Word on the Reef
Diving into marine science and conservation on the Great Barrier Reef and beyond!
Word on the Reef
S1 E4: Breaking: Coral bleaching at Heron Island with Dr Stuart Kininmonth
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
The Marine Park Authority has confirmed severe coral bleaching is unfolding on the southern section of the Great Barrier Reef 🪸 So this week, we head to Heron Island to meet the island's chief scientist and see first-hand what's happening 🏝️.
-------
- SUPPORT THE SHOW: Become a supporter to connect with Tanya and Brett, get a shout-out on the show, ask us questions and suggest episode topics!
- Got questions? Email info@wordonthereef.com
- Follow @WordOnTheReefPodcast on Instagram
PROTECT THE REEF - Sign these Petitions Now!
- Australian Marine Conservation Society: Australia, it's time to lead on Climate Action!
- Divers for Climate: Sign the 'I'm a Diver for Climate' National Statement
- Australian Conservation Foundation: No New Coal and Gas!
- Queensland Conservation Council: Take Strong Climate Action and Build a Positive Renewable Future!
- Our Islands Our Home: Protect the Torres Strait Islands from Climate Change
- Greenpeace: Save the Great Barrier Reef!
- WWF Australia: Protect Nature
- Rising Ti...
Hello and welcome to Word on the Reef, a podcast where we take the plunge into one of the world's most spectacular natural wonders, the Great Barrier Reef. February is a really exciting time on the Great Barrier Reef because it's turtle hatching season. And seeing these tiny, adorable little baby turtles emerging from the sand is so fun. We're going to experience all the joy of turtle hatching in an episode soon. I've also recently recorded an exclusive interview with one of the reef's most influential First Nations conservationists to learn how indigenous knowledge can help us save the reef. There are so many inspiring and positive stories coming up on this series, and I can't wait to share them with you. However, I did promise that this series will keep you up to date on all the latest reef news. And this week, the breaking news is that, unfortunately, it has been confirmed that the Great Barrier Reef is experiencing quite a significant coral bleaching event. In a reef health update issued yesterday, the Marine Park Authority confirmed it has recorded minor to moderate bleaching on surveyed reefs across the Marine Park, and has also received reports of severe bleaching in the southern region, around reefs in the Keppel group of islands off the coast of Rockhampton and the Capricorn and Bunker groups of islands off the coast of Gladstone. Meanwhile, the water is continuing to warm with sea surface temperatures now up to two degrees above average across the marine park. Now, back in episode 2, we discussed how corals get their bright colours, what coral bleaching is, what it means, how different corals are affected differently by coral bleaching, what corals can do to survive and regenerate from coral bleaching, and what we can do to help protect them. All that background is going to be super helpful for understanding what's happening to the reef in today's episode. So if you haven't already, I highly recommend that you go back and listen to that episode first. But to sum up, basically, carbon pollution from the mining and burning of fossil fuels like coal, oil, and gas is heating up our planet and our oceans, causing more frequent and severe marine heat waves. Currently, a marine heat wave in the southern hemisphere is causing corals to become stressed and turn white, a phenomenon known as coral bleaching. There have already been four mass coral bleaching events in the past eight years, which is unprecedented and a sign that we need to cut global carbon emissions urgently in order to give corals a chance to recover. But don't just take my word for it. Today we're going to take a trip to beautiful Heron Island, part of a group of islands known as the Capricorn and Bunker Groups on the southern end of the Great Barrier Reef, where reports of severe bleaching have emerged. To get there, it's a four-hour flight south of Cairns or a one-hour flight north of Brisbane to the town of Gladstone. From there, we'll take a two-hour boat trip out to Heron Island. As we approach the island, you'll see a beautiful coral cave covered in lush green vegetation and fringed by white sand and a turquoise lagoon brimming with corals. We're approaching the island through a narrow channel in the reef. And if you look to your right now, you'll see a spectacular shipwreck sticking up out of the water, surrounded by schools of fish. Ahead of us, two majestic eagle rays with wingspans as white as your arms are gliding through the water. Each one is black with a sprinkling of white spots and resembles the night sky. The northwest corner of Heron Island is a luxurious resort. The southwest corner is a scientific research station run by the University of Queensland. And the entire east side of the island is a protected reserve covered with a forest of ancient posonia trees. Today we're going to take a seat on the beach, under a shady tree, overlooking the turquoise lagoon, where we can watch rays and humless reef sharks drifting lazily by. Here we are greeted by Dr. Stuart Kinninmont, who has been the manager of the Heron Island Research