Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E8: Hot Water and Hot Air: Which Political Parties Have the Best Policies to Protect the Great Barrier Reef?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In this special Election Edition of Word on the Reef, Tanya Murphy and Brett Goodban dive into one of the most critical questions facing Australians ahead of the Federal Election: Who has the best plan to save the Great Barrier Reef?
To find out, we’re joined by Maria Poulos Conklin, Head of Government Relations at the Australian Conservation Foundation, who breaks down ACF's powerful Election Scorecard, comparing how each major party stacks up on climate and environmental policies... and let's just say it's a little confronting!
PLUS, all the major political candidates for the Far North Queensland electorate of Leichhardt have been invited to share their Reef protection policies with us. Today we're joined by Dr Phillip Musumeci, Greens candidate for Leichhardt, to talk about tube worms, space lasers and why sheep are big fans of solar energy. 🐑
If you care about the Reef and having a safe climate, this episode is a must-listen before you head to the polls.
🎧 Listen now and share with a mate who's still deciding their vote.
🌐 Scorecard link: www.acf.org.au/scorecard
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
This is Word on the Reef, where marine science meets adventure. Join Tanya Murphy and Brett Goodband to plunge into the wonders of the Great Barrier Reef and explore the mysteries beneath the waves. Yes, good morning, everyone, and welcome to Word on the Reef. I'm your host, diver, and marine conservationist Tanya Murphy. And joining me, as always, is Marine Educator and fellow ocean enthusiast Brett Goodband. Good morning. Hello, everybody. Today is, of course, Anzac Day, a solemn occasion where we pause to remember Australians and New Zealanders who served in the defence of our countries. My grandfather served in World War II. He survived, but sadly, three of his brothers didn't make it home. Do you have any veterans in your family, Brett?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, so um both grandparents on both sides served, some in Europe and some in Australia. My amazing nephew graduated as a naval officer and a very special young lady in our lives at the moment, is part of the Naval Cadets and did her Anzac march this morning. So we're super proud.
SPEAKER_00Anzac Day is a powerful reminder of the sacrifices past generations made to protect our amazing country. And that raises the question: what are we doing now to protect this amazing country and especially all its natural wonders for future generations that follow us? How will they remember us for the actions we are taking now? So speaking of that, we're now just one week away from the Australian federal election. Early voting is already open, and Australians head to the polls officially on Saturday, the 3rd of May. And as we mentioned last week, some are calling this election the reef's last real chance, because if we don't make big cuts to emissions this decade, we may not get another shot in time to save it. And the decisions made in the next term of government, especially around climate targets and accelerating the shift to renewables, will determine a lot of the future of the Great Barrier Reef. So today we've put together a bit of an election special for our lucky listeners. Later in the show, we'll be joined by Maria Paulos-Conklin, Head of Government Relations at the Australian Conservation Foundation. She'll break down how the major parties score on their climate and environmental commitments. And spoiler alert, you might be surprised by some of the results. If you're still on the fence about who to vote for, especially when it comes to protecting our environment, stick around. You won't
Phil Musumeci Bio
SPEAKER_00want to miss it. But first, let's kick things off with our first guest, Dr. Phil.
SPEAKER_04Dr. Phil? Geez, we've done all right.
SPEAKER_00Not the American TV psychologist. This one's a local legend, Dr. Philip Musumechi, the Greens candidate for Leichart. And just a quick note, I've reached out to all major candidates for this seat. That includes Labour's Matt Smith and LMP's Jeremy Neal, inviting them to come on the show and share their reef policies with you, our listeners. I haven't heard back from all of them just yet, but the invitation's still out there, so hopefully we'll hear back from them. I'd love to have them on next week's show. Of course, we know it's a frantic time for all candidates in the final lead up to the election, so we're just especially grateful that Philip could spare the time to chat with us today. Now, Phil grew up on his family's sugarcane farm in Babinda, just south of Cairns, and now lives in Cairns with his wife and son. He's a computer scientist and engineer who's taught thousands of students at JCU and other universities. And he's also a prolific inventor. He's even helped invent a space laser.
SPEAKER_04Stop it.
SPEAKER_00But back in the 90s, Phil helped modernize the sugar milling industry with electronic tech that transformed the way mills operate. A pretty big deal when you think about how important the sugarcane industry is for Far North Queensland. These days he's working on self-driving industrial vehicles.
