Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S1 E9: Coral or Concrete: How the Great Barrier Reef was Saved from Coral Mining
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
In the late 1960s, the Great Barrier Reef faced destruction from coral mining to supply materials for fertilizer and concrete. Few knew or cared about it, until a group of passionate volunteers stepped in to stop the devastation. In this episode, we meet Eddie Hegerl and Di Tarte, two of the original trailblazers who fought to protect the Reef. Hear their powerful story and explore the hidden history of how close we came to losing one of the world’s greatest natural wonders.
Episode Image: A young Eddie Hegerl.
References:
- Daley, Ben, and Griggs, Peter (2006) Mining the reefs and cays: coral, guano and rock phosphate extraction in the Great Barrier Reef, 1844-1940. Environment and History, 12 (4). pp. 395-433.
- Wright, J. (2014). The Coral Battleground (3rd ed.). Spinifex Press.
- Bowen, J., & Bowen, M. (2002). The Great Barrier Reef: History, Science, Heritage. Cambridge University Press.
- McCalman, I. (2015). The Reef: A Passionate History (Reprint ed.). Farrar, Straus and Giroux.
See also: www.ninneyrise.com
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Hello and welcome to Word on the Reef, a podcast where we take the plunge into one of the world's most spectacular natural wonders, the Great Barrier Reef. Today we're visiting Minnie Rise, a heritage-listed house in the rainforest overlooking Bingle Bay Beach, about two hours' drive south of Cairns near Mission Beach and Tully. As we step onto the sandy beach in front of the house, you can feel the incredible peace and unspoiled beauty of this place. Lush World Heritage Rainforest overhangs the waters of the World Heritage Listed Great Barrier Reef Marine Park, in one of the few places in the world where two World Heritage places meet. There are palm trees gently waving in the breeze and waves lapping on the mostly deserted beach. Just around the headland to the south is the forested mountain and white fringing sand of Dunk Island. And behind that, the Dara Island. Over there towards the northeast is Ellison Reef, which will be central to our story today. Although you can't see it because it's about 35 kilometers offshore. Before we continue, I'd just like to acknowledge the Jiro people as the traditional custodians of this land and pay my respects to their elders, past, present, and emerging. Today, it's almost taken for granted that the Great Barrier Reef is a World Heritage listed marine park with some of the highest levels of protection in the world. Australians pride ourselves on the pristine and protected nature of our reef, which makes it admired by people all over the world. We have multiple world-leading scientific organizations that exist purely to research and protect it, and a marine park authority to manage and enforce some of the world's strictest marine regulations. But incredibly, this wasn't always the case. In 1925, British marine scientist Stanley Gardner stated that, reef. Its existence is really a tragedy so far as the people of Queensland is concerned. It is a great nuisance to navigation, and it is also a curse because it destroys 70 or 80,000 square miles of admirable trawling ground. Thanks to this expert opinion and others like it, many people planned to get rid of this inconvenient great barrier to progress by blasting, dredging, and digging up various parts of it and carting it off to use as fertilizer and building materials, while other people planned to set up a vast network of oil rigs. Nobody, not even the main scientific organization of the day, seemed prepared to stand up to this development plan. Nobody, that is, except a small group of unlikely heroes, which included a bohemian artist, a poet, and some penniless postgraduate marine science students, who based their campaign here at Ninny Rise in Farnorth Queensland. They went up against the Queensland government and the multi-billion dollar oil and mining industries in a battle which exposed corruption and lies and was full of danger and adventure on the high seas. Two of these heroes are with us today. Eddie Higgle, who joined the campaign in 1967, and Diet Hart, who joined in 1971. Hello, Eddie and Dye, how are you?
SPEAKER_00Um, surprisingly healthy despite our age, I guess would be a way of putting it.