Station for four years. With a background in ecology, particularly coral reef ecology, Dr. Kinnin-Mont has decades of experience, including working for the Australian Institute of Marine Science, the CSIRO, which is Australia's National Scientific Research Agency, and internationally at the Stockholm Resilience Centre, the University of Oslo, and the University of the South Pacific in Fiji. Before we start our chat, I just want to acknowledge the traditional owners of the region we're visiting today: the Guren Gureng, Gurang, Bailai, and Talibalang Bunder peoples, and pay my respects to their elders, past, present, and emerging. Also, before we start our chat, I just want to quickly introduce some of the terms we'll be using. You'll hear Dr. Kininmont refer to Acropora, which is a type of branching corals, as well as porites, a sturdy type of coral which includes boulder corals. You'll also hear him referring to temperature loggers, which are a type of thermometer placed underwater to record water temperatures. And you'll hear us talking about NOAA. But we're not talking about biblical NOAA. We're talking about the NOAA, the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, a US-based agency charged with monitoring oceanic and atmospheric conditions across the globe. So now, without further ado, hello, Dr. Kinninmont. Lovely to be here with you today on beautiful Heron Island. How are you? Enjoy yourself. Yeah, good thanks. To start off with, what's your favorite spot to go diving or snorkeling on Heron Island?
SPEAKER_00Uh there's lots of fantastic spots, and they all have different attractions, but I really love what a spot called Lidby's Lair. Um and what I like about it is it's got a little a fair bit of variation in its geomorphology. In other words, there's lots of little canyons and little caves and little nooks and creddies. And so when you're diving and looking at it, you'll always find little sort of special things in each of those little hidden spots, and it can make uh for a very interesting dive.
SPEAKER_01Sounds amazing. One of my favorite spots was near the channel. Um so you're allowed to snorkel in the channel um at certain times a day when there's no boats. And we saw, I think, dozens of different types of rays, eagle rays. I've never seen so many rays in one spot. It was amazing and really beautiful coral as well. So it's an absolutely amazing place. But what's happening to the coral right now on Heron Island?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, it's right at the moment it's uh a bit upsetting. Make no mistake, it's not it's not a great sign to be watching the corals. The reason being is it's the water has been very warm this last month, and this warmth of the water has been stressing the corals because the algae that sits in their skin, which they farm to make sugar, that algae is very temperature sensitive. And so when the water gets too warm, then uh the algae essentially starts to break down, causes all sorts of issues. So the coral, one of the things it does is to offload the algae, which means that it's it's sort of getting rid of its production of sugar. And uh initially that's not really such a bad thing. Uh the coral has a bit of sugar stored and uh it's able to continue to live and to grow. But after uh only a couple of weeks, that runs out of sugar. And so unless the temperature changes, so it can bring back the algae and to regrow the farm, it's in a really big dilemma because it's run out of sugar and uh it will eventually die. Uh, and then the coral skeleton will be taken over by algae. Uh that's when you get the sort of the gregy reef that's not very healthy and uh will take quite a few years to recover.
SPEAKER_01So, what sort of coral bleaching extent are you seeing at Heron Island at the moment?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, that's the big problem. Sometimes we do see coral bleaching happening in just one or two small areas where the hot water's cooled. But uh this last week we did a we did a survey a week and a bit ago right around Heron Island, and we found extensive bleaching in the whole area. So all the reef flat and some of the reef crest is showing considerable signs of bleaching. Uh about 60% to 100% of colonies are affected. Uh in the deeper areas, it's not so bad. Um, we're getting down to 30% of colonies that are affected. And the bottom line is some colonies are very temperature sensitive, others are much more robust. So, this type of event will be having a major long-term effect on the species composition for Heron Island. And also with Stari and all the rest of the Capricorn bunker groups. And one of the reasons it's been so bad is that uh we really haven't had leaching here for quite a few years. We've we've escaped all those corals that have done really well here in the Capricorn group, they've flourished and they've grown really strongly. But this summer they've really been hit hard, and so consequently, you see a lot of corals that are badly damaged. Uh essentially our L coral here a month and a half ago was looking exceptionally good, even on a 60-year projection. It's one of the best that we've seen. And so it's very sad to see this event happening. We were expecting it to happen, and we've actually had meetings late last year to get ready for this exact event.
