Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S2 E4: Diving for Climate: Can Tourism Help Protect the Great Barrier Reef?
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week, we dive deep into the heart of the Great Barrier Reef’s current coral bleaching crisis with marine social scientist and CEO of Divers for Climate, Dr. Yolanda Waters.
🔬 What’s causing this widespread bleaching event?
🌍 How does reef tourism play a crucial role in protecting our oceans?
🤿 What can divers, snorkelers, and everyday citizens do to take action?
Join us as we explore Yolanda’s groundbreaking research on how climate conversations in tourism can inspire real change. From the power of education on the reef to the actions we can take beyond the water, this episode is packed with insight, passion, and a call to action for everyone who loves the ocean.
Don’t miss this essential conversation.
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
This is Word on the Reef, where marine science meets adventure. Join Tanya Murphy and Brett Goodban to plunge into the wonders of the Great Barrier Reef and explore the mysteries beneath the waves. Good morning everyone and welcome to Word on the Reef. My name is Tanya Murphy, and with me is my fellow aquinaut Brett Goodban.
SPEAKER_01Good morning, everyone. Show number four. So excited.
SPEAKER_00Yes, how are you, Brett?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, good. It's been a busy week, but yeah, fantastic.
SPEAKER_00And joining us in the studio today, we have Dive Instructor, Marine Social Scientist and CEO of Divers for Climate, Yolanda Waters.
SPEAKER_02Hello, thanks for having me. Excited.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, great to have you on our fourth radio show on Cairns FM. Yolanda has been diving since the age of 13 and specializes in researching climate communications and messaging in the reef tourism industry. Coming up on the show today, we'll be talking about the current coral bleaching that is actively impacting the reef from Townsville through to Cooktown right now. What causes this coral bleaching? What impact is it having and what can we do about it? We'll also be talking about a topic which Yolanda studied in her PhD, which is the reef tourism industry. What role does it play in helping protect our reef? What role can divers and snorkelers, like many of you listeners out there might be, what role can you play in protecting the reef? All these topics and more coming up on the show today. Now, for all those listening in live, save this number on your phone now. It is our text line. So if throughout this interview you have questions for us or your lander, you can text us on 0437-835937. And that will be the number for any of our future shows. So save it now and in any show that comes up in future, if you have any questions, you can send us a text. Don't call us because we're busy talking on the radio, but if you send us a text, we'll try our best to answer it. Now, time for uh what I've making a habit of doing at the start of most shows, a quick reef health update of what's currently happening out there. But firstly, uh birthday update. It is my birthday tomorrow.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you have a birthday, and you're going out with the fishies tomorrow, aren't you?
SPEAKER_00Yes, I am treating myself to a fun dive out on the reef tomorrow with Yolanda and some other divers. So I'm really excited to go out and see our.
SPEAKER_01I'll ring Wally and get him to sing your happy birthday when you get out there.
SPEAKER_00Thank you. So, yeah, even though I've spent 13 years working on the reef as a diver, as soon as I get the opportunity to just go there for fun, I'm out there again. So it really goes to show what an amazing place it is. And if there's anyone else out there that hasn't been there for a while, go check it out. But back to the subject of the reef health update. Unfortunately, the reef is now in the midst of another coral bleaching event. If there are any new listeners who want to get a deeper understanding of the science behind what is coral bleaching, what causes it, you can listen to an in-depth explanation on the Word on the Reef podcast. Listen back to season one episode two was when I did a deep dive into explaining the science of coral bleaching. But basically to sum up, carbon pollution from burning fossil fuels like coal, oil, and gas is trapping heat inside our atmosphere, causing climate change, which is heating up our planet. Much of the heat has been absorbed by the oceans, which are now at record high temperatures. The entire planet is currently in the grips of a two-year-long global coral bleaching event, which has affected corals from the Caribbean to the Pacific to the Indian Ocean, as well as here in Australia. Now the heat stress causes corals to get sick and turn white and sometimes bright fluorescent colours, which are a bright neon warning that we need to take action. Bleached corals can recover if they get a break, but as oceans continue warming, back-to-back bleaching events are making recovery increasingly difficult. And while this information is quite concerning, we will be talking about some of the solutions and what we can do so we can have a bright future for our reef. Um so stay with us. But let's take a look at what's happening on the reef at the moment, according to the Marine Park Authority, which released its latest reef health update on Wednesday. And their surveys have revealed widespread bleaching across the northern and far northern regions of the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, basically from Townsville all the way up to Cape York. Of the 440 in-water surveys conducted, 74% of reefs surveyed showed some signs of bleaching, although the severity of that bleaching varies across the reefs and the corals. And we don't have enough data from the Far Northern section yet, but I recently was in touch with the directors of the Lizard Island Research Centre, who informed me that Lizard Island, north of Cooktown, is currently experiencing its sixth back-to-back bleaching in six years. So every year for six years. They'll be, I guess, on next week's show, so we'll be able to find out more firsthand from them about what they're seeing up there next Friday. But over the past week, sea surface temperatures in the far north reached up to nearly two degrees above average. Meanwhile, in the northern section around Cairns and Port Douglas, sea surface temperatures have reached up to 1.2 degrees above average. They've had a little bit more cloud cover around here thanks to some of this rainy weather. And we know that some central areas of the reef have also been impacted by flood plumes, like the flooding that they had in Townsville, which when flood waters reduce salinity levels on inshore reefs, it can also cause bleaching and some mortality on shallow water corals at several inshore reefs, particularly impacted with the palm and family island groups. However, the bleaching we're seeing on outer reefs beyond the reach of flood plumes is a reflection of skyrocketing sea temperatures due to climate change. And meanwhile, we should note that Ningaloo Reef in Western Australia is also experiencing a severe bleaching event after temperatures there in some areas of Ningaloo Reef reached up to four degrees above average, which is just incredible. Yes. And it's the first time that widespread bleaching has occurred on both coasts at the same time, and it has scientists extremely concerned and calling out for strong climate action. Now, with that said, we know the reef is huge. Different corals are affected differently by bleaching, depending on their depth, the current local conditions, species of coral, some are more resilient than others, and so on. So it's important to remember that the reef is still beautiful, there's still lots to see out there, as evidenced by the fact that I am going out tomorrow for a fun dive on my birthday. So uh I have not lost interest or hope in the reef, and I hope all the listeners out there still understand how beautiful it is and what we still have left to fight for and protect. So that's my reef health update. Let's dive into a bit of a discussion with our guest Yolanda. Good morning again, Yolanda.
