Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S1 E11: Breaking: Global Coral Bleaching Event with Dr Derek Manzello
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
It's official - we are in the midst of the world’s worst coral bleaching event on record, affecting two thirds of corals globally, spanning some 64 countries and territories. We've already explored some of the impacts on the Great Barrier Reef - this week we'll head overseas to find out about the impacts in other countries.
To see the map discussed in this episode: https://www.noaa.gov/news-release/noaa-confirms-4th-global-coral-bleaching-event
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Hello and welcome to Word on the Reef, a podcast where we take the plunge into one of the world's most spectacular natural wonders, the Great Barrier Reef. Before we start, I'd just like to acknowledge the Indigenous people across the globe who are at the front line of climate impacts. I'd like to acknowledge that the coral bleaching we are seeing all over the world not only has an environmental impact, but also a very real human impact. People who have contributed very little carbon pollution to the planet are being impacted the most severely by changing seasons and declining food sources. I'd also like to acknowledge the Gimoy Walubara Yidinji and Irukanji people on whose land I live and work and pay my respects to their elders, past, present, and emerging. Over the last couple of episodes, we've been on a journey through some amazing parts of the reef's history. But it's time to come back to the present. And I'm afraid the recent news about the world's coral reefs isn't great. On April 15th, the US government's National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, or NOAA, officially declared that we are in the midst of the world's most widespread global coral bleaching event on record, with coral bleaching affecting more than two-thirds of corals on the planet, spanning at least 64 countries and territories. This marks the fourth global coral bleaching event on record, the second in less than a decade. Back in episode 2, we learned what coral bleaching is and what causes it. So if you haven't already, I highly recommend you go back and listen to that episode first, in order to understand better today's episode. But to sum up, climate change, caused by the mining and burning of fossil fuels like coal, oil, and gas, is heating up our planet and our oceans, causing corals to become sick and turn white, in a phenomenon known as coral bleaching. Prolonged coral bleaching can lead to mortality, which means death. Noah's coral reef watch scientists can predict how much coral bleaching is occurring anywhere on the planet at any given time with a high degree of accuracy by using satellite data to measure sea surface temperatures. They then gather in-water reports from around the globe to confirm their predictions. The temperature at which corals start to bleach varies across species and also across the globe. Sea surface temperatures on the Great Barrier Reef usually reach up to 29 degrees Celsius in summer, so bleaching can start at temperatures of 30 to 31 degrees. But down in Tasmania, sea surface temperatures normally only reach about 17 degrees at the height of summer. And so damage can occur at just 18 or 19 degrees Celsius because the species in that area just aren't adapted for those temperatures. So unfortunately, there really aren't many places that are safe from rising sea temperatures. The level of bleaching also depends on the length of time corals are exposed to those above average temperatures. So for example, if coral is exposed to temperatures one degree above average for one week, it might be fine. But after four weeks at that temperature, most corals will start to bleach. And if temperatures are two degrees above average, bleaching will happen twice as fast, i.e. within just two weeks. Multiplying the temperature elevation by the number of weeks it stays elevated for gives scientists a measurement called degree heating weeks. And the higher that number is, the more severe the bleaching. Some areas of the Great Barrier Reef this year experienced more than 15 degree heating weeks, resulting in 73% of the reef bleaching. To understand more about this global bleaching event and what it means, today we are chatting with Dr. Derek Manzello, coordinator of NOAA's Coral Reef Watch Program. Good morning, Derek. How are you?
SPEAKER_01I'm doing great, Tanya.
SPEAKER_00Thank you very much for having me. It's great to have you on the show, but unfortunately, the news is quite alarming. I understand we are experiencing a global mass coral bleaching event.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right. So since you know February of 2023, we now have confirmed mass bleaching taking place in at least 64 countries and territories. So this includes both the northern and southern hemispheres of all the major ocean basins. So the Indian, Pacific, and Atlantic Oceans.