SPEAKER_01When people hear about coral bleaching on the Great Barrier Reef, they often tend to just lump the whole Great Barrier Reef in together and assume it's all the same. But how important is it for people to recognize that the reef is really vast and this bleaching is in a specific place and different places are affected differently?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, look, it's really important because a lot of people do lump the entire barrier reef as a single thing, and they also lump corals as being a single thing. I guess we're so used to thinking about, say, the plight of rhinoceros or something like that. Um but uh for corals, we've got about roughly 750 species. For here on Herod Island, the species number would be about 450. And across those 450, there's incredible variation in the lifestyle and the form and the structural form, and also where they live. So in some places they they're gonna live in a spot which is nicely uh sheltered from the bleaching because the water flows through nice and quickly, like Pam's point. But other places the hot water will flow off the the shallow reef and it'll form a waterfall if you can imagine it. So the hot water then flows down into these deeper areas and uh does enormous amounts of damage. And so the corals there have to be very tough. And one thing people need to understand is that you know the diversity of the corals is critical to the long-term sustainability because there will be winners and there will be losers. And uh how it reassembles itself after all of these stresses is one of the great big questions of of our time.
SPEAKER_01Is there any way to predict how many of them will be winners and how many will be losers?
SPEAKER_00Well, well, we look we can certainly say that there are a number of species that really seem to be very vulnerable. And I guess you could then say, well, those ones are gonna be the losers. Some of the parieties are doing okay, and some of them will continue to be the winners.
SPEAKER_01That's boulder corals for any listeners that don't know what they're doing.
SPEAKER_00But they do have a more solid form. But there's a number of other species which seem to be better adapted for heat tolerance. Um, but some of the fast-growing corals that you would have seen in your channel swim, uh, that's the acroperas, um, particularly the fast growing ones, they really struggle. And it's because, you know, I kind of like to think of it like the three piggies. The cropperas make a sort of straw house and a very very weak structure. It's quick to make, but it's very vulnerable to these stresses. Whereas a parades make a brickhouse and it's slow growing, but it it's a bit tougher. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So you said that this bleaching was predicted, but is it more or less severe than predicted, or is it the same as predicted?
SPEAKER_00It's a really, really good question because uh the answer is yes and a little bit. So the first of all, NOAA have a website which you can go on to. It's called uh Coral Watch, the American one, which Australia has to be very active in participating uh with verification of this website. Um but the critical thing is uh the NAWA uses uh long-term predictions on the sea surface temperature using satellite information. This then provides the context for how that stress can manifest during the summer. The trouble is you only have to have a cyclone or you have to have some some change in weather event can rapidly change the prediction. So at one level, we would be expecting the bleaching to happen, but exactly how much it's going to manifest will depend on the weather patterns happening in January and also a bit of early February. So we were hoping with that cyclone recently that we get a lot more mixing. We got some mixing, but our temperature we have a temperature a little loggers around the place. They're showing mixing, but it's not as um strong as we would like. Uh so for instance, for those listeners who haven't been to Heron Island, you may not be aware, but in there for the Capricorns, uh, we're strongly influenced by what's called the Capricorn Eddy. And it's a big rotating mass of cold water that sits to the south of us here. And that cold water is able to uh to help cool down the areas and and basically um allow the corals to flourish where they may not previously be so cultible.
SPEAKER_01Thanks, Eddie.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, thanks, Eddie, exactly.
SPEAKER_01Eddie's doing a good job. So for any listeners that are interested in seeing those um coral bleaching coral watch predictions, NOAA has a great coral watch website where you can actually see maps predicting the heat stress across the whole world's oceans, and you can zoom in on the Great Barrier Reef, and the colours are darker for more serious heat stress, and looking at it over the past couple of weeks, it's been really dark purple on the southern part of the Great Barrier Reef around Heron Island, so that was a bit concerning to see. So looking at the forecasts, what do you think is going to happen over the next few weeks or months?