How to Spy on Tube Worms
SPEAKER_00But one of the coolest things, in my opinion, is that Phil was part of the team that invented one of the first marine life data loggers used by the Marine Park Authority on the Great Barrier Reef. This early technology helped monitor the activity of tube worms as an indicator of reef health. Do you know what a tube worm is, Brad?
SPEAKER_04Oh, do I want? I have spent thousands of hours staring at them, hoping they'll pop out and then pop back in. So any divers out there will know you have the massive boulder coals, and some of them can get up to the size of a house. They're huge. But these little calcium structures that come out like a flower are all colours of the rainbow. And actually they can live for about 40 years. They're just incredible. And they also have been known to help uh corals growth around where they live. And in turn of them popping out of those boulder corals, as they pop out, they actually knock the tube feet off the crown of thorns to knock them off the boulder coral. Wow. And will help support life. They're just amazing. So yeah, anyone who's been diving knows a Christmas tree worm, you waste a lot of air looking at them.
SPEAKER_00Okay. Well, Christmas tree worms are one of the types, but I think there's a few different types of tube worms as well. And when you swim past them, they often retract back inside their little tubes. And that's one of the things that they were monitoring with these with this early tech. And this was back before uh camera traps were invented. So, you know, a lot of people might think they're not particularly interested in the activity of tube worms. But that was one of the earliest reef health measuring devices on the reef, and that laid the foundation for the data loggers that are still in use today for purposes like logging water quality and temperatures on the reef. How cool is that.
SPEAKER_04Well, we all know that animals are going to tell us, aren't they?
SPEAKER_00That's true.
SPEAKER_04They know it better than we do.
SPEAKER_00That is very true. We need to pay close attention to the messages that we're getting from nature, whether it is from tube worms or not. But what we're really keen to find out today is what are the Greens' plans to protect the Great Barrier Reef? Because while they're still considered a minor party, the Greens do have a significant influence in Parliament. And here in Queensland, Green Senator Larissa Waters is up for re-election. So this is an important moment to consider their policies, especially with regard to protecting the reef. If you've just tuned in, today is an Australian election special. We're going to help you get informed about each party's reef protection policies before you head to the polls.
Phil Musumeci on Space Lasers
SPEAKER_00And our first guest today is Green's candidate for Lightheart, Dr. Philip Musumechi. And of course, we'll be talking reef policy with him. But first, I just had to ask Phil about something a little more out of this world. We've all heard of people dumping rubbish into our oceans. But did you know we're also polluting space? It turns out old satellites and space debris are starting to clutter up the sky. And Phil worked on an invention to help clean it up, a space laser.
SPEAKER_03Oh, cool.
SPEAKER_00To help deal with orbital junk. So here's what he had to say.
SPEAKER_03So the idea was for about 15 minutes a time, because that's how long you get usually to see a piece of junk in the sky as it moves across the sky. You keep pulsing your laser at that for a little 15-minute burst. You do that for about two to three weeks, and eventually that piece of junk will get a speed of about two centimeters a week. And I know that sounds extremely slow, but you're finished with that piece of junk, it's now going to just drift away.
SPEAKER_00It becomes Mars's problem or the moon's problems. You could say that.
SPEAKER_03But anyway, the important thing is they're about 200 meters away from the geostationary orbit, and that's enough. By the way, this would not be a problem if people would just park their satellites in the proper place when they were finished using them.
SPEAKER_00Ugh, report report them online. You know that uh there's those Facebook groups for the Kansas worst parkers. Yeah. If you've got a satellite emblazoned with a country's logo, name and shame them for poor parking.
SPEAKER_03Well, it is a problem. You know, there's this urge to keep using communication satellites right to the very end when they run out of propellant. Of course, if they run out of propellant, they're stuck.
SPEAKER_00And there's agreements of best practice, but they're not always so people should be using the last energy of their satellite to move it out of the way.
SPEAKER_02Oh, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Well, obviously, people were funding this program because space junk is becoming a big problem. So it's exciting to know that you worked as part of that project and hopefully they keep going forward and can clean up the space junk in future.
SPEAKER_03Or at least not make more. You know, people are at least becoming a bit aware now. I mean, this idea that you could just keep polluting the place, it's a very much a down-to-earth problem as well. But you know, we see people not looking to the future and just discarding their rubbish in inappropriate ways everywhere.