SPEAKER_01It's great to have you here. Thank you.
SPEAKER_02No, thanks for inviting me.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, so if you've just joined us, Dr. Yolanda Waters is the is a marine social scientist and CEO of Divers for Climate. Just off the back of hearing some of those latest stats of the bleaching on the reef, Yolanda, what sort of things are you experiencing or hearing from the members of Divers for Climate who are divers all up and down the reef?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, light question to start. It's tough, right? Because divers are so deeply connected to what's happening, right? I think it's a totally different thing. You can hear about it on the news, or you can hear about what's happening in warming ocean temperatures, but if you've been diving these reefs for a long time or even a short while and you've seen those changes and you've seen just what you just described, Tanya, like what the negative changes that are happening, but also the amazing things. Like it's really hard to explain that feeling to someone who's never been underwater. And so divers have this huge connection to what's happening, not just on the Great Barry, but all around the oceans and coasts around Australia. And when things like this happen, when these mass events happen, or when we're seeing these stresses that we know are from global issues that are quite challenging to tackle, they're quite complicated, the feeling of a lot of divers is there's a little bit of overwhelm, and divers are so passionate about the ocean, they're so deeply connected, and they already are doing a lot in a lot of ways. Like they're engaged in cleanups, in conservation efforts, in restoration, in in citizen science and monitoring. Like divers are actively engaged people. But when something comes through like a bleaching event because of warmer ocean temperatures, that's hard because all you can do at that point in the water is watch. Um, and that's a really uncomfortable feeling. Because I remember last year we were down in the southern Great Barry Reef when it was happening, and everyone was just like fingers crossed, because that's all you can do, right? Hope that the water cools down, it recovers, and we're safe for another year. And so the feeling a lot of divers, I think, yes, is concern, is sadness, is there's a little bit of uncertainty, but there's also a sense of what can I actually do here? Like I'm doing everything I can. It feels like a problem that's so out of our hands as individuals. And so yeah, it's a mixed bag of feelings, I think. It is.
SPEAKER_01And I think you've hit the nail on the head is that we can't ignore that connection that divers have with the wreath. And it can be really difficult for us and our colleagues that work out there and in the industry to feel watching this magnificent gift that we've been given start to slowly slip out of our fingers. It's another way of looking at it. And just all the guests that we'll have in here and everything we talk about in the show, you always hear that connection. The divers and the people in this industry have that connection, don't we? And it's something that you experience when you get underwater, and it can be a bit overwhelming when we go through all of this.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely. It has a big impact. So we'll talk a bit more about some of the research that you've done in a bit about the experiences of divers and uh tourism workers on the reef. But just as a bit of background for everyone, with the bleaching that we're seeing at the moment, do you find when you're working as a dive instructor and so on, people asking, like, is this just part of a natural cycle? Like what we're seeing, is it normal?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, I mean, people have no idea. If they have no concept of what a healthy reef looks like, they know they've got all kinds of questions. And I'm probably like, it's been a few years since I've been actively working as an instructor, so maybe Brett is better to answer some of these questions. But um, yeah, people have all kinds of natural questions. When you have no idea what to expect when you come and see the reef, for example, all you've seen is the news, all you've seen is pictures in National Geographic, or you've watched a documentary, like you've constructed this idea of what a a healthy reef is in your head. And so naturally, if you go out to a reef and it's fluorescing or it's bleached, it is stunning. Yeah. Last year the bleaching down south was I it was sad because we knew what it meant, but it was like glowing and there were there was still marine life around. It is a picture. And I had a friend, it was her first time on the reef, and she had the best time ever. She was like, that was out of this world, because it genuinely is. And so it's normal that people have those questions, which is something I guess we'll get to, is the importance of guides and tourism workers and people there to help guide that experience and that story in a way that doesn't, you know you don't want to depress them, but you also don't want them to leave without that opportunity of motivating them to act, to protect things.