SPEAKER_00Well, I looked at the temperature logger yesterday, and the pattern is that it's uh has cooled down a little bit. That's partly because we've got a fairly nice, steady southeasterly wind, which is pulling in a bit of cold air from well, down south. Now it's relatively cold air, it's not cold. But um what that's doing is that it's slowly taking away some of that heat for us anyway. So if it all goes well, the temperature will come down a bit. Um but if that wind starts to ease off, then uh the heat will build up again because of the sun coming through very uh very open skies at the moment. It's not a lot of cloud around or anything. So that means we're gonna see a lot of heating in the water and potentially the bleaching will continue. If it continues, then the corals will eventually start to give up in terms of not being able to continue with their growth. And we'll have to wait a year or two before some of those areas can get colonized again, which would be sad because we'd we'd have a drop in the percentage coral cover for some of the areas, uh, which is a real bidding.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, well, we'll all have our fingers crossed that the the cool winds keep blowing for you. But I guess, you know, we shouldn't have to be relying on luck of the conditions at the time or some clouds or some wind. The long-term solution to prevent these heat waves from affecting the corals is to do with climate action, is that right? What do you think is is the most efficient?
SPEAKER_00Absolutely, yeah. Look, there's there's very little you can do at a local scale. Yeah, like that's a lot of people think that there must be some engineering solution, uh, tarps, seeding the atmosphere, etc. That's just rubbish. But the bottom line is the reefs are so extensive, so complicated, and um the only thing that can be done is to dramatically reduce the carbon dioxide and methane being put into the air, um, because that's the only thing that's gonna stop the parts per million of these gases from increasing. And the science is very, very clear that while we are increasing the parts per million of carbon dioxide and methane, uh, we are just gonna have to expect more and more warming events. Okay. It's a very simple chemistry that's been known about for 150 years, and the corals are really sending us a very, very clear message to Emodity that uh we're getting close to overstepping the mark. And if we don't do something very soon, then it really won't matter what we do.
SPEAKER_01What are scientists on the island doing as the bleaching unfolds? Are there any ways they can make the most of this event to learn more about how corals respond to bleaching? Or is the bleaching interrupting the research on the island?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, really good. Good point. We had some researchers from New Zealand who were looking at the physiology of coral, and they actually had all the coral laws set up in their tanks with heaters. They are here for several months, I should add. The bleaching event came along and suddenly the water was starting to get quite warm, and uh they didn't need to use the heaters anymore because they actually had themselves uh natural bleaching events that they could then use as part of their experimental profile. So uh what they're doing is they're monitoring how a coral changes some of its chemistry, and they've got a number of samples which they're able to take some of the tissue samples from, and they can then process this in a way which allows them to make comments about how the whole bleaching affects the entire way the coral processes its metabolic activity. Uh, interesting enough, one of the um things about it is we had to uh get in extra liquid nitrogen because we have to ship the samples in liquid nitrogen to a chemistry laboratory that can do this uh fairly fancy analysis. So uh it's one of the uh interesting parts of working out of the barrier reef is having these um two big tubs of liquid nitrogen that can store the samples.
SPEAKER_01So what can we learn from this bleaching event at Heron Island and what can we do about it?
SPEAKER_00Well, I think the first thing to learn is that you know, while bleaching is is sort of part and parcel of the marine environment, these extra hot events, particularly these marine heat waves, are just coming in too often. And so this is really strong evidence that the predictions we were making 10, 20 years ago are right. It's not some wild scientific theory. It's based on really solid evidence, and we're now starting to see this in the coral profiles, and we're starting to see this in the coral community composition. Uh, and if we're not careful, we'll start to see this flowing onto every other ecosystem that we are so strongly reliant on. Some corals will be probably pushed locally extinct and maybe even regionally. Uh, but many other species on the terrestrial side of things are really really in a tough position because we've put all these roads and we've blocked migration. Um so these are species that will go extinct. And we do run a very big risk uh that the even for the global system that we end up with these cascade of tipping points where when one system starts to collapse, leads to collapse of another and another and another. And before we know it, the world that we used to think was so gorgeous becomes this uh horrifying mess where we're trying to reassemble how we're living on this planet. And the corals are sending us a very clear message get your act together, or you're gonna be in deep trouble. You know, there's never been a better time to get that message.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. I've heard it said that the earth doesn't need humans, but humans need the earth. So, you know, in millions and millions of years, corals may regenerate and re evolve, but humans right now, sixty-four thousand humans depend on the Great Barrier Reef for employment. People depend on the Great Barrier Reef because of the, you know, the wonder and the the beauty and the inspiration that it gives us. So So right now the corals are giving us a message to take action. So speaking of action, if there are listeners who want to do something to help protect coral reefs, even if they don't get to go and visit coral reefs all the time like you and me do, what are some things they can do?