SPEAKER_00So NOAA has published a map of the maximum bleaching alert levels reached globally over the past year. I'll put a link to it in the episode description so listeners can check it out. But basically, there are colors ranging from yellow through to red and then purple, indicating the levels of heat stress in each area of the ocean. And for those who can't see it, I'm not gonna lie, it pretty much looks like the entire ocean is on fire. The levels of heat stress are off the charts, quite literally. I understand you had to add in three more categories this year to accommodate new unprecedented levels of heat stress. Is that true?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right. So up until last year, Coral Reefwash only had two bleaching alert area levels. And these were bleaching alert level one and bleaching alert level two. So a bleaching alert level one is when we expect, you know, the risk of mass bleaching to really begin. Uh and then when you hit a bleaching alert level two, that's when we expect, you know, severe bleaching to really begin and uh mortality to start, especially in the most heat-sensitive species and coral genotypes. Now, last year in the wider Caribbean, by the time we got to about the end of October, the entirety of the Northwest Atlantic Ocean and the Caribbean was just one big blanket of dark red, you know, showing alert level two conditions. And we made the decision to add in three additional alert levels. And we had to do that just because it had gotten so hot and these heat stress events have gotten so extreme that we really need to add in this further, you know, level of detail and granularities.
SPEAKER_00I heard that the temperatures in the Caribbean were so hot that rather than going through those gradual stages of bleaching and then dying, corals were just going from healthy to dead within a really short space of time.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right. We saw a very, very extreme unprecedented heat stress event where sea surface temperatures were upwards of two to three degrees Celsius above that maximum monthly mean sea surface temperature. And and that, you know, heat stress was so severe that we actually saw acute heat shock happening in a lot of different corals and organisms. So in the Caribbean, the two corals that have been most responsible, you know, over the last half million years for reef building in the Caribbean are these things called staghorn and elk horn corals. And some of these elkorn corals in Florida last year uh experienced such rapid thermal stress that they just started sloughing off their tissue. So they basically died before they had a chance to bleach.
SPEAKER_00The blue color are areas with no stress over the past year, and it is a alarmingly tiny area. There's almost no ocean on the entire planet which had no stress experienced, which is really alarming to see. And the darker reds and purple colors, which indicate high alert levels for bleaching, are just all over the place, including off the east coast of Australia, near New Zealand, really dark purple in the Caribbean. And I think like around the Galapagos Islands areas, there's like a really dark purple area.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, that's right. So the eastern tropical Pacific also saw some record-setting heat stress, in particular, you know, around the Galapagos and Panama, but the Mexican Pacific really saw some severe impacts. And actually, the first publication documenting impacts from this event actually comes from the Mexican Pacific. So around Oaxaca, which is in southern Mexico, and they documented uh mortality on their reefs ranged from anywhere from 50 to 93 percent of the corals on their reefs, unfortunately, died last year from this bleaching event.