What inspired you to run for office with the Greens?
SPEAKER_00What inspired you to be active with the Greens and ultimately run for parliament?
SPEAKER_03There's three things. One was there was a time when there was a report to the army which talked about misogyny in the army, and uh, David Morrison gave a talk which went viral on YouTube about people in the army having to step up, and whenever they saw something that was unacceptable, they were not allowed to walk past it. They had to do something about it. And his magic phrase was, Whatever you walk by, you are accepting. And that really echoed in my mind. But then the other thing that got me going was Richard Dinatali. He's an ex-leader of the Greens. He read a lot about sustainability, and one of the things that got me with his writing was he kept saying we can have a sustainable income, but we won't have to do it out things. There will be a sense of abundance or a sense of having enough. The aim is to have just a good life. And his idea about a good life that triggered an understanding for me. And then after COP21, I read well almost a thesis by Pope Rantis called On the Common Good. And the whole document is about ecology and how you have to have respect for nature, how you have to have respect for plants and animals, and the the fundamental message there I got from that was that we have a responsibility of stewardship over the natural world. Are you a Catholic, Phil? No, I'm agnostic. But the clarity in the voice in that piece about our need to look after our world, that helped me on my way. Those people basically they say to me, you can't just ignore things if you've got the ability to do something
What are your Reef Protection Policies?
SPEAKER_03about it.
SPEAKER_00Let's talk about the reef now. What will you do if elected to help protect the Great Barrier Reef?
SPEAKER_03Well, one of the big efforts that the Greens announced in December last year was uh improving of water quality. And at that time there was an announcement saying we were going to invest $4 billion. But $2 billion of that was on water quality, and it is over 25 years. What we're saying here is we've got to try and improve the runoff onto the reef over that period. There has been some work done in trying to have our water quality plan over that period. So we've got to fund that work, and an important element of this would be land care. That is, we're trying to work with farmers, for example, and reduce runoff. And oftentimes the things that we would like farmers to do are things that farmers would probably like to do anyway. Things like losing less topsoil, and in fact, there's a big effort in the greens for regenerative agriculture in the country greens. And then the other aspect is the chemical content as well. And I happen to work in the precision navigation world these days, and what we see happening in farming now is that it is possible for farmers who are, for example, using fertilizer to deliver that fertilizer at different levels across a field based on the actual needs of the plant in a certain point. So they're able to deliver fertilizer in a way that should not have any excess to put in and therefore reduces the amount that might run off. So that precision, agriculture, is something that we would be uh promoting in that land care program.
How can we make sure no World Heritage Areas or sheep will be harmed in the transition to 100% renewables?
SPEAKER_00We know that the biggest threat to the Great Barrier Reef is climate change. So it's great to see that the Greens have a policy to deliver 100% renewable energy by 2030 in Australia and phase out coal and gas, including exports. But there was one wind farm project uh slated for Far North Queensland in recent years, which ended up getting rejected because it was really close to a World Heritage Area. So, how do you think we can get to 100% renewables as quickly as we need to to save the reef, whilst making sure these projects are appropriate and safe for nature and for communities?
SPEAKER_03Well, as a start, I guess a rule of thumb would be don't go putting any kind of project, renewable energy or whatever, right next to World Heritage Areas. But in more general ways, actually going out and seeking areas that are appropriate for renewable energy. If you look at New South Wales, their West Azana renewable energy zone, they went out looking for farming areas. They were particularly looking at grazing areas because their idea was, well, if we can put, say, wind farms or solar panels in an area where there's already been a loss of the original vegetation, we're minimizing ecological harm and we're still maximizing the benefit of having lower pollution energy sources. So that thinking is starting to happen in Queensland. For example, uh west of Gladstone, there are some wind farm projects there that are in, well, they're not in World Heritage Areas for a start. And um west of Townsville or West of Charter Stouse, really, there are some projects going ahead there where the area itself may be grazing land. So from a farmer's point of view, there might be a supplementary income. Meanwhile, we get access to sunshine or wind. And in the last year or so, there's been some work with solar panels being co-located on grazing areas where merinos are grazing. And if you put them in an area with solar panels at appropriate distances, then they benefit from shade in the middle of the day. And it turns out that the dew in the morning lasts a bit longer when there's shade in the morning as well. So the sheep end up earning about 18% more for the farmer.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, I read about that online as well. And lots of farmers are swearing by it. You just run your sheep underneath the solar panels. The sheep have shade, the grass is greener and more healthy for the sheep, they produce better wool, and the sheep mow the lawn for you, so there's like no maintenance on your solar panel areas. So I want to get back to the reef. So we know the reef is currently bleaching, and it's the sixth time in under a decade to have a mass bleaching
Is the Great Barrier Reef's mass bleaching a national emergency?
