. For some territories, that's, you know, just plastic bags, but that's a fantastic start. For other territories like South Australia and WA, they're really leading the way in these bans. And they're banning all kinds of things, you know, from straws were a pretty early one for a lot of states. But we're now even seeing things like disposable coffee cups and takeaway food containers that are being banned. So that's all really encouraging. And what we're seeing is less of these items are being found in cleanup. So if you think about, say, plastic straws, that's a really clear one. We used to find so many of them littered all over the beach and all through the ocean, and we're seeing less and less of those now, which is incredible. But the proportion of plastic is increasing in the amount of litter that we're finding in cleanup. So Cleanup Australia every year publishes their litter report. And the proportion of plastic is still increasing. So these bands are really helpful for getting rid of some of the most problematic items, but they're not sufficient to tackle plastic pollution. So we really need to think carefully about, you know, what big systems changes we can come up with. Keep going with these bands, keep going with our improvements, but you know, we need to reduce the amount of plastic we're using really rapidly to protect our marine animals.
SPEAKER_00That's right, because it doesn't stop at straws and check out bags.
How to be a detective for the Plastic Investigations Unit
SPEAKER_00So many items in the supermarkets are still wrapped in plastic, from the pasta to the biscuits to the salad leaves. Is it actually possible to buy everything you need from the supermarket without ending up with a trolley full of plastic? So to help us figure that out, Tara, you've done some research, and I think it's funny because when you tell people that you're doing research for the Australian Marine Conservation Society, they probably assume that you're out there glamorously in the ocean counting the fish and monitoring the corals and things like that. But your quest to save marine life has actually seen you and teams of volunteers trawling the aisles of local supermarkets across the country, gathering data about plastic packaging. So tell us about the what is it? The secret special agent plastic investigators unit. I've always wanted to be a detective.
SPEAKER_01This is your opportunity to live out your detective dreams. Yes, so our plastic investigation unit was formed in 2023. We approached the supermarkets and asked them a bunch of questions about their plastic packaging use. And the response that we got from them was pretty lackluster. They weren't really willing or able to share a lot of information with us. And so we thought, well, how are we going to get data out of our supermarket? So we asked our supporters to help. And we got hundreds of people collecting data for us in the supermarket. Some people had already noticed that pre-packaged produce was cheaper and were really happy to have an opportunity to do something about it. And others were absolutely outraged when they noticed and wanted to hold supermarkets to account. So what they found was really shocking.
What was the Investigation's most shocking discovery?
SPEAKER_01In the first year, we found that in 78% of cases, the loose fresh produce was more expensive than the pre-packaged produce.
SPEAKER_02I'm just so confused with this. I don't get it.
SPEAKER_01I know, I know.
SPEAKER_02We can I'm sorry.
SPEAKER_01So we found that shoppers were being penalised for trying to stop without plastic packaging on their produce. And you know, Tanya, like you said, we all know that we need to be using less plastic, but we're being penalized when we try and avoid it on our fresh produce.
SPEAKER_00Brett's just his head is exploding from confusion. I just don't understand. Do you do you have any ideas why that is?
SPEAKER_01Alright, so the supermarkets have given us a couple of reasons for why fresh produce is sold packaged for cheaper. So they're telling us that they're providing shoppers with choices. They're telling us that they're providing discounts for bulk purchases, and that the packaging is increasing the shelf life. But there's solutions out there. We could have supermarkets be providing discounts for buying certain quantities of fresh produce without packaging. We could have supermarkets using reusable solutions like tubs and bags to pre-pack things that aren't in single-use plastic packaging. And we've asked supermarkets to show us their research on how the packaging increases shelf life and for which products. And they couldn't or they wouldn't show us. And there's research out of the UK from a charity called RAP, who's all about reducing food waste. And their recommendation to supermarkets is that to reduce food waste, supermarkets should sell all produce loose unless they can prove that their packaging actually reduces food waste. And I want to really clear about that reducing food waste as opposed to increasing shelf life, those two things aren't necessarily the same thing.
SPEAKER_02Right. Okay.
SPEAKER_00So so like Brett said, your cucumbers and your potatoes have skin on them already.