SPEAKER_01It's a difficult balance.
SPEAKER_02It is, yeah.
SPEAKER_01It really is.
SPEAKER_02It's a tough job.
SPEAKER_01It is, it is, and you don't feel like I get a lot of people come into me and they go, Oh, the reef we went out yesterday, it looked incredible. But we're not we're a little bit confused after listening to your coral show about what's going on. But it looks so beautiful, it was all these beautiful fluorescent colours, and you you stand there and think, I don't want to burst their bubble.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But people want to know the real story. Yeah, you know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, for any listeners out there that aren't aware, corals naturally can be quite natural colours like brown, beige, olive. They can also be blue and purple, but they're usually quite earthy colours. Whereas um when they're stressed in the bleaching response, they can actually glow like really bright fluorescent colours. And it's just beautiful. So I've seen promotions saying come and see the reef while it's fluorescing, like it's an attraction, which is you know, it's great to go and enjoy that, but it's a sign of that the corals are under severe stress, and they can either recover from that, or if they actually succumb to it, then they won't look that beautiful for long because a dead coral is one that's overgrown by seaweed and no longer looks colourful. So, yeah, it's a really nuanced picture to try and explain to the tourists what's happening out there. But let's circle back to a bit of Yolanda's story. So, Yolanda, you did your first dive at 13. It's a lot younger than when I first started diving. So tell us about how you became enthralled with the underwater world and your journey to where you are today.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I've only just come to terms of sharing the story because I always felt like a fraud in this space. Because I used to hate the ocean. I grew up absolutely terrified. I grew up on the coast down near Sydney and um hated sand, seaweed, terrified of sharks, big waves. Not a great coastal ocean girly. Um and my my father, he was a dive instructor in his 20s and 30s, did the whole dive instructor life, traveled the world, and he was like, get your head in the water, you'll change your mind. And I was like, that sounds like the worst idea we've ever, ever had. Um and I don't I actually don't remember what changed my mind, but I did it. Did my open water course when I was 13, just after primary school down Terrible Beach, and I was so scared. But then I remember the first dive, and I was like, I like hid behind my instructor, and the first thing I saw was a cuttlefish, like a big cuddle fish.
SPEAKER_03Nice.
SPEAKER_02And I was just like, what is that? Well, you picked the right creature to ask that question. Um and I just like I'd love to say that was a you know, from then on my life was changed, but it was kind of like a from then on, like my relationship started changing with the ocean, and I was still like, because you know, diving's not the most accessible sport. So every now and again when we'd have a family trip, I'd get to do it. But it really wasn't until I finished my undergraduate degree, didn't know what to do with my life, was like, what are you supposed to do with a piece of paper? Um then uh my family was like, why don't you take a year off and go work on the Great Bear Reef or something, go do something different, get your dive mask, and I was like, Yeah, you know what, I will.
SPEAKER_00Your family is full of such good advice. I know.
SPEAKER_02I mean, it got me to where I am today. But um it was actually moving up here like six years ago and doing that, living the dream on the Great Bear Reef, getting to be in the water every day, that really was that big shift in my relationship with the ocean. Um, you know, like many people, like you guys, I'm sure, like many people up in this region, the Great Brave changed my life and the way I see things.
SPEAKER_00And then after working as a dive instructor on the reef for a bit, you decided to go back into research. So, how did that come about and what research did you decide to do?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, that was COVID's fault. Tourism wasn't a great place to be in in that time. Um, and I was stuck overseas, I got locked out of Australia. So, in that I guess in my time as working on the boats, you know, you get you get a lot of questions. What is happening on the Great Bay Reef? What's the deal with climate change? And you're just fresh up there doing a dive master. I was like, I don't know. Like, like I know what you know, I watch the news, I know it's not okay, but like the site we're going to is great to me. I've had a great time here. So what do you tell someone?
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And I ended up avoiding those questions and just being like, oh, just don't don't kick the coral, don't throw stuff in the water. And I I didn't feel satisfied with my response. You know, I was like, what can I be telling people? And so I'd started kind of reaching out to people, how do you talk about climate change? You know, I'm not a climate scientist. I was like, how do you have that conversation? I found the answers really hard to find, like people weren't openly having that conversation, or at least not where I was finding them. And so I had started talking to a researcher based down the University of Queensland, being like, because um she was looking into kind of public perceptions of climate change and the reef, like how do you start to navigate those conversations? And during COVID, obviously a lot of time online, not much to do. I started talking a bit more, and she was like, Do you want to do a PhD? And I was like, you know what? I've got nothing else to do. And I honestly kind of fell into it. It was just luck. And um the yeah, the research was how do you have those conversations? Because I have, you know, there's this narrative that the reef inspires action. I know from my experience and most people that I know it it inspired them, but I noticed there was a gap, right? If you can't have that conversation, does it inspire action for those tourists that are coming on the boat? You know, if if you can't even give them an answer. And so my whole thesis question was does the reef inspire action and how do we use that moment, the reef, as an idea, as a concept, and as an experience to engage people in what is a really complex discussion about climate change and how we move forward from here.