SPEAKER_00event. So do you think this could be grounds for declaring a national emergency? And maybe would you support an emergency response?
SPEAKER_03In the Greens, we do think that these kinds of events are an emergency. What we've been saying is if you have bushfires every three years, say, then eventually there's something catastrophically wrong with that environment. And so we would apply the same logic to the ocean. Of course, what's different here is people aren't seeing it. They're not living in that reef. So we've got this problem that people are not aware of some of these events. And I would just look across to people that are studying the reef, and if they're telling us that this is extremely unusual, then that sounds like a a prompt for more action.
Phil's personal story about the devastating 2023 Cyclone Jasper flood event.
SPEAKER_00Climate change isn't just impacting the Great Barrier Reef. It's also making extreme weather events like floods worse. And our community in Kansas has been hit hard. Hundreds of people were affected by Cyclone Jaswa in 2023. What impact did that flood have on you, Phil?
SPEAKER_03Uh in my case, I had a mud slide at the side of my house. It took me two or three days to dig a gap between the mud and the side of my house. So that was a bit of a wake-up call. But you know, worse was I was looking out over one of the floodplains of the Barren River, watching people in Camaranga villas basically leaving their homes. There was a lot of disaster where I live in in Caravonica. It was a pretty just generally terrible event. And actually you can walk around in Camaranga villas now, or you can walk around in bits of Holloway's beach now, and we've got areas of our city that are essentially unrepaired. I don't know if the people had no insurance. I mean that there will have been situations like that, or simply that there's been so much work required that jobs just haven't been done. My backyard is still a bit of a moving disaster, quite literally. And I know friends in Maitrons who I actually I got a a lovely friend, her house was flooded, a bunch of us went over there and we pressure cleaned its floor. In the end it turned out she couldn't live in it anyway because there were other concerns with the water that had gone through that house. And lately I heard her say that you know we're a bit more than a year on. She's just decided that she's not going to live there anymore, anyway. She's just worn out.
Cost of living and affordable solar power for renters!
SPEAKER_00Cost of living is a big issue this election. And some of the ways that impacts us in Far North Queensland is due to climate disasters like Cyclone Jasper, which saw hundreds of people being impacted. We've also got soaring insurance premiums because of increasing climate disasters. But another one is obviously access to cheap, clean energy like rooftop solar. So, how would you help cannons locals and renters access cheap clean energy like rooftop solar?
SPEAKER_03There's a proposal that renters will be able to get loans to pay off solar panels on a roof, and the owner of the building will have the option of not paying for those panels, which is fair enough. They've got their investment working, we're not trying to mess things up for them. But at a later stage, if they, for example, sell the building, then what that owner can do is they can say, okay, what's the residual value of these panels? It might be relatively low. So for a fairly small price, they might be able to take on full ownership of those panels and then sell a building that's got solar panels on it. But in the interim period, we've got a way for a renter to have access to a battery grant and to gain the benefits of a battery, and we haven't interfere with the rights of the owner.
Great Barrier Reef bleaching events could have been prevented
SPEAKER_00Have you ever been out and seen coral bleaching happen, or at least seen pictures of it? And how does that make you feel?
SPEAKER_03The aspect that I find hard to handle is the arbitrary or senseless loss of something in nature. You see something gone, and you know that we could have made some decisions differently that need not have caused that, and we would have been no worse off. I mean, it's just sad, and the sense of needless loss, that's really irritating.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. Senseless loss also frustrates me. Scientists have known about climate change for I think over a hundred years. They've been raising the alarm about it increasingly over recent decades, and a lot of the time on deaf ears. So if governments had actually got together a lot earlier and agreed to transition away from fossil fuels, these coral bleachings that we're seeing right now could have been prevented, is probably the most frustrating thing. We could have 100% prevented this, and it wouldn't require us giving up having nice things. Like we could have nice things with renewable energy.