SPEAKER_02So this is the message that I tell people at the end of my turtle tours go, okay guys, look, the only section in a supermarket that's grown naturally has its own skin. And you see people walk in to do their shopping and they're treating bananas like they're a newborn baby. But they don't realise that at four o'clock in the morning a 16-year-old kid has been throwing those things on the shelf. And you see people treat them so delicately. I said, you'll be all right, just put them in the trolley and they'll get to the fruit okay. And it's about not using that plastic bag that's rolled up above the fruit and veg that you see people put one banana in or one tomato. It just frustrates me.
SPEAKER_00Nothing will happen if your vegetables touch each other.
SPEAKER_02That's right.
SPEAKER_00They're not no and you've got to wash them and take the skin off anyway.
SPEAKER_02So it doesn't matter if they touch the trolley. They'll be fine. I've never seen a banana blow up on the way to the boot of the car. It's gonna be okay, trust me.
SPEAKER_00So I've got the graphs in front of me with some of those statistics, Tara, and Brett and I were just mind-boggling over the potatoes.
SPEAKER_02Oh just nuts.
SPEAKER_00Tell us about the potatoes.
SPEAKER_01Yeah so potatoes are 42% more expensive if you buy them loose compared to the same type of potato in a plastic bag. So the average price in pre-packaged potatoes was $2.78 per kilo and if you're buying loose it's costing you an average of $4.26 per kilo. Yeah.
SPEAKER_02Oh just shocking isn't it?
SPEAKER_01So shocked and I reckon everyone that's listening to this will be too happy to not be that that one really surprised me and I mean I've got to say I'm a huge potato lover and I probably buy more than the average person. So to find out that I'm being penalised that much for buying loose potatoes which as we've just said they have their own skin.
SPEAKER_02Yeah they'd be fine.
SPEAKER_01But the fact that it's costing customers more to avoid the plastic packaging is absolutely ridiculous, particularly at the moment where we've got a cost of living crisis.
SPEAKER_02Yep.
SPEAKER_01And it is just unfair for shoppers to be penalised to try and do the right thing and to choose between their budget and their values.
SPEAKER_00Yeah it would encourage me potentially to grab the big bag instead of just grabbing like two or three potatoes and in that case some of it's more likely to go to waste if I don't use the whole big bag.
SPEAKER_02And and that'd be an interesting survey to take, wouldn't it? Like what does the average household if they bought package stuff because it's cheaper, how much of that produce would they chuck out at the end of the week? Like I don't have any use for a two kilo bag of spuds. Well you might you might if you like spuds, but that you know I'm not I'm not going to use all those potatoes in that time.
SPEAKER_01Exactly and in that case it's a false saving. You're getting more than you needed potentially because you know it's a cost of living crisis. People are worried about how they're going to feed their families but people are also becoming more and more time poor and being able to just grab that bag and carry on and get everything else that they need to get done that day is a far more convenient choice for people and it seems to be cheaper. But this is why some research out of the UK is suggesting that supermarkets sell everything loose unless they can prove that it reduces food waste. Because the majority of the food that's wasted in Australia and you know worldwide is at the household level. So this is food that people are buying from the supermarkets and not getting to in time or you know not eating. And I wonder how much of that is because people are being encouraged to buy these bigger bags because they're a little bit cheaper and a bit more convenient. But they're coming with all of this single use plastic package.
SPEAKER_02There's one thing I'm struggling with because isn't it costing them more to have it plastic wrapped? So wouldn't it be the other way around then?
SPEAKER_01Yep, you would think so.
SPEAKER_02Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But for some reason I mean you know there's some potential reasons I can think of for why they're encouraging people to buy more than they might need. You know the supermarkets are saying things like it's to give people choice. But like I said, you know there's ways that they can do that to avoid the single use plastic packaging. Why would make it so that if you buy a kilo of buds loose you get the same discount for buying in bulk. You know, there's ways that they can go about it.
SPEAKER_02Yeah well the animals don't have a choice do they?
SPEAKER_01Exactly right.
SPEAKER_02They don't have a choice so yeah I just flabbergasted me I don't believe it. And typical the only thing on this list that I don't actually like tomatoes. Horrible is actually the one that is loose is actually cheaper than buying it packaged.