SPEAKER_00It's really, you know, shocking that you had to add in three extra alert levels because of the the heat levels in the ocean we're seeing and just off the charts, literally. Literally, they were off the charts that you previously had. So you had to add in new levels. Absolutely incredible. What are the impacts like in some of the other parts of the world over the past year and currently?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so you know, we we have heard about some very, very severe, devastating impacts in certain locations. So of all the reef areas in the Atlantic Ocean, 99.9% of those have experienced bleaching level heat stress. So there's really no reef in the Atlantic Ocean that hasn't been hit with heat stress in the last year. Um, and you know, we've heard reports of anywhere from 90 to 100% mortality in certain locations for the elk horn and the staghorn corals in particular. So the impacts in the Caribbean have been severe, unfortunately. And basically the same thing's playing out in the southern Atlantic on the reefs in Brazil. They are going through their worst bleaching event on record right now. And they're seeing impacts already that are way more severe than anything they've seen before. In terms of the rest of the world, you know, we do know there was some severe bleaching in Fiji. I'm I'm not really sure if it was record setting, but definitely severe. As well as Vanuatu and, you know, New Caledonia. Uh, we did receive a report of bleaching in French Polynesia, in particular Fakaraba, Atoll. And uh, you know, the Great Barrier Reef, a higher percentage of the Great Barrier Reef experienced, you know, bleaching level heat stress than ever before. Um, still going to be some time before those impacts are truly documented. And then in the Indian Ocean, there was very, very severe bleaching in the Persian Gulf last year, as well as in the Red Sea, which is interesting because the Red Sea is a location that has been suggested that, you know, it might be a climate refugia. Well, based on what happened last year, I think that hypothesis has now been quite challenged because there were some pretty severe impacts on the Red Sea. And right now, the Southeast Asia is just on fire, you know, as we talk. Like Thailand is just super, super hot, Malaysia, all those areas. Uh, also the South China Sea is heating up, as well as the Philippines are heating up right now as we speak. So this event is nowhere near over. It's it's essentially just getting worse now, unfortunately. And you know, we we discovered about two weeks ago that Play Island in Phuket in Thailand, they actually closed it off to tourists who are so severely bleached. So, you know, unfortunately the news is just bad almost everywhere that we're hearing. But it it is going to be some time before the hard data is really kind of collected and this event is truly documented in the scientific literature. But, you know, as of right now, the Atlantic Ocean, by far, this is way in excess of anything that's ever happened before. And then, you know, also in certain locations in the Pacific, in particular, the Southern Great Barrier Reef, as well as, you know, the Samoas, so Western Samoa and American Samoa has gotten hit pretty bad. And uh yeah, you know, like I said, this event is only growing, unfortunately. So it's not done yet.
SPEAKER_00So how many global bleaching events have there been? What other years did they take place? And how does this global bleaching event compare to the last few?
SPEAKER_01Uh so this is the fourth global bleaching event on record, which is kind of crazy to think about. So the the first large-scale coral bleaching event due to higher than average or extreme ocean temperatures occurred in in 1982 and 1983 in the eastern tropical Pacific. So this wasn't a global event, but what makes this event very unique is that this was the first time on record where there was a very large-scale coral bleaching and mortality event. So coral bleaching as a stress response has been well known for basically 100 years at this point. You know, scientists have known that if you stress a coral with low salinity water or sediment or high light conditions, it'll basically bleach and expel its algal symbionts. But, you know, prior to the 1980s, all the bleaching events that happened were extremely localized. You know, a classic example is in Discovery Bay in Jamaica in the early 1960s. There was a severe hurricane. It dumped a ton of rainwater, you know, it funneled out into the bay and caused the entire reef to bleach because of the low salinity. But in that event, you know, that reef completely recovered. So that just shows you that corals are pretty well adapted to recovering from normal kind of stressors they they experience every day. So the first global coral bleaching event on record occurred in 1998. And during that event, the peak kind of percentage of reef area that was impacted was about 20% of the world's reefs experienced bleaching level heat stress. So the second global event happened in 2010. And during that event, about 35% of the world's coral reefs experienced bleaching level heat stress. The third event took place over three years from 2014 to 2017. And during that event, the percentage of reef area that experienced bleaching level heat stress peaked at 56.1%. And that's a rolling window over, you know, a 365-day period. So currently, during this event, as of May 23rd, we have you know broken all previous records. We're currently sitting at 63% of the world's reefs had experienced bleaching level heat stress just in the last uh 365 days. And if you look at the cumulative percentage since this event started, we're over 66% now. So that means essentially two-thirds of the world's coral reefs had experienced heat stress in the last year at levels enough to elicit mass coral bleaching.
SPEAKER_00Wow, like there's no sugarcoating it. That is very concerning. I mean, yeah, you've obviously explained that it's gotten worse every time. And now this is the fourth time it's happened. In the northern hemisphere, now summer is going to start again soon. So is there a risk or a worry that this year of bleaching is just going to roll straight into another year of bleaching? What are the predictions for the upcoming months?