SPEAKER_03That is Richard Dinatelli's basic philosophy. You can have a good life, but you have to have a long-term view. Humans are animals and they need a place to live, and it's got to be able to sustain them. I'm not sure why people think that we don't need to care about humans and other animals in our environment. They all need somewhere safe.
SPEAKER_00We are not separate from the environment we're part of it, which is something that if people were to listen to the traditional owners of this country, that they would definitely understand. But as a parent, how concerned are you for, you know, seeing amazing wonders like the Great Barrier Reef and the rainforest being threatened by climate change?
SPEAKER_03We want to be relentlessly positive about how we can restore and preserve our environment. We want those future generations to have a chance of a good life like us. We've been very lucky. We've got to keep it possible for future generations to have those experiences as well.
SPEAKER_00Philip Musumerci, Australian Greens candidate for Lightheart. Thanks very much for your time today. Thank you.
Introducing our Second Guest, Maria Poulos Conklin
SPEAKER_00Good morning, everyone. If you've just tuned in, welcome to our Australian election special here on Word on the Reef. If you're still on the fence about which party has the strongest plans to protect the reef, stick around because up next, we're diving into a deep analysis of where each major party stands on climate and environmental policy. Joining us is someone who knows the ins and outs of this better than just about anyone, Maria Paulos Conklin, Head of Government Relations at the Australian Conservation Foundation. Maria has worked in foreign affairs and crisis management for the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade with postings in France, Sri Lanka, and Mauritius, and served as a peace monitor in Bougainville after the civil conflict. Maria is also the founder of the Save the Bay Coalition, which campaigns for biodiversity and heritage protection in Sydney. At the Australian Conservation Foundation, Maria has helped produce a comprehensive election scorecard comparing how each political party stacks up on climate and environmental commitments. And spoiler alert, some of the results may shock you.
SPEAKER_02Yes.
SPEAKER_00Good morning, Maria, and thanks so much for joining us. Good morning. Thanks for having me.
SPEAKER_04It's our pleasure.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thanks for coming on the show. Let's start with a little bit of background. For listeners who aren't familiar with the Australian Conservation Foundation or ACF, can you tell us a bit about who you are and what you do?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, so I'm here on behalf of the Australian Conservation Foundation. We're Australia's oldest national environment organization. We were founded in 1965. And today we are a community of over 700,000 people, and we're united by a commitment to protect the places and the wildlife that we love. Now, my role, I'm the Parliamentary Relations Manager, or as you said that has government relations. And my job is to basically camp out of Parliament House when there are sittings and help our wonderful campaigners and policy experts engage with some politicians, MPs, parties, and do activities in advocacy at Parliament House and also engage with government and bring some cohesion to how we do that. And you know, for my Finns, I was also tasked with coming up with the with ACF's uh election scorecards, which we do for every election. It's a very involved process, which I'm really happy to be telling you about today.
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's that's just so helpful, that scorecard. It's great.
SPEAKER_00Yes,
Why this election is so critical for our environment and Reef
SPEAKER_00Brett and I have been having a close look at it and it is very interesting. But before we dive into how the political parties scored on their environmental policies, why is this election such an important moment for our natural environment, including our threatened species ecosystems and of course the Great Barrier Reef?
SPEAKER_01Yes, this is the crucial decade for climate and nature. It's a moment of reckoning for our coal reefs. And we, you know, we really need to stop pouring fuel on the climate fire. And the science tells us we don't have time to wait. This next parliament must take bold action if we want to protect the places and the people and the the creatures that we love. So it's crucial because we need to slash climate pollution fast and build a 21st century energy system based on renewable energy that will power jobs and communities across the country. And if we don't cut emissions and transition, the Great Barrier Reef will continue to decline. You know so so it's well and good to have monitoring of the Great Barrier Reef, but we really need solutions. And we really need to fix our broken environment laws so they actually stop the destruction of habitat and species loss. So you know we have a window this is why we've done this. No, it's crucial because decisions made in the next three years will set the path for decades and the windows closing fast and we see this election as being the moment. It's about protecting our kids' futures it's about protecting the reef it's about protecting all the places we've got channel country it's really important that the next three years changes things for nature and climate.