SPEAKER_01For tomatoes for tomatoes the only one I don't like typical I'm a bit and this one confused me as well because there are some foods that I can see that packaging is helpful for you know you've got delicate foods like berries that might become damaged in transport and I can see use for some packaging in some products and tomatoes for me fall into that category. So I'm a little bit confused about this one. So if you are a tomato lover you can save money by buying them loose where you've got the option to do so. But it was the only item that we consistently surveyed that was actually cheap at a loose well I actually noticed the other day that the grapes are now this season coming in paper bags.
SPEAKER_02They're not in plastic anymore. I saw that the other day I was quite surprised. Well I wonder if that was as a result of the just they you know you all your grapes used to come in those horrible plastic bags and yeah they're all apparently recycled paper and etc on them now.
SPEAKER_00That doesn't happen until investigations like this find right on the issue.
How possible is it to shop plastic-free in a supermarket?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. But hypothetically if I do happen to have the extra money, let's say that I'm uh rot just rolling in cash one day and decide to splash out I can buy the more expensive loose potatoes. But does that mean it's easy for me to avoid plastic wrapped food at the supermarket?
SPEAKER_01No, not at all. What we're finding with our audit and with the surveys that we're getting from supporters is that it's becoming so hard to avoid plastic packaging. So all you have to do is walk down the aisles and look at your choices and you'll find that it's incredibly difficult. So even if you've got all the money in the world and you want to go and buy all of your produce loose there's still some items that you can't get loose at the supermarket. And then when you step out of that fresh produce aisle there's plastic packaging everywhere you look so it's incredibly difficult for shoppers and we need to make sure that there's other choices for people to avoid plastic packaging and that they're not being penalized financially for doing so but it's it's not easy at the
Which supermarket chain scores highest on plastic use?
SPEAKER_01moment.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely so with your audit you used your volunteer secret investigators but you also audited the supermarkets with some of the data that they could give you and other methods of auditing them as well. So how did the supermarkets score overall for their plastic use?
SPEAKER_01Well in the first year it was a pretty woeful result. All of the supermarkets came in well and truly under 50% and so this audit looks at supermarket practices and policies across five different categories. So we're looking at things like transparency, plastic reduction, reuse, reusable and refillable packaging, recycling, as well as their policies and their governance. So all of the supermarkets failed in 2023. 2024 saw an improvement across the board but really not enough. So Woolworths came out on top in the 2024 audit they received a total score of 38% overall so it's a low bar for everyone. It's a low bar, absolutely yeah so we're what we're finding is that the supermarkets are they're all claiming to be leading the way on sustainability but they're just not going as quickly as we wanted. You know the plastic pollution crisis is getting worse every day. Projections for the amount of plastic packaging that we're using continue to increase and they're just not doing enough to cut the overall plastic packaging on their shelves.
SPEAKER_00Yeah so if anyone wants to see this scorecard of how the supermarkets scored on their plastic use practices it's available on the website of the Australian Marine Conservation Society. But yeah Woolworths improved their score in the second year of the audit which was 2024 and that goes to show that releasing this data really helps to pressure them, right? Because that's what probably drove them to try to improve their score, isn't it?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely and
Can consumers make informed choices at supermarkets?
SPEAKER_01they're sharing slightly more data with us from the first year where we got very little and I spent hours and hours and hours trawling through their sustainability reports and their media releases trying to find information about what they're actually doing. And still in 2024 none of the supermarkets were willing to share their overall plastic packaging footprint. So that's the amount of plastic that they're using on packaging on their shelves but also out the back the things we don't see so the supply chain and the packaging that they're getting food from you know farmers and distributors none of them are willing to share that. So they're giving us more but we still don't know exactly how much plastic packaging they're pumping out every single year.
SPEAKER_00Wow yes and a key part of consumer choices which they say that we need to have choices but consumers need information about how their choices might be impacting the environment they need the information about that supply chain so we can make informed choices. So it's hard for us as consumers to make good choices when it's so opaque to find out what the supermarkets are doing with their plastic packaging. So yeah just uh those overall scores again though for any listeners that are curious Woolworths is on top with 38% then I see Metcash on 23% score Kohl's on 20% and Aldi on 16% is that right Tara?
SPEAKER_01Yeah that's exactly right and for anyone who hasn't heard of Metcash they're the company that owns brands like the IGA and they have a chain of independently run stores. Their structure is a little bit different to the other three but they're still pretty significant in terms of market share and they still have control over what they do with their own brand. So Metcash brands are things like Black and gold and community and co.