SPEAKER_01Well, unfortunately, things are not looking good. And the reason I say that is because we just hit uh the bleaching threshold in Florida two days ago, and that happened a good three to four weeks earlier than it happened last year. And so last year in Florida, the bleaching and the heat stress basically started in early July, and that was a full four to six weeks earlier than has ever happened before. So, you know, I've been fortunate enough to be in a position to monitor reefs in Florida and bleaching now for over 20 years. And in the past, when I was in Florida and doing all this research, I wouldn't even think about bleaching until August rolled around, right? Beginning of August, it would be kind of the dog days of summer. And I would be like, all right, let me let me pull up the temperature data to see if we're at risk of a bleaching year. Well, we're talking about last year, a full six weeks earlier than ever before, we saw the most severe bleaching event on record. And right now, we're seeing temperatures higher than they were last year, and heat stress already accumulating in certain places. So, based on the satellite temperature data, it's likely that bleaching has already started on the Caribbean side of Panama and Costa Rica and Colombia and Nicaragua. So this basically right now, we couldn't be in a worst case situation. And the reason I say that is because last year the heat stress was unprecedented in terms of how early it started, how hot it got, and how severe the impacts were. Well, right now, we're still a good three weeks away from the start of summer officially, and we're already seeing heat stress accumulate. So that, you know, if anything's keeping me up at night right now, it's that fact. Because last year was just, like you said, off freaking charts. And now this year, we're marching right towards a potentially more severe event than we saw last year. So it's very, very concerning. It's very, very alarming. Uh, and I'm I'm really concerned right now for you know the wider Caribbean and Florida, because I, you know, to be brutally honest, I can't even believe what I'm looking at when I look at these satellite sea surface temperature data. Like this is so far beyond anything I ever imagined happening, you know, within my lifetime, that it's just it's mind-boggling.
SPEAKER_00That is very alarming information to hear. But if there's any silver lining out of really serious impacts like this, it would be that it really, really jolts everyone into action. But because this coral bleaching is happening underwater and out of sight to most of the world's population, many people are probably not really grasping how serious this bleaching is and why we should care about it. So why should we be concerned as a global population about this global coral bleaching event?
SPEAKER_01Well, there's a lot of reasons, you know. Um the first and foremost, coral reefs are are the rainforests of the sea. So it's been estimated that about 25% of all marine species associate with coral reefs at some point in their lives. So the estimates of how many species exist on coral reefs around the planet, that estimate ranges from anywhere between 330,000 species to over a million species that are dependent on coral reefs. So the fact that we're seeing these large-scale declines in coral reefs everywhere, we're basically losing species that we don't even haven't even been documented by science yet, which is very alarming. But you know, coral reefs, aside from that, they provide very direct ecological services to humans. It's estimated coral reefs are contributing more than $3 billion a year to the U.S. economy. And that number is in the trillions globally. So that includes obvious things like, you know, scuba tourism, which obviously is huge in the Great Barrier Reef, bringing in tons of money to the Australian economy. But it also includes things like coastal protection from storms. You know, a lot of people don't realize that coral reefs are a natural living breakwater and they can attenuate about 97% of the wave energy from, say, a cyclone or hurricane, as we call them on this side of the planet, during a storm event. So as corals die and those reefs become degraded and they start eroding, you know, basically the reef structure itself is doing a less and less job of stopping all that wave energy. So that's going to translate to more damage to, you know, people living in coastal environments, you know, insurance rates are already skyrocketing in places like Florida. So, you know, directly things like that. And then some other direct impacts, you know, are people around the world depend on coral reefs as a major protein source, right? So as you start losing that 3D structure and that architectural complexity, coral reefs are going to be less productive in terms of fisheries, biomass. And then finally, you know, a lot of people don't realize that coral reefs are a source of a lot of new, uh newly developed pharmaceuticals and drugs. So, you know, some of the new experimental cancer drugs that have been developed have been developed from compounds that are only found on coral reefs. So even though this decline is out of sight, out of mind, and you know, some people might say, well, you know, it's it's just an aesthetic issue. You're just sad because you're, you know, you're losing all your colorful corals. Well, it really goes way beyond that and has serious ramifications for the entire human race. You know, we might, for all we know, the cure for cancer could be on coral reefs, and you know, that reef could be bleaching and dying right now, for all we know.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, exactly. And I mean, it's also they call it the canary in the coal mine. It's giving us a warning for other impacts which are going to flow on. If we can't save the coral reefs of the world, then what's next? The rainforests and, you know, ultimately ourselves depend on uh having the right temperatures to be able to survive. So it is concerning for everyone, and it is uh a warning for everyone to pay attention to when we're having two-thirds of the entire planet's corals bleached. So what needs to be done to save coral reefs?