SPEAKER_00It's really going to be pivotal because it's going to take us through until almost the end of the decade which is a like you said it's crunch time for the Great Barrier Reef and other climate affected
About ACF's election scorecard
SPEAKER_00ecosystems. So let's talk about the election scorecard now. You and the ACF team have reviewed and ranked the major parties climate and environment policies. How did you measure each party's performance? What was your approach?
SPEAKER_01So I'll just start by saying we created it because you know Australians deserve transparency and so many people who care deeply about the environment they they feel overwhelmed when it comes to understanding what politicians are actually doing right so you know and then as I just said the nature and climate crisis is right here and right now and the most powerful thing Australians can do to avoid the worst is to vote for politicians for the plan. You know a plan to cut pollution to restore nature and transition to renewables. So we built the scorecard and it's it's a research driven nonpartisan tool that cut through the political spin and what we did was we looked at 54 detailed tests of success. That's just another way of saying what are the 54 policies that matter what is good policy we looked at that and they were centered around four major themes. One was saving nature and that like who has the best policies to fix our broken nature laws and to invest in nature and and deforestation. The second theme was championing renewables who is committing to building more renewables faster in the right locations and to advocate for well planned faster closures of coal-fired plants and phase out gas right and who who has signed aligned 2035 targets. Then the other two tests were stopping the climate records which of the parties and candidates is actually advocating to stop new coal and gas approval and make Australia renewable manufacturing and export superpowers and have no new subsidies for coal and gas and finally was rejecting nuclear because we we see nuclear as dangerous polluting expensive and a distraction so they were the four tests and then we surveyed all the candidates on all our tests and analysed their public commitments, their performance in parliament in the last term and also what they're saying they'll do in the next parliament. Who we scored was the major parties obviously the coalition Labour and the Greens then we did all the incumbent independents all those teals and the other regional community independents and Bob Cadder and Dai Lee and all the others in different city seats and a bunch of independent candidates sort of running for the first time and we did that in areas where we saw a particularly interesting contest or where we have a very strong local community presence because we we obviously our supporters are very interested in those candidates. And then we we did the analysis we sent them the interim results we invited them to engage with the interim results that we we came up with and that was their opportunity to lift ambition and to you know to make more commitment and then we we basically finalized the score and we we have three tools we have a snapshot scorecard which shows tips and crosses and how well they're doing against those four tests. And we also have a digital tool online where you can enter your party candidate and see how they compare across 16 outcomes like nature laws and and climate pollution and all those things I just talked about. And so that's
Why this scorecard is so awesome
SPEAKER_01how we did it. Yes.
SPEAKER_04Well is uh I just wanted to say how helpful that is because um I'm education manager at the Cannes Aquarium and we have uh thousand people a day at the moment with school holidays it's been really busy and it's been great. And I do the coral education shows and chart shows and talk about the environment every day. And I've been mentioning this because the biggest question I'm getting at the moment from my customers is thank you for teaching us the real story. We want to care for the environment but we're just so confused as to who we want to vote for, which is the biggest question, right?
SPEAKER_00And that's why the politicians don't really help because they know the confusing thing that's right.
SPEAKER_04They can't answer a question and that's you know that's what you want. So I've been talking to them and mentioning this scorecard and said look this is available for you guys to have a look at it drowns out all the noise and it gives you the proper answers as to who's going to do the right thing and then it will point you in the direction you want to go in and and the response I've had from customers this week has been incredible compared to the last election because they now know that this is the most important election that our reef environment can have. So it's very helpful.
SPEAKER_01Yeah and that sounds like you did a tremendous amount of work Maria it must have been a big project and it it sounds like it's really thorough big team working on it yeah we did it very comprehensively because I think um it's very important to have that credibility behind the results because you know not everyone is pleased with the results often. So yeah it has to be robust.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely all right
THE BIG REVEAL: How did the parties score on their environment and climate policies?
SPEAKER_00well now is the moment we've all been waiting for the big unveil Maria how did the parties score? Who would you like me to start with? Well there there's there's there's a standout headline for me when I looked at the full results there's someone there is a party which scored only one point.