SPEAKER_00I was extremely curious when you started doing the research because I also wanted to know all the facts behind those questions. You surveyed hundreds of tourists on boats and also did telephone surveys with average Australians, right?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I think overall we did thousands of surveys. I did a lot of interview, like one-on-one interviews with people around the country. I interviewed a lot of marine guides, tourism operators, and then I did bother hundreds of guests on boats to see what they thought.
SPEAKER_00So your research actually conveniently enforced you to go on lots of uh boat trips to the Great Barry Reef, right? From the name of research.
SPEAKER_02Yeah, I uh because I'm not I'm a social scientist, so I don't study fish, I study people. So I was actually really lucky, like get a few tourism operators that were really willing and really accepting of the work that did let me go out there.
SPEAKER_00From talking to average Australians, how important and valuable is the reef to people that you're changing?
SPEAKER_02The reef is something that you just can't even explain, right? So there's a long-term social monitoring program done by CSIRO that manages Australians' perceptions towards the reef. So this is before I started, but there's studies that show that Australians who have never even been to the reef, never even been, say it's part of who they are. Because of the idea it is, how it's connected to the Australian identity, like it's the great barrier reef. Like it has this value that we can't even describe yet. And then you put on top of that people who actually have been, and then on top of that people that live and work and play on it. Like it has this like immense social and cultural value. And then if you think about that cultural and ecological history of the reef and the First Nations connections with the reef, like connections with the reef are uh huge and vast and extremely valuable, and I don't think you could even begin to explain them in a short answer. Um, but like across all of Australia, like the reef means something to people, even if sometimes it does feel out of sight, out of mind in the busyness of day-to-day life. Like it's it's there and there's an opportunity.
SPEAKER_00So, what feedback did you get from tourists visiting the reef when you went on boats and as you call it, you bothered them about their experiences and also their expectations versus reality of the tourists visiting the reef?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, well, like I thought I was gonna be bothering them. I was so scared, I was like, oh no. And I was so scared to do it, but I was actually like, no, I was pleasantly super surprised, like nothing but positive responses. People who didn't really want to have the conversation were just like, oh, I don't really know, like, I'm just gonna go keep playing in the sun. And you're like, great, that's fine. I'm not gonna force you. But the majority of people were like, yeah, let's have a chat. Purely because, like, usually on these boats is maybe one marine biologist, and they don't always all get a chance to talk to them. So people have questions they want answered, and people were surprisingly open. And the top three questions that I got were one, what can I do? Number two, well, what does that mean for the site that we visited today? Like, I don't care about the Great Barrier Reef, it's huge, but what about my experience? They want to be able to connect it to Wally the Maori Rass, to the turtle that they've seen, to the specific site that they've just that's now part of their life experience. And then the third one was, or what did it look like before? Like what's before, where are we now, and what's the possible futures? Was kind of the three main questions people were asking. But people were overwhelmingly positive. And so we what we did was a bit of an experiment. So I was very extremely grateful for the tourism operators that that worked with me. So we did an experiment where some trips we talked about climate change, so we worked with the marine biologists who made sure climate was part of their presentation, posters on boats, videos, and the other trips, none of it. Or I would do the surve, I would survey before the presentation or so climate wasn't actively in the experience. To compare, because they're I guess I I wanted to know, does having that information make more people more likely to take action? But I guess something that tourism operators want to know is does it ruin anyone's day? Because at the end of the day, they're a business. Yes. And they need they need to be attracting, making people come, tell their friends to come, and then come back because that's how that's their livelihood, right? So they want us to know, well, is it going to negatively affect us because it it feels like it might? And I was like, which is a very valid concern. So we also tested that. And we actually found that it's surprised, it does not ruin anyone's day. You know, 80% of people said they actually wanted more information, and the ones that didn't, they just don't engage. You know, they just ignore you and go about their thing. Like it's not going to put anyone down. We actually found that people that did get that information said the reef exceeded their expectations. And I think it's because, like we said before, people have no idea what to expect. So having that information, that guide, that that curated experience, and I'm sure you get this probably at the aquarium, like having th that kind of framework to help people with their experience changes their perceptions of of what is normal, what is healthy, what they've just seen, where it's going.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, education's definitely the key, isn't it? You know, we get such a vast ray of people every week, from little kids to 80-year-olds. And when I first started there and we started doing the education shows, there we could see this pattern where people didn't really want to be spoken to about climate change and they didn't really know how to talk about it, or they didn't understand it. But now you do a show and you've still got a hundred people sitting there waiting for your chat at the end, and then people come up to you and they say, I want to know.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Please teach me, or they'll come up to me and say, Thank you so much for just giving us the real story.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Do you know what I mean? We have this perception that people that it's drummed into us all the time that people don't want to know about that stuff. That's not true.
SPEAKER_02Not at all.