SPEAKER_01Well, you know, there's a lot of kind of short-term efforts that people have been doing now for geez, 20 years in an attempt, you know, to basically buy us some time. So NOAA has invested in a lot of kind of these cutting-edge restoration techniques and this idea of assisted evolution and trying to jumpstart the adaptation potential of corals to high temperatures. So, in the simplest sense, you know, you're basically identifying certain corals that are able to withstand heat better than others, and then trying to understand, you know, more or less the genetic or physiological mechanisms underlying how they're able to do that. And, you know, in places like the Australian Institute of Marine Science, which is very close to where you are, they're really the global leaders in this assisted evolution. You know, people like Madeline Van Oppen have been culturing heat resistant algal symbionts now for like 20 years. So there is some hope there in terms of being able to kind of offset these declines, at least on a highly localized scale. Again, we need to be we need to be realist and understand that. That anything we do is going to be very, very localized in nature, right? Because the GBR is bigger than the country of Italy, so it's not feasible to restore the whole thing. So there are some means and a lot of efforts taking place to restore reefs on a local scale. And then last year, you know, when things got so bad in Florida, there was a huge effort to basically salvage a lot of the genetic diversity and basically pull corals off the reef, you know. So we've basically gotten to a point on planet Earth where we're talking about survival of species, right? So, you know, some of the kind of more bigger picture things that can be done. So improving water clarity, reducing land place sources of pollution, reducing, you know, disruptive fishing practices and making sure any fishing that takes place is sustainable, not hurting the reefs. But again, all of these things unfortunately are just an insufficient band-aid on you know, a gaping artery that is climate change impacts on coral reefs. So none of this is going away. It's only going to get worse and worse until there can be some kind of international cooperation, an agreement to, you know, break humanity's dependence on fossil fuels. And until that happens, we're just going to see this get worse and worse and worse, unfortunately.
SPEAKER_00If there are any listeners who maybe don't get to dive on coral reefs very much, like you and I do, but they want to do something to help people all over the world can do things to help, for example, with climate change, right? So what do you think people can do to help?
SPEAKER_01Well, all of us should be trying to do everything we can to reduce our carbon footprint, right? And, you know, also doing everything we can to reduce other stressors, like plastic pollution and things like that. But, you know, it's really imperative that our elected leaders really understand the significance and the seriousness of what's going on. You know, unfortunately, in the United States, our political atmosphere is just so divided that the two main political parties don't even talk anymore. So on one side of the aisle, we have acknowledgement and concern and intervention and you know aggressive actions wanting to be taken. And then unfortunately, you know, we're we're just at such an impasse in the history of humanity and and politically that it's it's a bit demoralizing at times. But, you know, I I encourage everybody to reach out to their elected leaders and let them know about what's happening because these people are representing us, at least in democracies anyway, and they need to be aware of what's going on on planet Earth. I mean, this this is a really serious thing that's happening, and it's it's terrible to witness.