SPEAKER_01A whole one point out of a hundred is doing all right yeah they did very well the coalition scored one percent uh and now that's the lowest score we've ever recorded and we've like I said before we've we've done this over many elections and you know their score has ranged from you know they did four percent once up to something like twenty percent uh and this is the lowest and the reason is they have no credible plans to cut climate pollution their platform is built on expanding gas providing subsidies and funding to the gas industry slashing environmental protections and promoting nuclear energy and we ACF the position is that nuclear energy is deeply expensive, risky and slow to deploy. It's a slow to deploy distraction from a real solution right and the solution is renewable energy and we want a renewable future not a radioactive future. And the other thing is they voted against every law um to cut climate pollution in the last parliament and their policies we've calculated and the Climate Council backs us in would increase pollution by at least six point three billion tons. Or was it last week Dutton could not even answer a question Oh yeah we highlighted that in our show.
SPEAKER_04Yeah I nearly fell off my chair I couldn't believe it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah I'm not a scientist. Well I'm not a scientist either but I do listen to scientists and it's a classic climate denying response to saying I'm not a scientist and it's just not acceptable for a party or a senior political leader to claim they don't know the risks Australians are facing. I mean especially if you're vying to be Prime Minister not to have educated yourself thoroughly about the science. And so their positions for us are are just totally regressive and they they're avoiding action and so for us the coalition policy would policies would make the climate crisis worse. So we could not do anything but give them one percent and we've invited them to engage with us and commit to you know try to improve their score but um at the moment it stays at one percent so they have on the bottom of their report card from primary school room for improvement.
SPEAKER_00Room for improvement again and so yeah just drawing that back to the reef with that amount of extra pollution in the atmosphere that you mentioned Maria I kind of imagine what that would spell for the Great Barrier Reef which is currently in the middle of its sixth mass bleaching event in nine years. But I guess the ALP are not completely off the hook with their score as well how did they how did the Labour Party score on the scorecard?
SPEAKER_01So they've gone a bare path we scored them 54%. Now the thing with the ALP they've they've made strong progress on renewables and clean energy manufacturing and and they have said no to nuclear power. They have unlocked you know $87 billion of public and private investing in renewable power, storage and transmission and they have set strict limits on industrial polluters and they did create the vehicle standards to ensure new cars use less petrol and release less pollution but unfortunately for them that progress has been undermined by their continued support for new coal and gas projects and their failure to deliver on our nature law reform. Labor's approved 26 coal oil and gas development and and just last week you know the biggest dirtiest gas project in Australia the Barossa was approved and that threatens to emit a whopping 270 million tonnes of CHO into the atmosphere over the life of the project and this is like this is during an election campaign and it shows it shows the direction we're heading in with the ALP as well and they promised to fix the States broken environment laws coming into the last parliament but they ended the term by weakening them instead by creating um I don't know if you followed the salmon industry saga in Tasmania where they basically carved out a special exemption for the salmon industry. So that is a real backsliding and it's very disappointing. There's a lot of potential there but we've seen so much backsliding and we said to them if they commit to nature law reform in this campaign this election campaign and a timeline for nature law reform they could up their score but we unfortunately haven't received a response to that. So they get 54% and we hope that we at least get in the first hundred days some stronger commitments than we have right now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah wow so 54% well it's a bear pass. It's it's 54 times better than what the L MP got though. How about the Greens then Maria?
SPEAKER_01Well the Greens scored very well they got a high distinction 98% they've committed to halting deforestation they're committed to funding nature like they want to see one percent of the federal budget going to nature they support transition to renewables and their agenda when you read it on their website it's very ambitious it's science based and they supported every single climate bill in the last parliament and they also secured a number of important amendments including placing a hard cap on climate pollution and protecting clean energy investment from future rollbacks. So all round they performed very well in the last parliament and their commitments are very strong so they got a very good score from us.
SPEAKER_00Wow okay so that's pretty much speaks for itself 98%. And there's another party which has uh its stomping ground up here in far north Queensland which is the Cato Australia Party how did they rate?