SPEAKER_01It's just not.
SPEAKER_02And like of what you just said, people are so disillusioned with media, with politics.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02They also scientists aren't known for being the best communicators, you know. For example, like that Ames report that came out a few years ago is like reef coral cover is the best ever, and then you've got the news that says it's dead.
SPEAKER_04Yeah.
SPEAKER_02And then the average Australian goes, Well, what's actually going on? So something else we found that study was a huge level of trust in in guides and and crew and tourism operators to be like, Well, tell me what's actually happening. What's happening on your site? What have you seen? Because at the end of the day, people relate to people and personal experiences. Yeah. And so that was another huge thing. So that's like another like speaks the potential of the industry in activating millions of people.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Yeah. The figures dipped a bit during COVID and they're starting to recover. But normally, pre COVID, uh around two million people visit the Great Barrier Reef every year. That's not all divers, but it Could be people going to an island and all of them have the opportunity to learn something that could inspire them to take action, whether they go back to their home country where it could be a landlocked country where it snows all the time and is nowhere near a coral reef, but they can still take actions to reduce their carbon footprint or their impact. They can change their civic actions wherever people go in the world. So the power of the tourism industry to change people's lives is I feel like there's nothing else like it, because the people I talk to on the boats, the tourists say, like, I don't really trust the media because different media outlets say different things depending what their agenda is. Even though science is the best source of information, some people don't really trust it. So they're most likely to trust the things that they see with their own eyes when they go snorkeling on the reef, because that's their personal experience. But if they don't have a good guide to explain what they're seeing with their own eyes, most tourists wouldn't have the baseline knowledge to understand what they're seeing when they snorkle. So I know I went snorkeling in Thailand on a reef, which I could tell was completely decimated. There was like two corals in a hundred square meters, but there was fish everywhere. So all these tourists, it was their first time snorkeling, they were like just mind-blown. They're like, wow, this is amazing. I saw a parrot fish. So for them, the baseline, the bar is extremely low for them to have an amazing holiday, which is good, and one of the reasons why snorkeling is always going to be an amazing tourist experience, and everyone should continue to do it regardless of the changes. But on the other hand, you have people who have watched Finding Nemo and think that all corals should be bright rainbow colours. And so they'll dive on a perfectly healthy coral area, but they'll see some corals which are naturally brown, and they'll be like, Oh, I'm disappointed. I thought all the corals were going to be bright pink and purple. So as a tourist, they really don't understand how to interpret what they're seeing necessarily unless they have good interpretation from their guides.
SPEAKER_01Do you know one of the real positives also is that it in in one of the shows that we do at the aquarium, the the deep brief show, that's the opportunity where we get to explain to them what coral is. And I always start off the little chat, I look at it, a hundred people, and you and they're all looking at you, engaged in what you're about to say, and you say to them, What I want to do now is I want to spend two minutes teaching you what coral is, what it is, and once you understand what it is, you understand how it's being affected. And I say to them, Is that okay? I'm gonna say it anyway. But and they just look up at you and go, Yes, yes, please. And they're from little ones to old ones, and after two minutes they just look at you and go, that's incredible. I I had no idea, but now I understand what is causing that problem. You can't understand how coral bleach works if you don't understand what a coral is.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Which people want to know.
SPEAKER_00Which is uh whole subject in itself, coral biology. And I did talk about it on the podcast back in season one, episode two. So for all those out there who want to dive back into what coral is and what it means when it bleaches, just look for word on the reef on your favourite podcast app like Spotify or Apple Podcasts. For those who have just joined the show, our guest today is Marine Social Scientist and CEO of Divers for Climate, Dr. Yolanda Waters. And we've been talking about um the tourism industry and how important it can be in changing people's lives and inspiring them to take action to help protect the reef, particularly on the biggest threat to the reef, which is climate change. We've just discussed how important and valuable the tourism experience can be for inspiring action. But some tourists have a bit of concern about whether tourists visiting might actually be a threat or add to the pressure on the reef. Yolanda, do you have any thoughts about that?
SPEAKER_02Yeah, there's definitely a misconception within the Australian public, like of the disproportionate impact that tourism itself has. And then you know, some of the surveys that I've done, people do put it up there in some of the top threats, which we know from the Marine Park Authority and all those outlook reports, it's a very, very minimal threat. What is the number? Tourism is concentrated in like less than 1% or so. If something even less, something tiny to the reef. Yeah. And like I will say, like, tourism on the Great Barrier here in Australia is done exceptionally well compared to many other tropical coral reef tourism areas in the world. And I think a lot of the stuff we do so well, but it's because you know, psychologically, the way people think about environmental impacts is it's much easier for them to connect what they can see physically on in the environment. So if you see 300 snorkelers out in the reef, if you see boats going out, you go, well, that can't be good. Whereas thinking of something bigger like climate change, unless you're under there watching bleaching, even then, it's really hard to connect the dots. Whereas tourism, people connect those dots mentally much easier. So they go, Oh, well, 100 people out there, that can't be good for the environment. And so it's just like a psychological shortcut that people make. And so it's actually not true at all. It's obviously not got no impact, right? But tourism d does its best to have as minimal impact as it can. And that's kind of one of the concerns of the industry in speaking out about something like climate change. They are concerned that people will come back and call them hypocrites, right? And say, oh well, you're going out in the reef, you know, maybe ever think maybe you're the problem. And it's quite a difficult conversation to have. Yeah. I don't know what you've heard.