SPEAKER_00All the supermarkets can have total control over the packaging for their own brand so that's why they're included in this survey we've been talking about the amount of plastic that we're bringing home from the supermarkets and we've discovered that it is a huge huge amount of plastic waste that we are bringing home from the supermarkets. So Tara
Can we recycle our way out of this plastic crisis?
SPEAKER_00we've got to talk about what are the solutions and first of all is recycling the answer to all this plastic waste that we're bringing home?
SPEAKER_01That is such a great question and we do get that a lot and it's understandable because a lot of these brands that we're talking about like supermarkets and other brands they talk a lot about recycling. I would love to cast your mind back to primary school and remind you about the three Rs. Can either of you tell me what they stand for my hands raised got to it first.
SPEAKER_02Brett tell us reuse, recycle am I right? Is that the first two? Reduce reduce reuse mind you though I'm I might be only 21 so it's a while ago since I was at school. You go for it.
SPEAKER_00I feel like all the listeners are in there because I was right with the radios.
SPEAKER_01Yeah you've got them right but Tara's talking about in order so reduce reuse recycle the order's really critical because what these three R's are are just a really simplified version of something called the waste hierarchy. And this tells us how we should prioritize actions to reduce plastic pollution to reduce waste generally and so the the order is really critical reduce then reuse and recycles right at the end. It always has been but we think of it top of mind. So we know that recycling alone will not solve the plastic pollution crisis. I want to be really clear about that because the bin that you put your rubbish in is not the be all and end all of your impact on plastic pollution. What really has an impact is right at the beginning. So I'm talking about the choice that you make to buy something or not buy something and you know the materials that are involved in that, the processes that went into making that that's the really critical part. So what we're pushing for supermarkets to do to make more accessible for people is to first of all get rid of the plastic packaging that we don't need or packaging at all. You know just swapping to cardboard isn't a great solution. Firstly we need to say what do we need if we don't need it let's get rid of it. Secondly if we need it can we have a reusable solution like we used to be able to get soft drinks in reusable glass bottles then we can just wash them really thoroughly sterilize them and refill them that's preferable to recycling because there's so much less process that's required to use it again in that state. And then we're talking about recycling when we can't get rid of it completely when a reusable or a refillable solution isn't available or isn't suitable that's when we look for the cycling.
SPEAKER_00Yeah and and we know for example soft plastics like your biscuit wrappers and your pasta wrappers a lot of the time we don't have the facilities to recycle them like your local council bin cannot recycle plastics that are soft. There's what is it like nine different types or grades of plastic which are made from different ingredients of plastic and the way you recycle them differs for each.
SPEAKER_02It's just so complicated to be able to recycle all those people we can also see though that that's that's avoidable because they're doing all the chocolate blocks in cardboard or something now.
SPEAKER_00Mars bars Mars bars are in the why can't the pasta companies do that?
SPEAKER_01Mm-hmm because I think some of them are yeah yeah right there's a lot of opportunities for us to get rid of plastic packaging particularly soft plastic packaging because you're right it's not widely recyclable and you know when you make something like that recyclable a lot of people forget about those first two R's the reduce and the reuse and they go straight for recycling whereas we really need to think about our food and our packaging in a very different way and get rid of what we don't need at all.
SPEAKER_00Yeah because it does take a lot of energy and resources to recycle as well so that's why reduce is the first of the R's reduce using it in the first place. But
Can we all boycott supermarkets to solve the plastic crisis?
SPEAKER_00so I suppose one solution for us as consumers is to boycott the grocery stores and only shop at local farmers markets and the health food stores where we can refill our own jars of rice and muesley.
SPEAKER_01But is that feasible or likely to become a reality for the majority of Australian shoppers look I love that idea and if you've got that available to you by all means go ahead and do that. But we know we're living in a cost of living crisis and we know that people are so time poor that supermarkets have become so popular because they are a one-stop shop and you can get everything that you need for the most part from the supermarket. But you can't take your own containers for the most part to get things from the deli or from the scoop section. You can take your own reusable bags for your groceries and for your fresh produce but we really need to make these things more available in supermarkets. They have a role to play to make these options more accessible one of the recommendations that we've put forward to the supermarkets is to have supermarket owned containers and bottles for things like rice and pasta and you know laundry detergent and send them off with online delivery shoppers because then they can give their containers back to the delivery drivers and reuse those containers over and over.