SPEAKER_01Yeah so look I'll start by saying like we also did all the Table independence and they also scored very highly for their strong science-based commitment to climate nature and they've all made very valuable contributions to strengthening climate action and to get greater household electrification support in the last parliament so they've all gotten scores in the eighties and nineties that's really important I should have asked you about that because we do have listeners across Australia on our online podcast as well so thanks for letting us know about those TIL independents.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Yeah have a look at their results because their their influence of re-elected is expected to grow in the likely event of a hung parliament as well so we thought scoring them was would be really important. But we also scored Bob Catter and Dile and other more conservative independents and uh unfortunately Bob didn't engage with our survey he we did a thorough you know search of his website and his voting record in Parliament and we just I hate to say this he he did worse than the Liberal Party because at least they engaged with our survey not zero percent. Zero and and look I did a little bit of research before this program I looked up your local candidate Daniel Collins and I got a little bit excited by it because I saw oh he's an ecologist and you know he's got a background in human rights and land management and you know and then I I read a bit more and he actually wants to open up the cape for more grazing and forestry and and uh you know I think okay he wants to do it sustainably and he sees you know planting more trees in safe forest as a climate solution which is great but advocating for more forestry in a world heritage area is not is not aligned to what we are advocating and our policies and priorities. But I do invite Daniel to engage with us if he wants to talk about his climate policies and nature policies there's still time to improve his score but unfortunately we can only give the Cather Australia Party and Bob Catter zero at this point.
SPEAKER_00Well there you have it folks so to sum up the LMP 1% ALP 54% Greens 98% Cather Australia Party 0% on their scores for protecting the environment and acting on climate. And we know that polls consistently show that the majority of Australians care deeply about climate change and want to see stronger action to protect our environment. So as we are the ones that are that are hiring these people it's interesting to see how many are not actually um I've gone on to that I've just been shaking my head for about five minutes.
SPEAKER_04I just I just don't understand it. I don't and that's the bonus of our go is we can connect with everyone from every walk of life and I hope that our listeners of Word on the reef in what is this now our eighth show something like that. Something like that flying have been able to find that connection that we've been bringing across about our environment and our reef with our life experience and everything and we hope that this will steer you in the right direction.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely so obviously it's it's everyone's individual choice but people can't make a choice if they are confused by all of the sort of misinformation that politicians are throwing out there. So it's really good to have this sort of nonpartisan science fact-based comparison.
Why aren't we seeing more ambitious environment and climate policies from the two major parties?
SPEAKER_00And as I was saying for young Australians who now make up the largest voting demographic climate is one of their top three election issues. Yes. So Maria why do you think we're not seeing more ambitious environmental policies from the two major parties?
SPEAKER_01Well it's a great question and honestly I think it comes down to a few things. One is the influence of powerful vested interests particularly in the fossil and mining sectors. You know these industries have deep pockets and strong political connections and unfortunately that influence still shapes policy outcomes and we saw it with the salmon industry corporations that led to the weakening of laws in that final sitting of the last parliament like we have a special exemption for the salmon industry and that has meant we have weakened our laws not strengthened them in the last parliament. Another reason I think is is also short term thinking because right now a lot of political debate is centred around the cost of living crisis and you know and that's really important. People are suffering right now but but I say what's often missing in the is the truth that the the cost of living will be higher if we don't transition to renewables. Absolutely yeah right so if we stay locked into fossil fuels we'll see higher power bills and more natural disasters and more economic disruption.
SPEAKER_00Insurance bills.
SPEAKER_01Insurance bills yeah households that are uninsurable because of the endowment electorate you know so you know it's really really important that people see that there is cause and effect here and the reason why they have high power bills is because we're locked into fossil fuels. And we also just very finally a final point we have to recognise that our economy is dependent on nature right so research shows that around 47% of Australia's GDP is moderately highly dependent on nature and that means protecting ecosystems like the reef. And that isn't just good environment policy it's smart economic policy that's a really good message.
SPEAKER_00Yeah 64000 full-time jobs depend on the Great Barrier Reef. Yep that's it and it's worth billions of dollars to the economy every year and that's just the Great Barrier Reef. So there's farmers and tourism all over Australia depend on us taking action and protecting what we've got and the same way that the ANSEC soldiers protected what we've got. So that's all we have time for actually um folks but Maria Paul Conklin Head of Government relations at the Australian Conservation Foundation great to have you on the show today.
SPEAKER_04Thank you for your incredible work.
SPEAKER_01Oh thank you so much for having me and for allowing us to share the scorecard and can I just quickly say acf.org.au stroke scorecard that's where you can find it um share it talk about it use it and talk to your local candidates I'd like to say thank you to all of the brave men, women and animals both past and present for their service and sacrifice in times of war and peacekeeping unless we forget