SPEAKER_00There are certainly ways you can be involved in citizen science along the coast. And there's plenty of online ways to via videos or find some way to engage. I would strongly recommend any listener to engage with their politicians and find out where the stress points are. In other words, awesome. Awesome. Very clearly. Most politicians I've met, apart from the small rat bag mobs, most politicians are very keen to make a difference, but they struggle against a system that is heavily geared towards a carbon economy. So, you know, ask your local politician how can you help with what they want to do? And you will find they will be very keen to offer suggestions about things that can be done. And there's a whole range of environmental initiatives at a local scale, right through to national scale. But uh in terms of visiting the reef, yeah, I mean I obviously I strongly encourage anyone to see it because it is a most marvelous situation where you can hop into a water and see just this amazing uh life forms that are just floating around in front of you, from the rays to the turtles, the sharks, the fish, all the corals. And you can see it so easily. You know, this you don't have to uh spend days with binoculars trying to see some sort of rare bird or anything. It's just gonna be out there with you. And so it's a great environment. In terms of protection, uh, we obviously do need to worry about things like fish. And uh one of the things every listener should be thinking about is their diets, whether they need to be continuing, you know, as a heavy meat eater or perhaps switching to a more planet-friendly diets and also health-oriented diets. Certainly, virtually all my staff here aren't it's something that is going to be a big question for most people is is how can they make an individual difference there? And there's there's some advice about how you can make your own personal changes, which will uh definitely help.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you raised so many really good points there. I really liked the one about asking your local politician what you can do, because if we build awareness and show that most Australians want strong environmental policies, then the politicians will be able to respond to that. Also, yeah, I really liked how you talked about how important it is for tourists to come and continue visiting the reef because it's a really good way to learn about it. Maybe you might have an opportunity to help out with a survey or some citizen science during your visit. And yeah, I personally highly recommend Heron Island. Um, some of the benefits of visiting the Great Barrier Reef on an island is that you've got these beautiful sunny beaches to lay on in between your in between your snorkeling. And coral bleaching or not, there's still so many other things to see in the water, like the rays, the sharks, the turtles and things like that, right?
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. Oh, look, I guess from a coral reef ecology point of view, that's where we worry about. But from a point of view of seeing how wonderful the marine life is, it'll always be amazing. And so from a tourism point of view, you do come and visit it, you'll always be delighted.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, absolutely. And I understand there's also baby turtles hatching on the beaches of Heron Islands right now.
SPEAKER_00So Yeah, we have lots of laying turtles, and um it's just fantastic to see them climbing on the bench. And then of course these baby turtles, they're the by far the cutest animal that exists. Big black eyes with their big smile and little clippers, and you know, they they just delight everybody that sees them.
SPEAKER_01So it's it's magic. I've seen some videos of the hatching turtles on Heron Island on social media, and it's just the cutest thing ever. So I'm sure every every tourist at the resort is still having an absolutely amazing time out there. But like you said, for us to go and enjoy something because it's so beautiful doesn't mean that there's no threat, because there is obviously really a threat as well that you've talked about a lot. So, Dr. Stuart Keninmont, lovely to chat with you today here on beautiful Heron Island. Thank you so much for your time. Is there anything else you'd like to say before we go?
SPEAKER_00Just that uh we hope the the cool winds do come through, and uh then hopefully of course we don't get a cyclone later as well. Because I'll be in calmness after this event would be really much needed.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, we'll all be keeping our fingers crossed and um keeping an eye out to see what happens at Heron Island over the next few weeks. Thank you very much.
SPEAKER_00Wonderful to talk to you, Tonya.
SPEAKER_01I hope you enjoyed our trip to Heron Island today. If you want to keep an eye on the latest coral bleaching forecast maps, visit Coral Reefwatch.noa.gov. If you'd like to get involved in action to help protect the Great Barrier Reef, visit www.fightforarreef.org.au. If you're enjoying this podcast, please subscribe to this series and follow WordOnThe Reef on Instagram to get notified when it's time for our next adventure. This is a not-for-profit passion project, so if you enjoyed it, please write a review, share, and tell your friends. If you'd like to sponsor this podcast, please consider becoming a patron for as little as $5 a month over at patreon.com slash WordOnTheRef Podcast. You'll get a shout-out, and the proceeds will help towards covering costs like podcast hosting, email hosting, website hosting, and so on. This week I'd like to give a shout out to Emily. Thanks Emily for your support for our beautiful marine environment. That's all for now. Best fishes, and see you next time.