SPEAKER_01And I guess you can balance that with education as well. So you you touched at the start, we have uh an issue of out of sight, out of mind. Yeah. Right. And we often get questions that from certain customers, it'll come through and we'll we'll chat to anyone about anything. And and they'll say to you at the end, they'll go, Look, I really love this journey, but do we really need facilities like this? Do we really do we really need to be taking boats out to the reef? Do we need to be having aquariums? And my answer to that is, well, 70% of the most important ecosystem on our planet is hidden. If we don't bring it to you and we don't bring it up, we don't educate you on it, then you can't change the way you feel about it. And I think that the education that people can get from that, the experience they can get from that. And if we only change 60% of people's opinions over a year that go out there or or come into us and get the answers, or vice versa, yeah. We we need that. We need the people to go out there, jump off the boat, meet Wally, look at the coral, get taught about it, and then leave going. That was one of the most incredible experiences of my life. Because if we don't do that, how are they gonna know?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. I mean, all three of us in this room right now, and pretty much every other marine conservationist that I've connected with started their journey with a simple visit to the reef as a tourist. That was me, and probably you guys as well. So those who are advocating to protect the reef the most, it's because they've had uh connection with it. And like you said, Australia is doing particularly well. I've been talking with my friend Max from the Caribbean, and he was describing some areas of the world where there's overfishing and overhandling of the marine life in much higher numbers than what we have on the Great Barrier Reef, whereas it's quite well managed here, and less than 7% of the Great Barrier Reef is open to tourism vessels, but it like Yulander said, it works out to be less than 1% when you actually look at which parts of those reefs people are actually snorkeling on. And for me, having worked on the reef, I've seen that because we are so protective and so passionate about protecting our sites as dive guides, we're teaching the tourists we will not let them touch the coral, we will not let them set foot on it. If you visit the reef, you'll hear if anyone does step on the coral, you'll hear the staff going absolutely ballistic, blowing the whistle and shouting, get off the coral.
SPEAKER_01You're spending the day on the boat now.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, you've had your water rights revoked. But yeah, it can be very upsetting. Like you said, if you see a tourist kicking a coral, that can be very upsetting. But in the grand scheme of things, the impact of coral bleaching, which, for example, last year it was the worst coral bleaching on record on the Great Barrier Reef, 75% of the reef was bleached, which is obviously much bigger than the area visited by tourists, so it's definitely the biggest threat. So how comfortable are you know, you talk to a lot of tourism staff, Yolanda. How comfortable are they? How equipped are they feeling to educate tourists about the climate impacts on the reef, and how equipped are they feeling to teach people what actions they can take?
SPEAKER_02Yeah. Well, as I can't speak for them, but I can speak to some of the stories that were shared with me. I will just start by saying guides and interpreters on the reef and instructors and like extensor aquarium staff, like are some of the best educators I've ever met. Just like even We all deserve a pay rise, right?
SPEAKER_00Like I I'm not doing it currently, but but all my friends out there, they are doing an amazing job. Yes, pay rise.
SPEAKER_02But like like even just knowing when to read a room, like in in interviewing a lot of guides, they were like, I was like, you know, how do you feel talking about climate change? That all depends on the boat on the day. I can read a room and know if people are keen, if people are not, if it's the right day for it. It could be a horrible, super windy, rainy day, but the if the crowd is right, it might be perfect. Or the opposite, like know how to read their audience, and that's like comms 101, like know your audience. Yep. And then know how you sit as a messenger, and they know they're kind of trusted, they know they know their site, and then what do you say? And so I think guides are just because you have to be, like, you get confront confronted with a hundred strangers a day, you become a very good communicator, and you have to give good customer service at the same time, make sure they don't drown, like you just become the ultimate communicator about what is going on out on the reef. And there's a lot that do feel confident now, and more and more so with programs like the Master Reef Guides, and there's a range of kind of education programs to help guides kind of give more information about ecology, about biology, about some of the threats that are happening, particularly local threats. But then I guess when it comes to climate change, that's just a whole nother bucket, right? Climate change is complex to talk about for anyone, even if you are in the climate space, because the solutions are not clear. And I think if the solution is not clear means how do you get into a conversation about the problem, right? Like plastic, I mean solutions also not clear, but clearer, right? You see plastic on the reef, we pick it up, we do a lot of dives against debris, you clean it up. Um, if it's restoration, you know, you're you can see things that are happening. Whereas climate change, it's so hard to get into. And I think because it's become super politicized, people are scared, like, oh, I don't want to get into a political debate. Like, I'm at work, everyone's on a holiday, like, no thanks.
SPEAKER_03Yeah.