SPEAKER_02Oh what a great idea a bit like the old soft drinks that used to get delivered. Remember the glass soft drinks you drank and then you gave the bottles back and they cleaned them and brought the soft drink back. Maybe they could do bring your own container Saturday with the supermarket. Like a dedicated day where people can come in at the deli if they're going to buy at the deli give them your own container and they put your ham or your chicken or something in it.
SPEAKER_00You could probably do that now if you really thought of it and said oh just don't worry about wrapping my bacon in the container.
SPEAKER_01Well you know unfortunately that's not an option for people unless you are living in South Australia the rest of the country they will refuse your own container because they have no easy way of removing the weight of the container. So if you go to a health food store, a bulk store or maybe even your local butcher, you know, they might be able to do this for you. So if you shop at butchers or seafood markets, you know, give it a go. Take your own containers and see how you go. But I think a message I really want to leave to you both and to your listeners is if you're not happy with things the way they are if you want to take your own container to the supermarket and you can't then do something about it. Use your voice. Tell them what you want to see. Because if we just accept things the way that they are then things aren't going to change and we're going to continue along this path of increasing plastic pollution. So yeah use your voice use your dollar do whatever you can to make the world the way that you want to see it.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely so we've only got about three minutes left but just to sum up I think yes it's not time wise and cost wise feasible for everyone or sort of likely that everyone can go to five different shops like the baker, the health food shop, the butcher there's not always as much parking the farmers markets is only open on weekends there's no air con and no shopping trolleys there's so many accessibility issues of why the majority of Australians are probably going to keep shopping at supermarkets. You know the organic food at the health food shop is always more expensive than the food at the supermarket. So if you can afford to do those things and you have the time to go to multiple different shops and markets on specific days of the week then do it. But I think the work that you're doing Tara to try and improve the standards in the supermarkets which is where the majority of people shop is so important. And I think you mentioned raising our voice
Is legislation the answer?
SPEAKER_00and do you think the industry will continue reforming its own practices or do you feel like we need to push for legislation to enforce more solutions just like we had the plastic bag ban at the checkouts?
SPEAKER_01Yeah look I was uh lucky enough to attend a packaging conference recently and I had high hopes for discussions about sustainable packaging. But all I heard over the next two days was about how brand owners were really unwilling to make big changes. You know there were statements things like evolution not revolution that were being said at this conference. So I don't think that we're going to see the changes that we need without the government stepping in. So the government's promise to reform packaging legislation in Australia and we're really urging them to take that seriously and act on it as quickly as possible because the longer we wait the worse it gets.
SPEAKER_00And the more expensive it will be to clean it all up. So we need to get on the front foot and not wait ages for these slow incremental changes. Well there's so much more we could talk about and maybe we can get you back on the show another time to dive into the Global Plastics Treaty a bit more because we've we're just about out of time Yeah I would love to come back and talk more about that. I could talk about it forever. Yeah so could we well excellent
What can listeners do to help?
SPEAKER_00for all those listeners out there who want to do something to help with this ocean plastics campaign we know they can reduce, reuse recycle, they can pick up litter but what else can they do with regards to your AMCS supermarkets packaging campaign and where can they head to find out more?
SPEAKER_01You can join our plastic investigation unit and become a real life detective in your supermarket and if you work for Plastic Investigation unit it should come up it's with the Australian Marine Conservation Society. You sign up you undertake a really quick survey on your phone while you're at the supermarket you can do it as many times as you want and then we can see whether the supermarkets are improving over time or if we need to push them harder.
SPEAKER_00All right Tyra Jones Plastics and Packaging Program Manager from the Australian Marine Conservation Society it's been amazing having you on the show today.
SPEAKER_02Yeah thank you so much it's been a real eye opener for everyone I reckon it's been great.
SPEAKER_00Amazing thank you Tyra and thanks to you our listeners for joining us on Word on the Reef. I'm Tanya Murphy my co-host is Brett Goodband thanks guys we'll be back next Friday at 10 a.m with more awesome marine science adventures have a great week. Best bitches and see you next time