SPEAKER_02Before we start with Dye and Eddie's story, first we need to go back a bit further in time to understand the background of mining on the Great Barrier Reef. Many of the Great Barrier Reef's islands are internationally significant nesting sites for a huge variety of seabirds. Now, if you've ever had a bird leave a surprise for you on your car, you probably don't consider it a valuable substance. But prior to the 1940s, several coral caves on the Great Barrier Reef were mined for guano, i.e. bird poo, and rock phosphate to be used as fertilizer on crops. Intensive mining took place at Lady Elliott Island off Bunderberg, Lady Musgrave and Northwest Island off Gladstone, Holborn Island off Bowen, and Rain Island in the far northern reef, which we visited last episode. Less intensive but more sustained guino mining took place at Upolu, Oyster, and Micklemus Cays near Cairns. Today these are popular tourist destinations and nesting birds on the islands are protected. But it's estimated that all these islands suffered severe geomorphological and ecological transformations as a result of thousands of tons of deposit being removed. Coral mining also took place in at least twelve locations between 1900 and 1940, with the result that thousands of tons of coral were removed and pulverized to reduce agricultural and industrial lime. Mining methods included dredging, smashing the coral with crowbars, and breaking it up with explosives. Early coral mining was done without permits, but the Queensland government soon began to encourage the lucrative industry. In 1922, the Queensland government issued leases for the removal of coral and coral sand from Green Island and from Oyster and Apollu Kays near Cairns. These operations were reported to have been significant. One account claims that thousands of tons of material were removed from Apolu Kay, and that the island was halved in size and completely denuded of vegetation and bird life, a state from which it has not completely recovered today. The blossoming tourism industry eventually began to take issue with the mining that was deterring visitors to these beautiful islands. So, after some lobbying in 1937, the Queensland government legislated to prohibit the removal of coral from the foreshores and reefs surrounding Green Island, Low Isles, Micklemas Cay, Arlington Reef, and Oyster Cay. At Green Island, this created what was effectively the earliest marine protected area in existence. After the 1930s, cheaper and easier to obtain sources of agricultural lime were found inland in Chilago. And as the tourism industry grew and advocated more strongly for their coral patches to be left alone, coral mining was prohibited at 28 high-value tourism reefs. This is just one early example of why the tourism industry, when regulated and managed correctly, is one of the strongest allies we have in advocating for the reef and fighting for its protection against other much more destructive industries. Today, these reefs and islands have recovered, and through their protection, both the environment and the economy benefit, as thousands of tourists come to enjoy them each year. But we'll never know exactly what they were like prior to the short-sighted mining operations that happened there back in the early 1900s. By the 1960s, it seemed like the idea of coral mining on the reef had been largely forgotten. But the reef was soon to face its biggest battle yet. In 1965, Eddie Higgle and a group of fellow marine science students from the University of Queensland in Brisbane set up the Queensland Littoral Society, or QL S for short. And I don't mean literal as in literature, but littoral, spelt L-I-T-T-O-R-A-L, which comes from the Latin word litus meaning seashore, and refers to the coast or the sea. Today that organization has a slightly less confusing name, it's called the Australian Marine Conservation Society, or AMCS for short, and it's now the oldest and largest ocean protection charity in Australia. But when Eddie and his mates set it up, he was a penniless 22-year-old zoology student. He had grown up snorkeling on the reefs of Florida, and his passion for marine conservation brought him to Australia to study the Great Barrier Reef. The Littoral Society conducted research and advocated for action on a variety of marine issues, including water pollution, coastal development, mangrove clearing, sand mining, and more. But they had no idea that they were about to be thrown into the center of one of the most pivotal conservation battles in history. It all started in 1967, when Eddie was contacted out of the blue by Far North Queensland artist John Buust, who had concerning news. John Buust had moved from Melbourne to Far North Queensland to get away from the city and lived off-grid on Badara Island for 17 years before moving with his wife Alison to the mainland, where they built ninie ries out of sustainably sourced local materials. Drawing his inspiration from the reef and rainforest around him, John was the president of the Wildlife Preservation Society of Queensland, the state's first conservation organization, which he co-founded in 1962. Along with the eminent Australian poet Judith Wright and ecologist Len Webb, he dedicated the rest of his life to advocating for the protection of the wet tropics environment, which in those days was not heritage listed and was much less protected than it is now. John was the first person who noticed a suspicious public notice in the newspaper in 1967, and he wrote to you. The notice in the newspaper stated that the Queensland Department of Mines had received an application from the Cairns Cane Growers Executive to mine coral from 34 hectares of Ellison Reef as a cheap source of lime fertilizer. Ellison Reef, like much of the reef today, goes little considered by much of the population, and that application to mine it for coral could have easily slipped by unnoticed and might have been little considered by most people. So why was it so concerning for John and for you?
SPEAKER_00Seeing as limestone is juicy making cement, there was a lot of development going on all along the Queensland coast. I mean cities were getting bigger and bigger, and uh you had the potential for reef mining becoming accepted practice if it got going.
SPEAKER_02Although coral mining had occurred in the past, that was nothing compared to the demand for fertilizer and concrete that now existed. John and Eddie were concerned that if the coral mining industry got restarted again, it would be used as a precedent to justify mining and drilling along the entire length of the Great Barrier Reef. At the time, the Queensland government was led by the National Party, which was in those days called the Country Party. As the name suggests, they represented country people, and in particular, cane farmers. So it seemed a foregone conclusion that the application would be approved. The proponent of mining Ellison Reef argued that it was a dead reef. Now, John Buust may not have been a scientist, but after spending years on and around various reefs, including Ellison, he knew for a fact that it wasn't dead, and was much the same as other reefs. So John lodged an appeal against the mining application in the Innesval court. But he wasn't taken seriously because the court wanted to hear from scientists. They wanted proof that Ellison Reef wasn't dead. Disappointingly, John could not find a scientist willing to help him. One of the organizations he approached for assistance was the Great Barrier Reef Committee. At this point, the Marine Park Authority and the Australian Institute of Marine Science didn't exist yet. The only scientific authority on the reef was the committee, funded by the Queensland government, and tasked mainly with conducting geological surveys, which were conveniently helpful for assessing the mining resources of the reef. Studying the actual life that lived on the reef was considered a low priority. That's not to say there weren't any scientists concerned about the impacts, but they seem to have been of the opinion that mining and oil interests could not be stopped, and declined to get involved, apart from advocating for the mining and drilling to be done in a controlled manner. You asked the Great Barrier Reef Committee for help. Is it safe to say that they did not help?