SPEAKER_02They think they have to be an expert. Like, I can't have a conversation about climate change. I don't know all the stats and the facts. I'm not a climate scientist, which is ridiculous, because if you shouldn't have to be a climate scientist to talk about something you care about, right?
SPEAKER_04Yeah, that's right.
SPEAKER_02Um, and then just general kind of just not feeling confident to get into the nitty-gritty. And there are some guides that do it, and I've watched some guides actually get right into like the IPC, like the projections of what a warming planet looks like, which is fantastic, but not everyone feels like they're able to do that because they're not sure what the response will be like from the public. And so a lot of kind of the feedback that I got was that well, I can address the threat, you know, climate change is the greatest threat. Every pretty much guide does that. Um and what they prefer to do is then guide it to local solutions and how we build local resilience and like to tell people of the work we're doing here in the region, like talk about the Crown of Thorns, talk about the coral nurture program, or the restoration work that's going on, talk about the monitoring we're doing, the citizen science, or the you know, some of the programs that tourism operators now engage in with the Marine Park Authority. Like they bring it back down to local, um, which is really great, and I think it's really good. I think there is this little gap there where how do you bring that back to what people can take home for climate change and bring it back to that global discussion?
SPEAKER_01Something that's going to relate to them when they leave. Yeah, it's like we've also got to focus on some of the positives that we're doing as well, and that takes a lot of that overwhelming feeling away from people. And you see people start to calm when you talk to them and say, look, if you're going out to the reef, you use Reef Safe Sunscreen, don't touch the animals. And if you're snorkeling, you're three feet longer than you've ever been in your life, so please don't snorkle near the coal, you're gonna kick it. And then while you're in cans, don't buy a single-use plastic water bottle. Get a reusable one. Try and limit the amount of plastic you do, and when you leave cans, you have a big smile on your face, you've helped the environment, you've had a great holiday. And people start to feel a bit more calmer because they get that overwhelming feeling that we've gone too far, we can't fix it. That's not true.
SPEAKER_02Well, yeah, and I definitely think this is the tricky bit, right? Like, yes, I a lot of guides and and people that work out and they do feel comfortable giving calls to action like that, like kind of smaller, small little steps, lifestyle things, things you can do at home. But what we actually found was that a lot of people generally know those are good things to do for sustainability when they either do or don't do them, but a lot of people also don't believe that those things have an impact. And so that's kind of those three things that are missing in a lot of communication, not just about the reef, but about climate change generally, is not just what can I do, but how can I do it and how will that actually make a difference? And a lot of them can't make that last step. Like they've been told to recycle a million times, like I've been recycling my whole life, climate's still warming up. Yeah, what else do I do now? And so they they're waiting for that next thing, and then what that next thing is is really hard because it depends on the context that you're in. Like, obviously, next thing would be great if everyone could be activated to go speak to their leaders, right? But that's not an appropriate call to action if you're on a tourist boat out on the reef. So, what what's that next step you can give people to take back and think about bigger, changing the system, changing the policies that that kind of guide what we're doing to the climate at the moment?
SPEAKER_00Our guest today is Marine Social Scientist and CEO of Divers for Climate, Dr. Yolanda Waters. And we've been talking a lot about the role of tourism on the Great Barrier Reef in inspiring people to take action to protect it, especially on climate impacts. And we've discussed how a lot of people are already doing, you know, recycling and are quite aware of lifestyle actions they can take at home, whether they do them or not. Most people are aware of those things. But Yolanda, what does individual action look like when it comes to climate change? I mean, it's a global issue, it's caused by carbon dioxide gases in the atmosphere from burning fossil fuels. What can I, as an individual, actually do about that? This is my favorite question.
SPEAKER_02Well, because I think the way individual action on climate change has been framed until now is just things you can do. You must reduce your energies, you must switch to this, you must stop eating meat, you must you must, must, must, you must do this. Which is not very empowering. It just feels like a lot of a lot of weight and responsibility gets pushed on the individual for a problem that we know has been caused by a lot of factors beyond us. Of course, we're not blameless, we're part of the system, but it's very uncomfortable to have all that put on you as an individual person, because there's only so much you can do, right? And especially now with the cost of living, like people are just trying to get through the day as it is. So to have that individual frame can be really tricky. And so, what a lot of the climate space and the climate movement talks about is like, no, it's not about the individual, it's about the system, right? How we change the social and political and cultural system that we live in, how do we shift politics, how do we shift media narratives, how do we shift that needle so that when we talk about things like accelerating the transition to renewable energy, it's not so scary. Like it is just part of what we do. And so they talk about systems change and advocating for systems change, which is great and is what's needed. But then what that does is make the individual, just you or me, feel kind of like, oh well, I'll do my thing, the system does its thing over there. And something that we found in the research, interviewing people, we did a bit of like a what we call a mental model exercise, a bit of a post-it mind map exercise to see how people see the Great Barrier Reef, the threats, the solutions, and where they see themselves and the actions they can take, and they saw it as completely separate. They don't people don't see themselves as active agents of change. They don't see themselves in changing the system. And so then you get this narrative that's like individual or systems, which is really frustrating because systems aren't abstract. Systems are made of individuals, right? They're made of people like you or I, they're made of people who who make decisions, who take actions. Politicians, they're individuals, CEOs of huge companies, individuals. Every person that works in a climate space got there because they were passionate and they decided to do something as an individual. And obviously, you know, there's certain levels of privilege that, you know, that help decide whether you can do something like volunteer or not. But so I'm on this mission to reframe when people say individual action, what does that mean? And yes, it can mean things you do at home. Like there's like some really impactful things you can do to decarbonize your home and your lifestyle personally, and if that's something you'd keen on doing, amazing. But individual action also means things like social action. How do you engage in groups? How do you talk to other people? So educators, right? How do you those those hundreds and thousands of conversations you have every day? That's you as an individual.