SPEAKER_00Yes, absolutely. And if there if there are any elected leaders out there that end up listening to this, I hope that this information will inspire some bold decisions, you know, thinking further ahead than just the current election cycle and and to future generations and what sort of reef or ocean or planet we are currently building. So there's there's a lot of heavy information that we've learned today, but can you leave us on a message of hope? What do you focus on? What do you think we can focus on to keep ourselves going and to maintain hope?
SPEAKER_01You know, I I find myself keying in on the positive aspects that have happened. So, you know, my fear last year was that, you know, Florida was just going to be sterilized. Like I didn't think I was very, very concerned that there would not be a single thing left on those reefs. Well, you know, there there were very, very severe impacts in the Alcorn and the staghorn corals, but you know, a lot of the corals that have massive and more bolder morphologies, you know, there there was pretty marked survival in some species. And that gives me some degree of hope that all is not lost. There's still corals that somehow are able to survive that. So I find myself really focusing in on some of the positives. And in particular, if you look at the Great Barrier Reef, again, it's so gigantic in certain locations absolutely experienced record-setting heat stress, but you know, there were other locations that weren't impacted as bad. So I like to key on on the fact that it wasn't universally horrific everywhere. So that leaves me with some hope because that means there's still reef areas and enough corals out there to reproduce and ideally provide baby corals for some of the sites that got more severely impacted. So yeah, I mean, I at this point I really try to focus on the positives we're seeing and just take it one day at a time.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. And knowing that there is still hope, there are still some corals left, which can provide us a chance to see corals regrow in the future, you know, it's obviously not a reason for complacency because, you know, we need to take action to make sure that we don't have another global bleaching event and that it doesn't continue in that trajectory of just getting worse each time. So does it kind of take a toll on you? Like it's your job. I mean, all of us, we are focused on solutions and on the science and keep going forward by focusing on what we can do. But, you know, if we take a moment to think about what's happening, like, does it grind you down?
SPEAKER_01Uh well, you know, we all need to understand that all is not lost. Even though we're seeing these severe impacts and they're getting worse and worse, you know, there's still time to basically put a stop to what we're seeing. And it's really going to take all of us doing everything we can to really kind of bring this issue to the people that need to know what's happening and take action to change things.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, absolutely. There'll never be a point where we should give up because if we can cut global carbon pollution now, every fraction of a degree of warming that we stop could be a few more species of coral that we save. So 1.5 degrees, 1.6, 1.7, these are all going to be massive, massive differences in how much coral we have left. And um, yeah, every single little thing that we can do will make a difference and could be more species that we save. So there's never going to be a point where we should just give up. Right now, our corals need us to take action, not to despair. So those are some really good messages of hope there. So to wrap up, if people want to find out more, where can they head for more information about Noah and Coral Reef Watch?
SPEAKER_01So the website is coralreefwatch.noa.gov. Um, and that is updated daily. So, you know, anytime you want to go on that website and and check the heat stress and temperatures on your favorite reefs, you can, you know, pull that up right now and you'll see temperatures on the Great Barrier Reef as of yesterday. Um so this updates every day and near real time.
SPEAKER_00Derek Manzello, thanks very much for your time today.
SPEAKER_01My pleasure. Thank you for having me.
SPEAKER_00I hope you enjoyed our chat with Dr. Derek Manzello today. It's difficult news, but it's important to know about and not ignore. And remember that hope is found in taking action, not in despairing. If you'd like to take action to help protect the Great Barrier Reef, visit www.fightforourreef.org.au. If you're enjoying this podcast, please subscribe to this series and follow Word on the Reef on Instagram to get notified when it's time for our next adventure. This is a not-for-profit passion project, so if you enjoyed it, please write a review, share, and tell your friends. If you'd like to sponsor this podcast, please consider becoming a patron for as little as $5 a month over at patreon.com slash WordOnTheRef Podcast. You'll get a shout out, and the proceeds will help towards covering costs like podcast hosting, email hosting, editing software, and so on. That's all for now. Best fishes, and see you next time.