SPEAKER_00No, they didn't.
SPEAKER_02They declined.
SPEAKER_00They declined.
SPEAKER_01Well, in fact, it was why um Eddie with QLS was invited to do the Ellison Reef survey. Was John originally reached out to the Great Barrier Reef Committee and they declined.
SPEAKER_00I didn't want to be involved. It was too controversial.
SPEAKER_01Hence the involvement of QLS in doing the Ellison Reef survey.
SPEAKER_00Ross Robertson, who was a diving biologist at the University of Queensland and I, and a local member of a diving club who had an underwater camera, a good one. Tiny little boats that were pretty well uneconomic because they were so small. That was our fleet to go out and study Ellison Reef. You know, we we spent two or three weeks out on Ellison Reef in two little boats which were unseaworthy uh in calm waters, and it wasn't calm. So we got sloshed fit, but we showed that it was not, as the proponent of mine had claimed, a dead reef. It was a perfectly normal coral reef in which there were areas of large slushy sediments around, and there was some damn root reef uh around parts of Ellison that were far from dead.
SPEAKER_01There were 34 families of living hard corals containing 88 species, 34 families of molluscs containing 96 species, uh 45 families of fish containing 226 species were observed on Allison Reef during the limited observation period.
SPEAKER_00We showed it was a normal coral reef full of marine life and that it shouldn't be mined. Uh and it would set a precedent that was internationally undesirable considering the air reef is the largest system of coral reefs in the world. And if you can't manage the best system in the world, it's gonna happen to the rest of the world's coral reefs.
SPEAKER_02I know, right? Because who gets to decide how dead a reef has to be before you can can dig it up? Because all healthy reefs have some dead corals, but then they have the healthy corals as well.
SPEAKER_00That's the point. Uh cyclones do impact on them, even just big storm waves uh can slosh coral around and break off stag haunts. Um and that's how a lot of the sediments form and how the islands form even. So, you know, that's part of the natural system, but it it's a question of how much you can tamper with it before it starts having really detrimental effects. And mining was going to be one hell of a lot of tampering. Yeah. Catastrophic would be a a not inappropriate word.
SPEAKER_02Meanwhile, John Bust used his considerable communication and interpersonal skills to build political and public awareness about the Ellison Reef proposal. He wrote to the Premier, the Minister for Tourism, the Minister for Conservation, and the Queensland Tourist Bureau. He also wrote letters to newspapers generating widespread press coverage, and enlisted the help of his longtime friend, the Australian Prime Minister, Harold Holt. The two had gone to school together in Melbourne, and after being introduced by John to the beautiful reef and rainforests of far north Queensland, Holt bought a holiday home close to his place. John also spoke with friends in the sugarcane industry, and as it turned out, many of them were also opposed to the mining of the reef. The campaign was a huge success. In December 1967, everyone breathed a sigh of relief when the mining application for Ellison Reef was rejected. This landmark case set a precedent for not mining the reef and helped to boost public awareness and concern about the exploitation of the reef's resources. And that was to prove important because the battle was about to get a whole lot bigger. To hear what happened next, join us next episode for a dramatic retelling of the fight to save the Great Barrier Reef from oil drilling. If you'd like to learn more about the history of coral mining on the Great Barrier Reef, I highly recommend you check out the sources I've used for today's episode, which I've referenced in the show notes and episode description. There are several books on the topic and a very interesting James Cook University research paper which you can access online. If you'd like to support the Australian Marine Conservation Society and the work it's doing today to protect the reef, visit www.fightforourreef.org.au and get involved. If you're enjoying this podcast, please subscribe to this series and follow Word on the Reef on Instagram to get notified when it's time for our next adventure. This is a not-for-profit passion project, so if you enjoyed it, please write a review, share, and tell your friends. If you'd like to sponsor this podcast, please consider becoming a patron for as little as $5 a month over at patreon.com slash word on the reef podcast. You'll give a shout out, and the proceeds will help towards covering costs like podcast hosting, email hosting, editing software subscriptions, and so on. This week, I'd like to give a shout out to Gemma. Thanks, Gemma, for your support through our beautiful marine environment. That's all for now. Best fishers, and see you next time.