SPEAKER_00Start one individual can can reach how many people have visited the Cairns Aquarium and heard your talk?
SPEAKER_01Just over 2.3 million since we both have.
SPEAKER_02One of the number one reasons people don't talk about climate change is because they think the person next to them doesn't want to talk about it either, or doesn't want to hear about it, or is not interested, which is just not true. Like maybe they're busy, sure, but it's not like um we haven't quite normalized the conversation yet. So those social things that you can do, whether you share things on social media, if you host events, if you run a podcast. Run a podcast. Or a radio show. That is a climate action, like social actions, and then you've got organizational actions, things you can shift in your workplace, right? Are there any workplace policies that you could be, oh this could be done better, as small as it might be? And then you've got what we call civic actions, you know, we have a federal election coming up, but like how we engage, not just now, but beyond the election, right? How do you engage with decision makers? Like we're lucky enough that we live in a democratic country. And so people often don't realise that we're allowed to engage in that. And it doesn't have to be scary, you don't have to be an activist or a lobbyist.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, anyone can actually meet with their local member of parliament. And if they got voted in for a reason, they're probably a really friendly, approachable person. That's kind of their job.
SPEAKER_02Honestly, most of them are, and they're really happy to sit down and have a chat. They're just people too, right? And I think even if not going that far to talk to representatives, just being able to write letters, write op-eds in in papers, like individual action can be so many things. And I think people have this idea that, oh, if if I'm gonna be engaged in climate action, I have to do everything, I have to be perfect, have to do all the things. Um but in reality, if everyone just did a few that they that that really fit in their lifestyle, in their needs, in their context. Because not everyone can volunteer, for example. They've got full-time jobs, they've got kids, they've got things. But maybe in that way they can there's something for them, there's something for everyone. I think expanding that idea of what individual action looks like for people, I think that is kind of where we need to be going. Because there's enough people are concerned and aware at the moment. They're just not sure what to do.
SPEAKER_00Yep. We know that more than 80% of Australians, according to surveys, care about climate change and want to see more action on it and would like to see the government taking more action on it, but they're just not quite sure what to do. And that's what Yolanda's helping us to understand is how powerful actions can be. And I think everyone understands like, you know, recycling one piece of plastic or picking up one piece of plastic off the beach isn't going to save the ocean. But if there are thousands of people picking up thousands of pieces of plastic off the beach, it will, and that's what motivates people. But people need to understand that extends to your vote or signing a petition. You know, you might think like, oh, it's just one vote, it's not going to change things. But there's if you join a group full of thousands of people who are doing those same things, then that's how pretty much every environmental or social progress has happened throughout history to where we are today. I'm very aware that we have very little time left. Do that out. We could we could definitely talk a lot longer on these topics, so we'll definitely have to get your lambda back at some point.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely.
SPEAKER_00And we didn't even go very deep yet into your organization, Divers for Climate, but we can get an update on that. Yes. Follow Divers for Climate on social media. Do you want to, you know, explain to people in in uh speed dating speed dating style.
SPEAKER_02Oh it's it's a little it's a combination of everything we've been talking about, right? We know there's a dive community that's keen and engaged to activate on climate action. They're just not sure what to do. And so Divers for Climate was trying to be that pathway, right? We're trying to connect divers and then the dive industry with decision makers and kind of make sure our concerns and needs are reflected in climate policy and solutions. So we're kind of a bridge and a platform to have those conversations. Follow us and you'll find out more.
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, everyone, follow Divers for Climate. Thanks for joining us on Word on the Reef, Yolanda Waters. It's been amazing to have you here.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's just been brilliant.
SPEAKER_00Can't believe how quick an hour.
SPEAKER_01I know, I told you, didn't I? Once we start talking, time evaporates.
SPEAKER_00Yes, it's an abstract concept time here on Word on the Reef underwater, the time just goes differently.
SPEAKER_01And and uh before you wrap that up, happy birthday for tomorrow.
SPEAKER_00Happy birthday. Everyone text on your happy birthday. Yeah, absolutely.
SPEAKER_01And uh enjoy your dive tomorrow, buddy.
SPEAKER_00Thank you, and everyone don't forget if you came in late and you want to listen back on this or any of our other episodes, you can do so. Just look for Word on the Reef on your favourite podcast at Lex Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, and wherever. See you next time. See you guys.